Mexico City to Use Books to Lower Crime

Status
Not open for further replies.

MicroBalrog

member
Joined
Dec 25, 2002
Messages
2,896
Location
The State of Israel - aka Gun Nut Hell
Mexico City to Use Books to Lower Crime
Fri Jan 23, 5:27 AM ET

By MORGAN LEE, Associated Press Writer

MEXICO CITY - Mexico City's subway will begin lending books to riders Friday in a new program aimed at reducing crime and fostering a more hospitable atmosphere for millions of commuters.



The city plans to distribute 7 million paperbacks in the next two years and hopes that people will return the books when they are finished — turning the Metro into a kind of lending library as an unorthodox way of helping to reduce crime.


"We are convinced that when people read, people change," said Javier Gonzalez Garza, the director of the Metro.


The idea emerged from discussions of ways to cut the sky-high crime rate in Mexico's capital, a city of some 8.5 million people.


Some have doubts about the program's value as an anti-crime tool.


"Now we'll have an equal number of delinquents, but well-educated," said Omar Raul Martinez, the director of a book and magazine publishing firm.


Mexico City's subway has adopted other measures to improve the commute, including installing art exhibits in stations and requiring men and women to ride separate cars at rush hour to prevent fondling and other forms of sexual harassment.


Robbery and pickpocketing remain common on the vast Metro system, which carries 4.7 million people a day across the capital for less than 20 cents a ride.


Authorities in Mexico are considering a number of measures to reduce crime in the city, but Gonzalez said the Metro decided to address the issue from "the cultural side."


The administration of Mayor Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador, a potential presidential candidate in 2006, also may have voters in mind as it lends out books to the city's poorer residents, who are more likely to use the Metro than wealthier Mexicans.


The subway program comes amid a national push to increase literacy, with President Vicente Fox (news - web sites) planning an expansion of the national library system and increased spending on textbooks.


Mexico has an official literacy rate above 90 percent, but many people do not read on a daily, in part because many are too poor to buy books.


Organizers of the book project hope to create 500,000 new readers. A private company that controls the subway's advertising concession will pay for most of the books.


The city has commissioned 250,000 copies of a book containing accounts of Mexico City life in prose, poetry and works of theater — with passages short enough to read during a subway ride.


The opening piece by Carlos Monsivais, one of Mexico's most prominent writers, recounts the aftermath of a devastating earthquake in 1985, when people rallied to organize rescue crews and help victims.


"It could have some effect if it convinces people that without organization, without solidarity you cannot confront the immense urban and ecological catastrophe that is Mexico City," said Monsivais, who accepted a "symbolic" payment of $300 for use of his work.


Monsivais, a regular Metro rider, said he had faith the books will be put to good use.





"Those that don't (return them) will lend them to other people," he said.
 
Ummm....

I would expect this kind of stupidity in New York or LA, but Mexico City?

This is one of the stupidest ideas I have ever heard. If given the choice between mugging some old lady or sitting down and reading Harry Potter, 99.9% of criminals will choose mugging.
 
People who are free are happy. If I want to read a book, let me choose the book.

Those books did not appear out of thin air. The government confiscated money from someone to buy the books. At best, the "poor" riding the subway funded the books. I would be happier if the gov. left the money in my pocket and I was free to make a choice. At worst, the "rich" paid for the books, and they do not benefit if they do not ride the subway: income redistribution.

As stated before, the intent is to improve literacy in order to reduce crime. The criminals are not going to be reading: this is not an ABC after school special about morals. The readers are usually the victims of the crime. I guess it is better to steal from the victim, buy them a book, and then they will not think about being mugged by the gov. or the criminal.
 
The government confiscated money from someone to buy the books

WRONG!!!

A private company that controls the subway's advertising concession will pay for most of the books.


The criminals are not going to be reading: this is not an ABC after school special about morals

Not every criminal is born a criminal. Yeah, many are born thugs, but not all (especially in a place such as Mexico).
 
The city plans to distribute 7 million paperbacks in the next two years and hopes that people will return the books when they are finished — turning the Metro into a kind of lending library as an unorthodox way of helping to reduce crime.

Mexico City's subway has adopted other measures to improve the commute, including installing art exhibits in stations and requiring men and women to ride separate cars at rush hour to prevent fondling and other forms of sexual harassment.

The administration of Mayor Andres Manuel Lopez Obrador, a potential presidential candidate in 2006, also may have voters in mind as it lends out books to the city's poorer residents, who are more likely to use the Metro than wealthier Mexicans.

The subway program comes amid a national push to increase literacy, with President Vicente Fox (news - web sites) planning an expansion of the national library system and increased spending on textbooks.

The city has commissioned 250,000 copies of a book containing accounts of Mexico City life in prose, poetry and works of theater — with passages short enough to read during a subway ride.

But

A private company that controls the subway's advertising concession will pay for most of the books.

So, just who is driving this train?

The City
The City Subway
The Mayor
President Vicente Fox

and who is paying for it

A private concessionnaire

You think the payment was voluntary? I know, it is hard to believe that the Mexican government would strongarm the vendor into paying for it. And I am sure the vendor is doing it for the betterment of society. I wonder how much he must raise his prices to pay for this? How many possible layoffs are in the future when the concession sales slow. Or, to put it another way, the dead hand of government at work.

The commitment of the resource is by government. There is no free lunch.
 
I really dont see the harm in this. It doesnt look like its going to cost anything. And heck it might actually work. I dont think its been tried in the past so at least its a new approach.
 
You think the payment was voluntary?

Why not?


And I am sure the vendor is doing it for the betterment of society. I wonder how much he must raise his prices to pay for this? How many possible layoffs are in the future when the concession sales slow. Or, to put it another way, the dead hand of government at work.

Or capitalism, we don't know enough.:D
 
It seems quite likely to me considering that an ADVERTISING firm is footing the bill that it was either part of their existing advertising contract or that they are using the reading material as another means of distributing advertisement as well. As micro says, capitalism in action.
 
Mexico City to Use Books to Lower Crime

Bet I know which books....

0899333206.jpg


0679746676.01.LZZZZZZZ.jpg

book3.gif


:banghead: :banghead: :banghead:
 
NOTE: Why do you think this won't work?
The real question is: why do the Mexicans think it will work? Since at least the 1960s, in the U.S. and Europe, there have been tons of similar efforts to reduce crime that failed -- this is just a variation on the "community center" fad of the 1970s or the "midnight basketball" fad of the 1990s.

But hey, if it's a private company using private funds, more power to them -- I think privately-run charity libraries are great. However, the sponsors should be realistic about the benefits.

In any event, if access to free books were an answer to crime, then there would be very little crime in U.S. cities, many of which have some of the best and biggest library systems in the world.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top