My AD story please read

Status
Not open for further replies.

realmswalker

Member
Joined
Feb 11, 2003
Messages
415
I haven't ever talked about it here, or on any forum but I recently had a discharge in my house.

Scenario goes like this. I have a 1911 giving me feeding issues, so I do a little polishing and a real good cleaning and I load up a couple rounds in the mag to see if the gun will chamber a round upon release of the slide lock, it was jamming every time.

I had previously taken this gun to the range on two other occasions and fired about 300 rounds through it, but it jammed like crazy and was pissing me off.

I had dropped the slide on about 5 live rounds within a matter of 10 minutes looking for where it was jamming and what was going with the gun. I had done this a number of other times on a couple of other occasions with the gun pointed in what I thought was a safe direction.

This was a very clean gun, didn't look fired very much at all, so I though it was something small or a break in period. I had purchased it in a trade.

What happened next will always haunt me and to this day I have no idea how I got so lucky in a very unlucky incident.

I live in a apartment complex. The direction I had the gun pointed at was a connection wall to another apartment.

I was sitting on the floor crosslegged, my girlfriend was at the computer about 10 feet to my left. I pointed the gun at the floor and dropped the slide. I absolutely made 100% sure my finger was off the trigger. BOOM!

I was in absolute shock. The gun surprised the living hell out of me. Luckily There was only 1 round in the magazine or it could have been ugly, I will say why later in the post.

My GF turns around and says "Oh babe are you OK"? I said yea through the ringing in my ears. I had just had an AD. I know people here say AD and ND are the same but in my case I don't believe so.

The bullet, a 230 grain FMJ round nose .45 with 5.3 grains of red dot behind it entered the carpet at a 45 degree angle. It hit the concrete slab and Thank god stayed underneath the carpet and traveled about 18 inches. It stopped underneath the carpet bunched up in a mound of padding. If the gun had been pointed at any other angle this would have been so much worse.

I later dug this bullet out, in two large fragments and 1 small. I think I only got half the bullet, the other half is still somewhere in that carpet because I searched every inch of every wall and coffee table, and anything else the bullet might have gone into and there was NO sign of a hole or any impact.

I keep these bullets as a reminder of the stupidity of what I had done. I did not press the trigger, i was so sure but there was a little doubt in my mind. The only thing that could have happened was the dreaded hammer follow.

A few days later I loaded up some dummy rounds, no primer no powder, just the bullet and brass and load them up in the gun. The second time I inserted a mag and dropped the slide, Bingo, Hammer follow.

Thats why I said earlier I was so lucky there was only 1 round in the mag at the time of discharge, I can't imagine what would have happened if it went full auto because of hammer follow on a 10 round mag.

I took the gun to a gunsmith and he told me that someone had attempted a trigger job on this gun and someone had jacked it up pretty bad. The sear was toast and had to be replace, the hammer was barely able to be saved.

When he called me and told me this I was so relieved because there was a small doubt in my mind that said "you had your finger on the trigger dummy" even though I proved it with my dummy round test that I did not.

Now for the Things I learned portion of my , STUPID STUPID STUPID MISTAKE.

1. DO NOT test out your reloads to see if they chamber on a slide drop, EVER EVER EVER except for at the range. I should have known this already Make some dummy rounds first. I have been shooting for 10 years, I have never had anything like this happed and I got confident in the safety system on my guns. I was so wrong and it almost cost me dearly. I have tested the feeding of live rounds in my m1 garand, ar, glock etc in my house. Never will I do it again except for at the range

2. 45 acp in a confined space is loud, but not as deafening as I thought. My ears rang for an hour but I have no discernible hearing loss.

3. Do not put 100% confidence in your guns, they are machines and they can fail. I have a USPF 45 that I use for home defense and I cannot bring myself to drop the slide in a normal fashion to load it since the AD. I let it slowly forward and chamber. Even this still makes me a little nervous, but I think that will pass with time. I encourage other people to load their semi auto home defense guns in this manner.

4. I made a horrible mistake by using live ammo to test the function of my gun. If this AD hadnt happened I would probably be doing this horrible practice still to this day. But I had confidence in my guns, a very misguided confidence.

This is very very hard for me to admit and write about, writing about it now gets my heart rate up. Like I said so many things were lucky about where the bullet went on such an stupid unlucky incident.

I know some of you here will tell me "it was bound to happen sooner or later with what your were doing" or as simple as "your'e a F^%* idiot" and you would be right on both occasions. But no amount of what is said about me here can be 1 100th of how hard I have been on myself, so please let it fly. I only ask one thing please learn from my mistake.
 
Scary stuff, thanks for sharing. I'm sure it's hard to do.

I carried a 1911 for a long time, and loading in the house always scared me.

I had a welder buddy make something like this, but for a couple of hundred dollars you can buy pre-made traps.

If you do a lot of chambering of live rounds, it's something to think about.

Really glad that nothing was really hurt but your ego. Those heal :)

Mini-Check-It.jpg
 
I had damn near the exact same thing happen to me back when I first got into guns... cept mine was a Ruger p89 and it wasn't feeding 9mm correctly.

I ended up accidentally shooting my old wooden dresser and driving a round into the concrete under the carpet. I didn't touch my guns for months. I was incredibly hard on myself. It took me a long time to talk to anyone about it (except my parents... they were in the next room). I sold that p89 soon after that event.

It was MY fault, but i'm alot safer now than I was.

Like you said, it was a horrible mistake on my part and the only time my guns are loaded at home is to load them for defense. No more "test" chambering, no "just seein how it works", none of that.

I'm glad you're okay and that you learned from it.
 
Could have been a lot worse.

Look at it this way. You followed all four rules, and you have demonstrated that there is a reason there are four. Everyone still has their fingers and brains intact.

I tell people that if they have a ND/AD, it's because they broke AT LEAST one of the rules. The odds of mechanical failure are so remote, I don't even think about them. Doesn't mean it's impossible.

I would replace ALL of the hammer and trigger group.
 
RW, glad you're okay and nobody else was hurt.

I was shooting alone one time, and AD'd into the fender of my truck. Maaaaan, did I feel stupid. Within an hour I had it pounded out, filled, and the second coat of primer on (I worked for a body shop at the time). Never told anybody for about 5 years.

Parker
 
Well, I too have heard and about 99% believed that there were no accidental discharges, only negligent discharges. Actually, thinking while I am writing, I would say that what happened to you is 100% negligent discharge. 100% negligence on the part of whoever messed with the trigger without knowing what they were doing and then selling the gun, probably knowing how messed it up was.

I have done exactly what you have, checked a jamming gun with live ammo at home. Mine happened to be a brand new out of the box handgun that jammed the first time we were shooting it at the range, but, in hindsight, not a smart thing to do, especially since, like you, I reload and it would be easy to make up dummy rounds to do everything I needed to do.

Don't beat yourself up over this one, that is for sure. You obviously had the gun pointed in a safe direction, it was a gun someone had previously messed up and now you know what a .45 will be like if you should ever have to fire it for real inside the home.
 
The gun is at the gunsmith right now. I told him "no matter what you do, make this gun safe above all else please".
 
I think everyone should have one of these... ESPECIALLY if you have a decocker on your gun or end up needing to put the hammer down on a live round...

http://www.safedirection.com/

When I buy a used gun, I usually take it to my gun smith and have him give it the complete take down and once over. Usually costs a few $$ ($50) but if there is an obvious not so obvious problem, he spots it right then.
 
When I packed a 1911 I was in the habit of unloading the chamber each evening, putting the same round back in the next morning and dropping the slide on it. After several months the gun discharged when I gently lowered the hammer on a loaded chamber. The hammer did not slip, it was gently lowered and the gun went off.

I have since learned that primers can become sensitized through repeated slamming of the round into the chamber, making them unstable and likely to fire with little provocation.
 
mljdeckard: "The odds of mechanical failure are so remote, I don't even think about them."

Start thinking; they happen all the time.

It's why I never chamber a live round in a semi-automatic weapon, or cock the hammer on a loaded non-semi-automatic, unless I'm ready to fire. Even on concealed carry I normally carry without a round in chamber.

It's also why I will not carry a striker-fired pistol, except very rarely my Ortgies .32ACP.

I won't split hairs on AD versus ND. I use "UD" -- for Unintended Discharge. I've had one.
 
I think everyone should have one of these... ESPECIALLY if you have a decocker on your gun or end up needing to put the hammer down on a live round...


THAT is fantastic, and much better than the 20 pound steel bullet trap I have next to my reloading bench.

Never seen that before, thanks for posting it.
 
Great story.

I'll quit dropping that slide today. Just started getting into that habit recently.

Slam magazine, release slide lock and it drops ready to go. no more of that sillyness.
 
Last edited:
Thank you for telling your story, and also for telling how the problem could have been avoided. Stories of problems and solutions like yours have so far saved me from having any AD problems of my own at home.

Off topic but oddly related, when a kindly stranger lets you shoot their black powder cap and ball revolver at the range, they may not mention that it has a trigger which can be set off by the motions of two flies landing on that trigger to have a good time. So don't even bother putting your finger into the trigger guard till the sights are line up on the target.
 
Sounds like you did alright, I read your story but let me see if I got this right as I am confused Slide back, put in mag, close slide (finger not on trigger), bang,

Yeah I have gotten into the habit of actually bracing when I first dry fire the gun, even though I just cleared it.

Good to hear no one got hurt though.
 
.
Thanks for your story. Flying magazine has a monthly column called "What I Learned About Flying From That". Basically, private and commercial pilots write in describing how they inadvertently tried to kill themselves in the air - and what they learned. Other pilots read and think about these experiences. Exactly what you did with your story. There've been more than one letter describing how an article saved a pilot from making the same dumb mistake.

I've had an ND at a range. Thank St. Cooper that I was observing his other 3 commandments when I unthinkingly fondled the trigger. No harm, no foul - just had to buy the beer that night. But I make DAMN sure I don't do that again!
 
IMHO there is nothing to be learned from feeding live rounds into the chamber when you don't intend to fire, or holster the gun for carry, that is worth the risk.

If you must do this, make up dummy rounds or at least remove the firing pin!

I had a hammer follow AD at the range once, and a hang fire once, that's why the four rules must always be adhered to, no exceptions!

--wally.
 
I have since learned that primers can become sensitized through repeated slamming of the round into the chamber, making them unstable and likely to fire with little provocation.

Not only that, but the bullet gets slightly deformed each time it's loaded and jammed further into the brass. Given enough time, it can seat way down and cause much larger pressures when fired.

Why do people seem to refuse to use snap caps? It's obvious that they are dummy ammo vs. making up dummy rounds (unless you paint them or drill holes in the side).
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top