gbran
Member
My longtime female freind and collegue met me here in CA for business purposes recently. She is a single widow with 2 pre-teen children. She is also a lawyer. During dinner the other nite, she voiced her concern that SCOTUS would probably rule RKBA to be an individual right and then kill DC's gun ban. Her concern is that DC will now have no way to keep guns out of the District.
I told her DC didn't have a gun problem, they had a people problem in that too large a percentage of the population was prone to violence. We then had the following exchange (shortened and paraphrased);
Me: Sarah, if I gave you a handgun to take home with you, would you use it to purposely maim or kill someone?
Sarah; Of course not!
Me; Now imagine some nite, you awaken to your door being kicked in and you take this handgun to your kids room to find a very large man with a machette raised above your kid......... do you shoot him?
Sarah; Yes, but these questions seem unfair.
Me; Now try to imagine the same scene with a law that prohibits you from having that gun for defense.
I summarized by telling her it appeared that giving law abiding people guns wouldn't turn them into violent criminals and that allowing them might actually save them. I also pointed out that there are lots of cities that don't have DC's crime rates without any serious gun control laws. She didn't like the way the exchange went, but she'll go home and see the light. She did say that she would never have a gun, but would trust herself is she did, but thet didn't mean she would trust others in her community to own guns.
Hey..........I gave it my best shot.
I told her DC didn't have a gun problem, they had a people problem in that too large a percentage of the population was prone to violence. We then had the following exchange (shortened and paraphrased);
Me: Sarah, if I gave you a handgun to take home with you, would you use it to purposely maim or kill someone?
Sarah; Of course not!
Me; Now imagine some nite, you awaken to your door being kicked in and you take this handgun to your kids room to find a very large man with a machette raised above your kid......... do you shoot him?
Sarah; Yes, but these questions seem unfair.
Me; Now try to imagine the same scene with a law that prohibits you from having that gun for defense.
I summarized by telling her it appeared that giving law abiding people guns wouldn't turn them into violent criminals and that allowing them might actually save them. I also pointed out that there are lots of cities that don't have DC's crime rates without any serious gun control laws. She didn't like the way the exchange went, but she'll go home and see the light. She did say that she would never have a gun, but would trust herself is she did, but thet didn't mean she would trust others in her community to own guns.
Hey..........I gave it my best shot.