Okay, this isn't so much an X vs Y thread as it is just trying to shorten a list. I and my brother want to get into casual steel matches - a run-what-you-brung sort of thing, no classifications. Since we don't CCW there's no issue with size or weight. We want to find a fun and accurate 9mm to keep down ammo cost for casual competition events. Lastly, being in CA means 10-rds only, so no point in frames other than single stack just for reasons of capacity.
Because we are in CA most of these are not approved, but due to the Single-Shot Exemption we can legally get any one we want. It does mean however that it's impossible to do the recommended "try them out at the range and see what you like." So we've been doing tons of reading and are having trouble cutting down the list any further, so I'm opening myself up for comment, scorn, ridicule, mockery, whatever you've got.
The budget is $1600 tops, and we both prefer new pistols to avoid someone's problem case. Neither of us plan to have any extra work done on these so no fair saying that "pistol X is great but only if Y and Z are done to it." The idea is to buy one nice enough that it works great right out of the box as-is.
So here's the current list:
I'm currently torn between the STI and SIG, and my brother is after a 6" barrel, yet neither of us can quite dismiss any of these on the list. We have nothing against 1911s, but admit to being a little wary of what we read about how they seem to have issues with 9mm, seemingly more so than other designs. And lastly, we admit that the list is somewhat sensitive to looks; the all-black tactical-look isn't attractive to us, which is why there aren't any Glocks on the list!
Because we are in CA most of these are not approved, but due to the Single-Shot Exemption we can legally get any one we want. It does mean however that it's impossible to do the recommended "try them out at the range and see what you like." So we've been doing tons of reading and are having trouble cutting down the list any further, so I'm opening myself up for comment, scorn, ridicule, mockery, whatever you've got.
The budget is $1600 tops, and we both prefer new pistols to avoid someone's problem case. Neither of us plan to have any extra work done on these so no fair saying that "pistol X is great but only if Y and Z are done to it." The idea is to buy one nice enough that it works great right out of the box as-is.
So here's the current list:
CZ75 SP-01 and variants (the Shadow Target looks really nice, http://www.cz-usa.com/products/view/CZ_75_SP01_Shadow/)
SIG P226 X-Five Competition (http://www.sigsauer.com/CatalogProductDetails/p226-x-five-competition.aspx)
STI Trojan, stock
STI Trojan + Brazos or Dawson pkg (such as http://www.dawsonprecision.com/ProductDetail.jsp?LISTID=80001322-1326301295)
STI TargetMaster, 6" barrel
S&W SW1911 Pro
Dan Wesson Pointman 9
SIG P226 X-Five Competition (http://www.sigsauer.com/CatalogProductDetails/p226-x-five-competition.aspx)
STI Trojan, stock
STI Trojan + Brazos or Dawson pkg (such as http://www.dawsonprecision.com/ProductDetail.jsp?LISTID=80001322-1326301295)
STI TargetMaster, 6" barrel
S&W SW1911 Pro
Dan Wesson Pointman 9
I'm currently torn between the STI and SIG, and my brother is after a 6" barrel, yet neither of us can quite dismiss any of these on the list. We have nothing against 1911s, but admit to being a little wary of what we read about how they seem to have issues with 9mm, seemingly more so than other designs. And lastly, we admit that the list is somewhat sensitive to looks; the all-black tactical-look isn't attractive to us, which is why there aren't any Glocks on the list!
Last edited: