People. Please remember, we are talking about PGOs. Pistol Grip Only. I'll repeat: Pistol Grip ONLY. As in, a shotgun, with a pistol grip, and nothing that extends to the shoulder.
A fully-stocked shotgun with a pistol grip is a whole different animal. Personally, I like the traditional stock for a scattergun, but I would never cast a PG-equipped fully stocked shotgun into the same category as a PGO. Some people might shoot traditional stocked guns better, some might shoot full stocks with pistol grips better, and ultimately the differences are debatable.
The scorn heaped in this thread are on PG-only guns.
Mike