I've never had an issue in working up regular cast loads from powder puff to full magnum loads that did not shoot clean and accurate, so I never really understood this new trend of powder coating. I know some guys have had issues with cast in some semi-autos, but the idea of powder coating for a revolver blows my mind. If it works for you, then have at it, but for me its always been a solution for a problem that I never had.
As I do work with powder coated metals in my occupation, I can't help but have concerns about how hard powder coat is. Harder than some of the metals we put it on. Certainly harder than the cast bullets, which is its attraction, but seems to be a lot harder than copper jackets as well. I'd be very interested in long term barrel wear studies with powder coat.
I had some concerns early on about powder coating and barrel wear also. Frankly, there isn't a lot of real data out there about the subject and most of what is available is anecdotal at best.... So I will pile on
Here on THR there are a few members from Australia where they have been doing this for several years. They are not allowed to use uncoated lead anymore there so started doing this as an alternative. None of them have reported any issues.
In spite of that, I had reservations so I used an older 92fs as my test barrel and stuck to it exclusively for about a year with the PC bullets. I regularly inspected it for wear and got well over 5,000 rounds of PC bullets through it before I stopped looking. The only thing I ever noticed was a nice, clean barrel. While my experience is far from proof, I am comfortable enough with it that I PC almost all of my bullets now.
I've never had an issue in working up regular cast loads from powder puff to full magnum loads that did not shoot clean and accurate, so I never really understood this new trend of powder coating
I sincerely envy this. I am fully aware of slugging my bores, sizing at least .001 over that and lubing prior to and after sizing but it still just doesn't always cut it for me. While I have worked up many 45/45/10 lubed loads in .38, .357, .380, and .45acp that were clean shooting and non-leading, I have never been able to push any of them very hard at all without leading. In 9mm, I can prevent leading by keeping them under about 900FPS but anything higher and I run into problems. In .44 magnum, I see leading regardless of bullet diameter, load, bhn, etc so I don't shoot anything but PC bullets for .44. After realizing how clean my guns, hands and dies were after giving up the lube, I was sold. As GBExpat stated, I do see it as a choice rather than a solution.
I do think that there is some negative sentiment out there from experienced reloaders about powder coating. It is often seen as a cheep way out or shortcut. I understand the point of view but disagree with it. To me, if both methods achieve the same results and one is preferred by the reloader, why not?
As a side note, I just enjoy doing it. The bullets look cool