The point is that the statistics are useful in dispelling the myth that anti gun people perpetuate that the old west was somehow an inherehntly violent place, and that allowing modern citizens to carry defensive arms would return us to a supposedly violent society.
Certainly one can't draw a direct correlation between the old west and modern America, but then if such statistical comparisons are invalid, then so too is the argument that modern concealed carry by citizens in the 21st century will turn them into brutish savages who have shootouts on mainstreet.
Really, I'm somewhat surprised I even have to point this out.
Justin, those statistics cannot accomplish the goal you're stating because they are void of the other variables required for a comparison. They cannot confirm or dispel ANYTHING, period. Yes, if both sides are trying to use them that way, both sides score 0 points!
And come on, you can't say:
"Certainly one can't draw a direct correlation between the old west and modern America..."
And then go on and try to make the correlation anyway! Just leave it with the statement: You CAN'T draw a direct correlation, period. You've already won the discussion at that point because you're correct, the rest of the sentences just weaken the point.
Frankly, I'm surprised that I have to point that out
Certainly one can't draw a direct correlation between the old west and modern America, but then if such statistical comparisons are invalid, then so too is the argument that modern concealed carry by citizens in the 21st century will turn them into brutish savages who have shootouts on mainstreet.
Really, I'm somewhat surprised I even have to point this out.
Justin, those statistics cannot accomplish the goal you're stating because they are void of the other variables required for a comparison. They cannot confirm or dispel ANYTHING, period. Yes, if both sides are trying to use them that way, both sides score 0 points!
And come on, you can't say:
"Certainly one can't draw a direct correlation between the old west and modern America..."
And then go on and try to make the correlation anyway! Just leave it with the statement: You CAN'T draw a direct correlation, period. You've already won the discussion at that point because you're correct, the rest of the sentences just weaken the point.
Frankly, I'm surprised that I have to point that out