igordon81
Member
My next wheel gun will be a 4" specimen of one of these two models, but I'm driving myself crazy trying to figure out which one. And yes, I understand that both is the best answer. Please help.
Unless you have very large hands you will like the slightly smaller lighter L-frame 586 better if you intend to shoot much.
I agree with L-Frame. Try to handle both before buying. I have had both a 28-2 and a 686 and they do feel different in my hands. I have small hands and the 28 being a large frame gun was little harder to grip correctly than my 686. The 686 grip is real close to the K frame. In my small hands the 686 is a little easier to grip. But no question a vintage model 28 has got some history. They are not made anymore. A 686 is still being made so they are more plentiful.I'm repeating what others have said here but you really need to shoot them both, or at least handle them both. I've owned a few very nice 27's and 28's and always sold them because they just felt too large in my hands. L-frames fit me much better. Also, for me, the extra weight at the end of the L-frame barrel helps dampen muzzle flip better, even though the N is heavier. I find 581,586 etc. to be better balanced. 581 hands down.
Thanks for all the info. I actually played with a 27-2 today and decided that the price difference is worth it 2 fold. That thing felt like it was made for me. It had the large factory target grips on it, and they felt perfect. I was previously interested in the 4" variant, but the 6" barrel felt so ideally balanced. This one appears to have been fired very little. I will post pics and a range report soon. Thank you guys again.
I fired my new (To Me) Model 27-2 6" today. It shot well with 148 HBWC .38Spl. and 158 JHP .357's. Different heights on the groups, but good groups, for my first outing with it. BTW, I also have/shoot a Model 681 with very good results.Thanks for all the info. I actually played with a 27-2 today and decided that the price difference is worth it 2 fold. That thing felt like it was made for me. It had the large factory target grips on it, and they felt perfect. I was previously interested in the 4" variant, but the 6" barrel felt so ideally balanced. This one appears to have been fired very little. I will post pics and a range report soon. Thank you guys again.
Kraigwy: Awesome picture and quotes! I liked the picture soo much, I saved it. Thanks. What ammo did you use in Alaska while on the job?
I'm digging the 28!