I have tried Weaver, Redfield, Leupold, Nikon, Vortex and Bushnell all in the $150-$350 price range. There is surprisingly little difference between them. For hunting and target I prefer 4-16X4x. 3-9 doesnt offer as much on the high end of maginification and stepping up from 3x to 4x on the low end isnt going to cost you any game. There are 4-12 scopes but why stop at 12 when you can go to 16 and pay no optical penalty? Going with a 50mm objective adds weight and bulk so that is why I prefer 40, 42, 44 mm objectives. I hunt at night and almost all my rigs have illuminated reticles. I just got a sub $200 Vortex Crossfire 4-16X50 AO illuminated reticle and it can hang with any VX-2. I am running three vortexs right now and just sent back a weaver buck commander for repair. I like the buck commander allot but it stopped holding a zero after I put $60 worth of ammo through it so that left a bad taste in my mouth.