Self Defense in Eastern PA - good article

Status
Not open for further replies.

PennsyPlinker

Member
Joined
Jul 29, 2006
Messages
645
Location
Pennsylvania
I did not see this one posted anywhere yet. This appeared in the Morning Call, from Allentown PA. Overall the article was well written, especially coming from this paper - well, maybe any paper, but this one is pretty anti most of the time.

http://www.mcall.com/news/local/all-a1_3shooting.6170564dec06,0,5983352.story?coll=all_tab01_layout

Rob Pierce Jr.'s walk through Easton's West Ward for dinner at his fiancee's mother's house Tuesday almost cost him his life.

He was mugged by two men, one a self-proclaimed Crips gang member, the other wearing a hooded jacket and carrying a handgun, police said.

''It was like hell,'' Pierce, 27, of Easton said Wednesday night in a brief phone interview.

While being told to be quiet and cooperate, he was dragged across the street in the darkness and told he was going to be shot. But in an instant, the hunted became the hunter.

Pierce, who carries a handgun for protection, pulled out a .357 revolver and shot Maurice Cook of Easton, who had thrust a .45 handgun into Pierce's back and the side of his head.

Cook, 22, who was shot in the abdomen, was taken to St. Luke's Hospital-Fountain Hill, where he underwent surgery and was expected to survive, police said.

He and the other mugging suspect, Tyrone Wright, 22, of Newark, N.J., were charged Wednesday with robbery, aggravated assault and conspiracy. Wright told a district judge he was recently freed from a New Jersey prison, where he had been held on a drug charge.

Northampton County District Attorney John Morganelli said the good guy won in a botched armed robbery. But at a news conference Wednesday, he also cautioned against a return to the vigilante days of the Wild West.

He said Pierce violated no law by protecting himself and will face no charges. ''Luckily, this time, the citizen won. I think Mr. Pierce acted responsibly.''

Morganelli said he supports laws that allow people to carry concealed weapons and hopes this latest shooting in the West Ward, the second in less than a week, sends a message to ''these young thugs'' that their victims might fight back.

Cook, of 717 W. Wilkes-Barre St., was the fourth person shot in less than a week in the West Ward. Last Thursday, three people were shot to death in an apartment at 128 N. 13th St. No arrests have been made in that case, and police have said there is no connection between the triple homicide and the shooting Tuesday.

Police have said the homicide victims had been targets.

Capt. David Ryan said he was ''not prepared to say'' if Pierce knew either of his assailants. ''We don't know if it was random,'' he said.

Pierce was mugged in the 200 block of S. 11th Street about 5:30 p.m. when Cook, pulling a gun from his hooded jacket, told him to hand over everything, police said in an arrest affidavit. Pierce backed up and Cook ran behind him, sticking a gun in Pierce's back while Wright grabbed Pierce's left side, police said.

The muggers took Pierce's keys and cell phone, then dragged him toward the east side of the street while telling him to cooperate and be quiet, police said.

''The only thing I had was my gun, and I wasn't going to give them that,'' Pierce said in the interview.

After being dragged onto the sidewalk, police said, Cook told Pierce he was going to shoot him. The muggers pulled him toward the ground and Cook put his handgun to the right side of Pierce's head, police said.

Pierce tried to stand up and turned while pulling his own handgun from his pocket, police said. He fired a shot into the air when he saw Cook holding a gun next to his head.

Wright ran when he heard the shot, police said. Cook ran into the street, pointed his gun at Pierce and fired a shot into the ground, then a second shot at Pierce before fleeing, police said.

The affidavit does not say when Cook was hit.

In all, seven shots were fired. Only Cook was shot, and police found him a few minutes later at 1143 Washington St. after getting a report of a gunshot victim there.

Two vehicles and a garage were damaged by gunfire during the exchange.

At the news conference, officials noted Pierce had a license to carry a weapon and believed he was in danger of death or serious injury when he started shooting in self-defense.

Morganelli said that since last Thursday's triple homicide he has received calls from several people wanting information about the right to defend themselves.

He said each case of use of deadly force is examined separately, but under the law, a person who reasonably believes he or she is in danger of death or serious bodily injury may resort to deadly force.

''It's absolutely crystal clear'' that Pierce had a right to defend himself, Morganelli said.

Asked what Easton police are doing to allay residents' fears, Chief Larry Palmer said extra patrols have been in place in the West Ward for some time, with funding for police overtime coming from Weed and Seed and other programs.

Palmer said other measures have been put into place since the killings last week, but ''I can't speak specifically to them at this time.''

Morganelli said people are afraid. ''We don't expect our citizens to wait and get shot. As long as I'm district attorney here, I'm probably going to err on the side of the citizen'' who defends himself. ''We're happy that Mr. Maurice T. Cook didn't die, but his injuries were brought on by himself.''

Ryan, the Easton police captain, said that after the attempted holdup Cook and Wright fled to the Washington Street home, where they had friends.

He said Wright was arrested and taken to Northampton County Prison because he gave a fake name, and Cook was taken to the hospital, where he was in stable condition Wednesday.

Wright was arraigned at the prison and Cook at the hospital. Bail for each was set at $250,000.

Morganelli said that at the prison, Wright said he belonged to the Crips.

Wright told District Judge Sandra J. Zemgulis at his arraignment that he got out of Southern State Correctional Facility in Maurice River Township, N.J., on Oct. 29. In the last three weeks, he said, he had been staying with a girlfriend at 1143 Washington St.
 
.... But at a news conference Wednesday, (Morganelli) also cautioned against a return to the vigilante days of the Wild West.
He did? Where's the quote? Sloppy writing.
''The only thing I had was my gun, and I wasn't going to give them that,'' Pierce said in the interview.
:D:D:D
 
Morganelli said people are afraid. ''We don't expect our citizens to wait and get shot. As long as I'm district attorney here, I'm probably going to err on the side of the citizen'' who defends himself.

a new presidential candidate?
 
He did? Where's the quote? Sloppy writing.

This is a good question. Given Morganelli's other comments, I actually wonder if Morganelli said anything remotely like the "wild west vigilante" comment the journalist suggests, or if that was just tossed in there for thrills.
 
In all, seven shots were fired. Only Cook was shot, and police found him a few minutes later at 1143 Washington St. after getting a report of a gunshot victim there.

I guess that proves that just because you have a gun and a mag full of ammo doesn't mean you are going to hit anything...practice!
 
Northampton County District Attorney John Morganelli said the good guy won in a botched armed robbery. But at a news conference Wednesday, he also cautioned against a return to the vigilante days of the Wild West.
As noted above, I wonder if he said that or it was added for jouralistic flair. A trained writer should know the difference between "vigilante" and self-defense.
 
I guess that proves that just because you have a gun and a mag full of ammo doesn't mean you are going to hit anything...practice!

Well it is one thing to practice at a range, and another to face real danger and draw and fire and avoid getting shot in the dark under duress while worrying about your dinner partner/potential co-victim...

But yes, practice!!
 
John Morganelli's words have been suprising me lately... in a good way.

Just as an FYI, he's very outspoken on a number of issues,
such as this article he wrote for USA/PAC (below):
A MESSAGE FROM DISTRICT ATTORNEY JOHN M. MORGANELLI

Dear Fellow Citizen:

Let me share with you some troubling facts:

* 10-20 million illegal criminal aliens presently roam the U.S.The number of illegal criminal aliens doubled in the 1990's.

* Illegal aliens constitute over 25% of the federal prison population. In some areas of the country, 12 % of felonies, 25% of burglaries and 34% of thefts are committed by illegal aliens.

* In Los Angeles alone, 95% of all outstanding warrants for homicide ( which total approximately 1,200-1,500) target illegal aliens. Up to 2/3 of all fugitive felony warrants ( approximately 17,000) are for illegal aliens.

* In fiscal year 1999, incarceration expenses for incarcerating illegal aliens in state & local jails in Pennsylvania alone cost taxpayers $13.3 million. It has been established that the nationwide costs to states and localties for housing illegal criminal aliens is about $2 billion per year.

Let me introduce myself. My name is John Morganelli. I have served as District Attorney for Northampton County, Pennsylvania for 13 years. I am past president of the Pennsylvania District Attorneys' Association.

As district attorney, and as president of the state prosecutor's association , I have worked diligently to protect our communities from violent crime. I believe that violent criminals need to be locked up and isolated from law abiding citizens. We must never compromise our personal security.

Now, however, more than ever,I am concerned about an ongoing problem that threatens our security and is causing a crime wave in communities across the US. It is the growing invasion of the US by illegal aliens and foreign criminals.

Let me give you a few more facts:

* Approximately 400,000 illegal aliens who have committed crimes and have been given a deportation order are at large in the U.S.and their whereabouts unknown.

* In May 2002, federal agents arrested 2 Egyptian nationals for trying to smuggle illegal Middle Eastern immigrants into New Jersey via Mexico.

* In December 2002, Saul Morales-Garcia, an illegal alien, shot La Vegas police officer Enrique Hernandez 6 times following a foot chase.Garcia had previously been deported but again illegally re-entered the U.S.

* In June 2004, Enrique Sousa Alvarez, an illegal alien, was arrested in San Jose, California and charged with violently kidnapping a 9 year old girl from her home, holding her captive for 3 days, and repeatedly raped her before releasing her at a convenience store parking lot.

* In August 2004, Adrienne George Camacho, an illegal alien with a criminal record that included 4 previous felony convictions, and who had been deported from the U.S., sneaked back into California and shot and killed police officer Tony Zeppetella. Office Zeppetella left behind a wife and infant child.

* Illegal alien Walter Alexander Sorto was repeatedly picked up for driver's license violations and for driving without insurance. Houston police, however, were barred from reporting his illegal residency status to federal authorities by "sanctuary policies". In March 2004, Sorto and a companion abducted, raped and killed 3 Houston women.

I could go on and on. Unfortunately, the majority of politicians in Washington in both political parties have not protected us. Many actually support amnesty for the lawbreakers, and support such things like in state college tuition and social security benefits for illegal aliens. They have ignored for too long the serious and growing problem of illegal aliens and foreign criminals entering the US, and utilizing fraudulent documents to maintain their presence here.

WHAT CAN YOU DO?

I am asking that you join with me and other law enforcement people in mobilizing thousands of citizens in the cause of our security. If you agree with me that that illegal aliens should not be rewarded with drivers licenses, free college tuition et., and that violent criminals from other countries should be incarcerated and then deported, please join USA/PAC by signing up for our free newsletter. At the same time, go to our secure online "Contribution" page and make a nominal contribution.

WHY USA/PAC?

Political action today necessitates money. The voices of average Americans will not be heard unless we all mobilize to influence those in power. USA/PAC is a political action committee I have established to marshall the voices ( and dollars) of average Americans concerned about the security of our country.

My goal is simple: to support those candidates, regardless of party, who demonstrate a commitment to strengthening the security of our country and protecting us from foreign elements and domestic criminals.

WHAT YOU GET FOR JOINING/CONTRIBUTING TO USA/PAC

* You will be one of thousands of Americans whose voices will be heard on issues concerning illegal immigration, crime and other issues concerning the security of the US.

* You will receive periodic updates informing you of important news regarding crime and security issues and how you can increase your influence on elected officials.

Believe me, we in the law enforcement community need your help. The power of thousands of citizens who are willing to make their voices heard will have an impact. I ask you to make a commitment today.

Sincerely

John M. Morganelli

District Attorney
http://www.usapac.us/
 
http://blog.pennlive.com/lehighvalley/2007/12/from_victim_to_victor_amid_a_h.html

From victim to victor amid a hail of bullets
Posted by Stephen Althouse December 06, 2007 00:39AM
Categories: Breaking News
Sometimes the good guys win. On Tuesday night, about 5:35 p.m. in the 200 block of South 11th Street in Easton, (LCTF holder). went from victim to victor in seconds flat. One of several bullets fired from his .357 Taurus revolver into the abdomen of 22-year-old (thug #1) saw to that. (Thug #1), along with (thug #2), 22, of Newark, attempted to rob (LCTF holder) by putting a gun to his head and telling him his life was about to end, officials said Wednesday. Instead, (LCTF holder) turned the tables, pulling out the concealed .357 Taurus and firing three shots in self-defense. (thug #1) fired four shots, none of which hit (LCTF holder). Read Colin McEvoy's report here. Here, he shares the robbery victim-turned-shooter's story. Precious Petty reports today about (thug #1) and (thug #2) criminal histories here.
Morganelli"There's a real fear here of these young thugs (on) the streets with a gun, trying to take down another citizen of Easton. Luckily, this time the citizen won," said Northampton County District Attorney (JxxMxx).
The neighborhood where the incident occurred has been systematically deteriorating, according to residents. Last week, a triple homicide rocked the West Ward. Residents Wednesday recounted witnessing drug deals up and down Washington Street.
"The characters that go into that house, I'm telling you, it's enough to scare the devil. Lucifer wouldn't go in there. Believe me, he wouldn't," said 71-year-old (elderly neighbor).
Precious Petty writes about a prayer vigil held Wednesday night at North 13th and Spring Garden streets here. Express-Times Editor Joseph P. Owens describes his experience at the vigil here. Assistant Managing Editor Tony Rhodin writes in his blog that before you start packing heat you'd better learn to respect the weapon and understand how your actions can impact others and yourself.
He (LCTF holder)is a hunter whose father prepared him in the correct ways of aiming and firing a weapon. It's not as easy as it looks on TV. It's as likely a citizen pulling a gun in self-defense shoots himself, someone other than the person threatening his life or surrenders the weapon to the bad guys as it is for the victim to wound or kill an assailant" Rhodin writes.



There was actually three articles in the Easton Express or Express Times as it is now known. All of the articles expressed generally positive support for the LCTF holder. Folks are getting tired of the drugs and gangs and are starting to not take it any more. I just don't agree with publishing the name of the LCTF holder and the fact that at least one of the thugs was a purported gang member. Now, I've got to get on the papers' blogs and point out differences between this incident and the Mall shootings.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top