Shooting 9mm Handguns - Which was the Most Accurate

Tallball

Member
Joined
Oct 2, 2014
Messages
7,806
My shooting buddy and I were both feeling poor, so we decided to go on a range trip and only bring 22lr and 9mm parabellum handguns. After we warmed up with 22's, we decided to find out which 9mm handgun was the most accurate of all. We went to one of the seven-yard benches and wasted a bunch of ammo embarrassing ourselves with our mediocre shooting skills before we were through. The answer was unexpected.

Ruger LC9s pro - It's one of the small CCW 9mm pistols I keep in a safe and carry revolvers instead. It is puny in my gigantic mutant paws. Either of us could empty the magazine into a fist-sized group easily, but they were all a little bit high and to the right.

Glock 43 - It's another one of the small CCW 9mm pistols that I choose to own but do not choose to carry. We shot my friend's example. It was pretty much like shooting the LC9s, but the trigger not quite as good. It shot to POA, though.

Ruger SP101 - I do not like SP101's very much. I got this one used with a decent trigger. I changed out the grips, installed a slightly lighter mainspring, and shot it a whole lot of times. At this point I have finally accepted it and can shoot it almost as well as my preferred j-frames or LCR. After I warmed up with a few cylinders, I shot it a little better than the small autopistols. I'll probably be practicing with this one a lot, since 9mm is much cheaper than 38 special right now.

Ruger P85 - My friend inherited it from his dad. His brother put adjustable sights on it for him. The trigger is dreadful, but other than that it's easy to shoot. He and I both shot decent groups with it - about the same as most service pistols. (No picture, sorry.)

RIA 1911 - I don't know why a cheap imitation version of an antiquated design (in the wrong caliber no less) is so easy for me to shoot well, but it is. I bought it used, it had been shot a bunch, and I have shot it a bunch more. My friend and I both shot tiny groups with it. I shoot my 1911's better than almost anything.

Ruger Blackhawk - I bought a 9mm cylinder off ebay and by luck it fit into the revolver... just barely, after I scrubbed it within an inch of its life. It's ammo sensitive and a few random factory rounds won't quite fit into the chambers. I've read that the barrel isn't even the right diameter for 9mm anyway, and there's no way this thing can be very accurate. Besides, the revolver itself is from the 1970's and has had a whole lot of rounds through it. None of that matters. Most of my groups had every hole touching. My friend's groups were close. It was the most accurate 9mm handgun of the group, though the 1911 was close.

What's your most accurate 9mm handgun?





 
Last edited:
The CZ TS2 has one of the finest factory triggers I've ever tried! And I agree - most shooters cannot match the accuracy potential of the better handguns today. Doesn't mean you can't own a super accurate handgun, just manage expectations.
 
RIA 1911 - I don't know why a cheap imitation version of an antiquated design (in the wrong caliber no less) is so easy for me to shoot well, but it is. I bought it used, it had been shot a bunch, and I have shot it a bunch more. My friend and I both shot tiny groups with it.
I consider RIA 1911 "Glock" of 1911s due to generous chamber mouths that will reliably feed even sloppy LSWC reloads after 500 rounds of fouling.

And Citadel is "target" model of RIA made with tighter tolerances with tighter barrel chamber and produced comparable/smaller groups than my railed Sig 1911 that produced 2" groups at 25 yards.

FYI, here's a listing of groups produced by various brands/models of pistols at 25 yards for reference - https://www.thehighroad.org/index.p...s-and-discussions.778197/page-9#post-10940688
 
What's your most accurate 9mm handgun?

For me, probably my Glock 19. Because it's also the largest.

Ruger SP101 - I do not like SP101's very much. I got this one used with a decent trigger. ... I shot it a little better than the small autopistols. I'll probably be practicing with this one a lot, since 9mm is much cheaper than 38 special right now.

Would love to have a 9mm snub right now, for just that reason. Local gunmonger has lots of 9mm, not so much (and expensive) .38. And the last time I saw .38 at the farm store was in the depths of the "teh covids!" panic.
 
For me, probably my Glock 19. Because it's also the largest.

Would love to have a 9mm snub right now, for just that reason. Local gunmonger has lots of 9mm, not so much (and expensive) .38. And the last time I saw .38 at the farm store was in the depths of the "teh covids!" panic.

Our accuracy pretty much did go from small to large, with the largest handgun being the most accurate for us... or at least, the one with the longest barrel. The only legitimate contest was between the 1911 and Blackhawk. The sight radius on the smaller handguns was too short to compete in practical accuracy with semi-unskilled shooters.

If someone wanted a 9mm snub to practice with, I've seen the Taurus 905 as cheap as $329 NiB recently. It's just their old j-frame copy, in 9mm instead of 38 special. They normally go bang.

IMHO, snub practice is snub practice. Shooting the SP101 is close enough to shooting a 38 j-frame that practicing with one is about like practicing with the other.
 
I consider RIA 1911 "Glock" of 1911s due to generous chamber mouths that will reliably feed even sloppy LSWC reloads after 500 rounds of fouling.

And Citadel is "target" model of RIA made with tighter tolerances with tighter barrel chamber and produced comparable/smaller groups than my railed Sig 1911 that produced 2" groups at 25 yards./QUOTE]

You're correct. I wasn't giving that poor old 1911 enough credit. I saw it for $330 used and thought of it as a beater that I might shoot every once in a while. It turns out it's IRA's nicer model. I really like the sights, and the trigger is excellent. It goes to the range more often than any of my other service pistols.
 
I no longer have a service size 9mm but of the bunch I have had my P85 was lights out accurate, just not with factory ammo. It, strangely enough, loved the RCBS 38-150 KT bullet which is accurate in every gun I've shot it in. 4.4 grains of Unique produced 2.5" groups out to 20 to 25 yards. Bagged. My 3" SP 357 with wadcutters is about the same but harder to hold.
EC9s and G43 are spread hand group size.
 
My Kimber Stainless Target II 1911 and CZ Shadow2 are both ridiculously accurate. My CZ 75 SP-01 isn’t too far behind. My various 9mm Glocks can’t beat them, but a few are pretty close.

Stay safe.
 
I'm a pretty poor shot really, but I've recently gotten a couple of Tisas 1911's in 9mm that have really impressed me. One is an all steel "Tank Commander" and the other is an aluminum frame "Sting-Ray." Both are "commander size" guns. I shoot them, especially the "Sting Ray" a lot better than any other 9mm I remember. The only reason I say the Sting Ray is I've shot it a lot more. They both have good triggers and decent sights.
 
Ruger Blackhawk - I've read that the barrel isn't even the right diameter for 9mm anyway, and there's no way this thing can be very accurate.

Whoever wrote that was wrong. There is no difference in the groove diameter between the two calibers.

38/357 and 9mm barrels have the exact same barrel specification of .355 + .004 groove diameter. Anything between 0.355" and 0.359" is within spec for both calibers.

https://saami.org/wp-content/upload...rfire-Pistol-Revolver-Approved-12-13-2022.pdf
 
At 7 yards my Dagger and Taurus GX3 (The only 9mms I currently own) can shoot ragged hole groups with my handloads.
The 2 most accurate 9mm I have owned were a Springfield Range Officer and a CZ SP01 Competition model. A distant 3rd was a Glock 34 with a bunch of upgrades.

I had a Ruger P89 for a decade or 2 and it was surprisingly accurate and completely indestructible.
 
I can shoot some more accurately than others but which one is more accurate would require a ransom rest as I will never be able to determine that by shooting them.

Some days my pps just fits and shoots best other days my cz or ppq does.
 
By a large margin it's my son's Canik Mete SFX. With factory ammo its slightly more accurate than my M&P9. With handloads its nearly as accurate as my Blackhawk in 357, which routinely turns in sub-1.5" groups at 25 yards during load testing.

Speaking of a Blackhawk, are 9mm cylinders available for those that aren't sold as convertible, or did the OP just get lucky and find one that worked? A 9mm cylinder for mine would make it twice the fun.
 
At 7 yards my Dagger and Taurus GX3 (The only 9mms I currently own) can shoot ragged hole groups with my handloads.
The 2 most accurate 9mm I have owned were a Springfield Range Officer and a CZ SP01 Competition model. A distant 3rd was a Glock 34 with a bunch of upgrades.

I had a Ruger P89 for a decade or 2 and it was surprisingly accurate and completely indestructible.

<Yoda voice> G3C or Gx4, there is no Gx3.</Yoda voice>
 
Back
Top