Should I trade in my Ruger LCP for a S&W Bodyguard???

Status
Not open for further replies.
the count

the count

Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2010
Messages
794
Location
Anywhere, USA
I got the LCP a while ago simply because it easily fits in any pocket. Do not really like the 380 caliber. I don't reload it and its more expensive than 9mm. Stopping power is questionable too, but better than BB's. A friend at the range showed me his new S&W Bodyguard. While not new, I had never seen one before. Really light AND nice trigger. I make plenty of 38SPL ammo already, so this part is a no brainer. However, I would loose one round...5 vs 6. What to do? Anything I should consider not mentioned here?
 
The LCP isn't really a "range gun", if you plan on shooting the gun a lot at the range, and you already reload .38, then that's the way to go.
 
Personally I think the trigger on the LCR is nicer than the Bodyguard, but that's just personal preference.
 
I got rid of my LCP because I felt that I should not carry a gun that I could not shoot effectively.

Can you shoot your LCP effectively?

If not, get rid of it. There are better choices for pocket guns... maybe just not as small an an LCP.
 
My wife has the Bodyguard (.38) and it is definitely not a range gun. She runs 10 rounds through it sets it down. I run 5, and set it down. Her dad who carries a Kimber .45 shoots 3 and sets it down. And last time we went the range master put 3 rounds through it, set it down, shook is hand and said "well that's just not fun to shoot at all is it!".

We're looking at getting her a Springfield XDM compact now to compliment the SR9c.
 
My wife has the Bodyguard (.38) and it is definitely not a range gun. She runs 10 rounds through it sets it down. I run 5, and set it down. Her dad who carries a Kimber .45 shoots 3 and sets it down. And last time we went the range master put 3 rounds through it, set it down, shook is hand and said "well that's just not fun to shoot at all is it!".
Click to expand...

I have a Kimber .45 acp and when I go to the range I'll put 50 to 100 rounds through it. I love shooting that gun!
 
I'd trade it for a Colt Agent or Cobra. You'd still have a lightweight pocketable .38, but it would be a six shooter. With the stock grips on a Cobra or the stock grips plus a Tyler-T adapter, you can shoot more than a cylinder or two without putting it down. Heck, you can shoot it all you want without breaking out in tears.
 
He loves his Kimber as well, that one he'll shoot 100 easy, that Bodyguard though no one likes.
 
I have a S&W 442 Airweight and between 25 and 50 rounds, my hands hurt. Oddly enough, I was looking at trading it in for a Sig P238. The LCP seemed too small for my hands.
 
I picked up my S&W BodyGuard 380 a few weeks ago and love it! 380 auto with 6+1. Ive put 500+ through it and really enjoy shooting it. I like the "real feel" of the gun and the "real sights". I've had a few chances to fire both the LCP and BG380 and in my personal experience, the Bodyguard is far superior in grip, feel, ergonomics, and features. Anyone who has ever sighted down an LCP or a P3aT will immediately notice the superior sights. XS BigDot sights are available now too. I also like the lock back on empty and the safety, plus the integrated laser sight has all my friends grinning when they shoot it at the range. One day I put 200 rounds through it. I'm a slim guy, 6' and about 160lb's, and i have no issues with the recoil. My brother did have an issue with releasing the mag when shooting quickly, but after a few grip adjustments, he has no problems and is looking to pick one up. I highly recommend it.
 
Last edited:
Ah...i thought he meant the .38 since that is what he reloads and mentioned he would have to go down to 5 rounds. My bad if I misread that.
 
Stop and think about it yall small light weight carry guns are ment and used for
self defence not a range gun.
I carry a Ruger LCR and im willing to bet that I havent run 100 rds through it I have shot it just enough to feel comfertable with it. When I go to the range to do alot of shooting it is with my 22lr and if I want to shoot something with some more bang I will use my 9mm,SBH 44mag.
And if I want to reach out ant touch something I will use a long gun or
my Contender or Encore Pistol.
 
No one can tell you if you should get the S&W Bodyguard 38 except you. If you like the revolver you should get it. I wouldn't worry too much about losing 1 round over the LCP unless you intend on missing a lot... :p

I'm a huge revolver fan and would make the trade in a second! (but then again, i probably would have an LCP to trade)
 
I have a Model 637 Airweight. The first time I took it to the range, it still had the Uncle Mike's boot grips and I loaded it with .38 Special +P ammunition. The second time I took it to the range, it had better grips and I loaded it with .38 Special ammunition. It still kicks but I can put a box of 50 rounds through it.

I did some research and found the too-short grips, while dandy for stuffing in your boot, handicap your grip and, therefore, control of the gun. Grips that have room for your little finger allow you to use your hand's full grip strength to reduce the twisting and have better control. I added the grips Smith & Wesson supply with the Model 60 Pro. They add only a half-inch to the overall height of the gun but allow a far better grip.

The other thing I did, and what I should have done in the first place, was get a Model 60 with the 3-inch barrel. You can also get it with the 2.125-inch barrel. It's chambered for .357 Magnum but it's fun to shoot with .38 Specials.
 
I've put 475 rounds through an LCP this past week. It's not a range gun but it has yet to malfunction. Not real fun to shoot in the cold either. Kind of stings more when it's cold. I do like how it can be carried so easily though. It suits it's purpose well IMHO
 
I love my LCP. I tried to make a switch to a S & W 642 .38, but it wasn't a great fit in the pocket and kicked like a mule. Trigger ate my finger and I had to aim low with it to hit anything. I can shoot the LCP left or right handed and hit the target almost every time. I usually shoot from about 15-20 feet with that particular gun. Keep in mind it isn't a range gun; it's a close-up and personal belly gun, if you are unfortunate to have to use it for self-defense. Carries nicely too. The holster store.com sells a nice leather IWB for it, and an Uncle Mike's #10 works well too.
 
Sure the Airweight kicks a little, it is a 15oz revolver after all but kicks like mule, I think not. I wouldn't was to put 200 rounds of .38 Special +P through it every range trip but I do usually shoot 50 rounds of .38 Special and 15 to 20 rounds of +P before I leave the range.

Like a mule?? Noooo...
 
Just go shoot a lightweight snubby and see what you think. If you like it more, get it.
 
I carry the LCP almost all the time.Never meant for it to be a range gun.
I think the .380 is under rated.6 rounds in the bad guy?Get er done.
My next carry weapon will be the Ruger LCR.I've heard good things about
the S&W Bodyguard also.
 
If you like revolvers more, then yes, if your an auto pistol man then no. If you want a more shootable .380 try the .380 bodyguard.

Seriously, the difference in power between .380 and .38sp out of the actual guns that shoot them is very marginal. Not enough to worry about.
 
The short answer is no

The longer drawn out version is that I do not care what anyone says, it is far easier to carry an LCP than any revolver, other than perhaps the tiny NAA 22s. The LCP is also very reliable and, for me anyway, easier to shoot than a snubbie. Over the years I have owned, and tried to carry:
Several model 36's
3 or 4 Ruger SP101's
A BEAUTIFUL Colt Detective special that I regret selling
a couple of Taurus 85's and, last but not least,
a model 637-2
Along the way I also owned a Colt Mustang that ws incredibly accurate for a gun of its size. It got carried more than any of the snubbies. Now, my LCP usually goes along for the ride despite that fact that I most always am carrying a 1911 on my hip.
 
My wife and I opted for the S&W Bodyguard 380 over the LCP... Its going to be her primary carry gun (once our permits arrive from Utah... its been 6 weeks). While the .380 wont be my first choice for a carry caliber, its better than nothing at all.

I like the fact that it is a Double action only and has an external safety. My only complaint would be with the laser... It stays nice and bright until you fire off a few rounds. By the end of the magazine, you can hardly see it, even at 5 yards at the range. I figure in a self defense situation, you are not going to have time to click the laser on anyways, but it is good for practice.
 
colt 380 mustang stainless

Hello guys and gals, i need info on my colt mustang 380 it is not the plusII and not the goverment its the standard mustangand stainless, the research i have found says they are getting harder to find and becoming collectables. also the ones i see come with the plastic box. mine has the card board box and i have researched the box and only boxes i see have the small colt logo mine has the large logo that covers the hole top of the lid . i cant seem to find one like it.. any info on the mustang and box ? i could use some info please.. thanks.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

J
  • Locked
Ruger LCP vs. S&W Bodyguard
2
Replies
33
Views
7K
Guns and more
G
O
  • Locked
Anyone Seen The New S&W Guns?
Replies
8
Views
1K
wlewisiii
W
T
  • Locked
LCP vs Bodyguard .380
2
Replies
37
Views
2K
Rugerspyderon
R
Autodidactic
  • Locked
Thinking of selling my Ruger Wrangler and buying a .380 Bodyguard on Hold
2 3 4
Replies
99
Views
4K
Autodidactic
Autodidactic
U
  • Locked
What self-defense ammo for a .380?
2
Replies
46
Views
5K
Shawn Dodson
Shawn Dodson
Back
Top