I'd take the SIG 228. I've always heard good things about them and the ones I've shot have been fine. If they are as accurate and reliable as my 220 and 239 thats the way I'd go.
Second choice, the PC-13, thats got to be one of the best fighting revolvers out there. Unfortunately, out of the range I'm willing to pay for a handgun. Now when a nice, used 3 inch, round butt, M13 shows up that will be a different story.