I'm not trying to start any wars here, just debating which gun to carry, looking for some feedback. The 1911 is certainly thinner, and more stable at really low temps (I grew up in Minnesota, so being able to use the gun at -40F is important), and while the XD is thicker, it's less picky on ammo, and can be carried without any manual safety on. Both guns are about 5" tall, the Kimber allows for all fingers to be on the grip, while the XD doesn't (at least without a grip extension). Lastly, I know the XD is a little thicker than the 1911, and while I carry IWB, it will probably show more. Any thoughts on the advantages and disadvantages to either? Again, please, no 1911 versus poly wars.. I am truly not trying to start one. And finally, while I know the XD is less $$, that's not really part of my consideration.
Last edited: