Sub $200 6-18/20/24x50mm scope comparison

Status
Not open for further replies.

LiveLife

Member
Joined
Jan 10, 2010
Messages
32,965
Location
Northwest Coast
For those on a budget, with the arrival of Vortex Crossfire II 6-24x50, thinking about doing a comparison between following scopes I have:
Field of view brightness/clarity/turret tracking box test will be done through "Real World - Accurizing 22LR on the cheap" thread using EGW 20 MOA scope mount on 10/22 at 100 yards - https://www.thehighroad.org/index.p...22lr-on-the-cheap.898035/page-2#post-12194385
 
Last edited:
Last edited:
Went to do some 100 yard testing yesterday after installing EGW 20 MOA rail on the 10/22 and took Vortex Crossfire II 6-24x50 and Viridian 6-24x50 to compare.

Just as I got the Vortex scope zero'ed, another shooter (recently moved to the area) drove up and asked if he could set up next to me for 100 yard powder work up. I said "sure". He set up Savage 110 Elite Precision 300 PRC with Arken EP5 5-25X56 FFP MOA scope and bipod/monopod. I went, "Nice!" but I was hoping to do some scope comparison. :)

He asked if I verified distance to target and I told him I already "measured" to be around 100 yards. He pulled out a range finder and told me "105 yards" with a smile. :thumbup:

While he shot .3 gr powder charge increments, I was actually getting smaller 4/5 shot core group sizes around 1"-1.5" with Aguila 40 gr CPRN (He eventually got smaller groups on par with mine as his powder charges got higher). He looked at my Lead Sled Solo setup and told me he would pull out his Lead Sled on his next range test. We chatted while changing out targets and I switched out scope to Viridian and got to check out his set up and look through the Arken scope. Yes, turret definitely had a nice and positive "click" with bright and clear field of view and he said turret tracking was dead on.

With 20 MOA rail, for both Viridian and Vortex scopes, vertical reticle adjustment returned towards center (I was 6" off center with Vortex scope mounted out of the box with Monstrum V2 rings). Since bright sunlight comparison just shows bright clear field of view for my eyes with these 50mm scopes, I waited til later in the afternoon around 4:30 PM with target area darkened by shade. Comparing to Vortex and Arken, Viridian still produced sharp field of view without distortion to edge at 24x power but was not as bright as Vortex and Vortex produced slightly sharper image but inch grid target lines were clear and 22LR bullet holes were readily visible for Viridian - https://www.thehighroad.org/index.php?resources/inch-square-grid.22/

While turret tracking improved, before I could repeat the box test, my group size began to increase likely due to barrel needing its third cleaning with round count approaching 6000 (10/22 barrel has been bore brushed twice). In comparison, Vortex turret felt mushy and vague.

So what do I think about the Viridian Serac?

Especially having looked through Burris FF E1 6.5-20x50mm and Vortex Crossfire II/Arken at low light shaded 100 yard inch grid targets, these are my thoughts:
  • At $150 and free shipping, not sure if you could find a better scope in the 6-24x50/30mm tube with tactical locking turrets (and likely good lifetime warranty service through Viridian) that is sold under major brand name.
  • Low cost Viridian 30mm high profile rings worked well (Only tested with 22LR)
  • Came with flip up covers
  • Side focus parallax verified accurate at 100 yards
  • Turret with positive "click", locking rings and good tracking pending (Will repeat box test after cleaning 10/22 barrel)
  • Full sun/low light shade brightness on par with Burris FF E1 6.5-20x50/Inch tube for my eyes
  • For 22LR shooting at 50/100 yards, good low cost "consideration"

So what do I think about the Vortex Crossfire II?
  • At $172 and free shipping (Now back to $299 everywhere) happy with bright and clear field of view, even under shaded low light viewing inch grid lines and 22LR bullet holes.
  • Great lifetime warranty service
  • Came with sunshade
  • Adjustable objective verified accurate at 100 yards
  • Capped turret that is mushy and vague
  • Full sun/low light shade brightness on par with Burris FF E1 6.5-20x50/Inch tube for my eyes
  • For 100 yard 22LR shooting, no need for tactical turret so Vortex Crossfire II with capped turrets would be fine
After cleaning the 10/22 barrel, will bring Bushnell D&D/Burris FF E1 to the next range trip.
 
Last edited:
Just as I got the Vortex scope zero'ed, another shooter (recently moved to the area) drove up and asked if he could set up next to me for 100 yard powder work up. I said "sure". He set up Savage 110 Elite Precision 300 PRC with Arken EP5 5-25X56 FFP MOA scope and bipod/monopod. I went, "Nice!" but I was hoping to do some scope comparison. :)

So were you given the opportunity to look thru it?

I am contemplating another scopre for my Savage Model 11 build as I do not believe the Burris FF E1 4.5-14 is going to be enough scope for what I want to do and also believe I will be leaving my Athlon Argos 8-34X56 on the Model 10. So I have been leaning towards another Athlon of maybe the Arken.
 
So were you given the opportunity to look thru it?
Yes, as we spent several hours setting up targets, shooting, chatting and shooting some pistols and I ended up showing eyes closed point shooting POI synchronization to POA, unsighted point shooting and sighted (looking past the front sight) point shooting at multiple targets along with cadence shooting - https://www.thehighroad.org/index.php?threads/holding-your-weapon-sideways.901822/#post-12212166

Looking through the Arken EP5 5-25X56 FFP MOA scope later in the afternoon of dark shady area under the trees of the inch grid copy papers is a good test of low light clarity. Compared to Burris FF E1 6.5-20x50mm (1" tube) and 30mm tubes of Vortex Crossfire II and Viridian Serac, Arken EP5 produced brighter field of view (Likely from 56mm objective) that was sharp and easier on the eye due to better eye box (Viridian Serac has tighter eye box than Burris/Vortex and has comparable low light brightness to 1" tube Burris but slightly dimmer than 30mm tube Vortex but after going back and forth comparing shot groups with Arken and Viridian, it was relatively easy to visualize both targets with sharpness ... I was actually surprised by Viridian's low light clarity).

While Viridian Serac had nice positive "click" turrets, Arken's turrets were definitely more positive "clicks" that were substantial.
I have been leaning towards another Athlon of maybe the Arken.
I have been thinking about buying Athlon Argos BTR 10-40X56/30mm SFP MOA for 300+ yard shooting with my AR (18" .223 Wylde SS barrel that's been producing around 1" 10 shot groups at 100 yards with 55 gr FMJ and planning to use heavier bullets at longer range) but comments mentioned clarity dropping off at higher than 32x power which is OK for me as I am thinking about shooting out to 300 yards mostly.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top