Too much recoil

Status
Not open for further replies.
Different tools for different jobs...

It should be noted that a SP-101, .357Msg. was NOT designed to be a hunting, or target sidearm.
My FIVE shot 2 1/8" Double Action only SP-101 is made for a small carry package that can put out 5 rounds of .357Magnum Hell to the person on the other end. I also have the Hogue Mono Grip rubber, and that helps, but this weapon is NOT made to be fun to shoot.
To me, as the OP has been advised, a GP-100, or a 'K' frame Smith & Wesson, would make a better match for hunting.
If your hand strength continues to be a problem, a smaller caliber will be needed...Bill.
 
Try some .38 special 148 grain wadcutter target loads. They have mild recoil and a good reputation as a self defense load. They were often carried by cops in their snubbie back-up guns.
 
Try some 158g SWC's with a low dose of Trail Boss. Feels like shooting a .22wmr even from a LCR.

Its accurate too, but keep the shooting in SD ranges. Your not going to hit the 50yard gong with that recipe.
 
If you reload just lighten the loads... I shoot some 38 +P loads out of my .357 brass all the time. (686 snubbie) I don't like using 38sp brass because of the ring that can develop in the cylinder, if I'm swapping ammo.

Some of my most accurate loads out of a 686 6" are lower power .357 mag loads.
 
Getting hurt by handguns sucks so my recommendation would be keep your revolver and hand load minimum loads.

1: Trail Boss powder for practice .

2: Real stuff for the real deal.
 
I dislike smooth grips.
I feel like it's too easy for the gun to move.

So I have matching grips on both my SP101 & GP100
They're from Altamont & Called "Snakeskin"
http://www.altamontco.com/experimental/products/pistol/ruger/#Ruger_gp100.php

Both the rubber & the wood panels have a sort of snakeskin looking texture.
You can get the rubber & wood as a set, or you can get rubber or wood separately.
(cost is the same)
The wood is Super Walnut - it's lighter in color & shows the texturing better.
(I think it looks great - but that's just me. Rosewood looks great too)

sp101l.jpg

sp101r.jpg
 
Last edited:
Too much recoil is subjective topic. It's what a person gets used to. I like to shoot my Super Blackhawk (.44mag) but the wood grips made it painful to shoot more than a dozen rounds. I put on Hogue grips and it changed it a bunch. I've shot it enough that I wore the grips out. Typical day at the range is 50 to 100 rounds.
 
Too much recoil is subjective topic. It's what a person gets used to. I like to shoot my Super Blackhawk (.44mag) but the wood grips made it painful to shoot more than a dozen rounds. I put on Hogue grips and it changed it a bunch. I've shot it enough that I wore the grips out. Typical day at the range is 50 to 100 rounds.
That is a good example. My Model 29-5 while a nice revolver could be a little painful to shoot and I went to Hogue rubber grips and the gun was much more comfortable to shoot to where 50 full house rounds really weren't a problem at all to shoot. While the actual free recoil energy did not change the felt recoil certainly did.

Ron
 
I have an SP101 in 327 magnum. It will also shoot several other milder 32 rounds. My wife (ruined wrists) and daughter (eleven years old) shoot it easily with 32 H&R magnum, which is a respectable round. They shoot 32 S&W long for target practice, which feels about like a 22, though throwing a much larger chunk of lead.

My friend also has an SP101, in 357. My problem with both his and mine is that the factory grips are imho horrible. Most people very much prefer the Hogue monogrip. I thought it was an improvement. But with my huge hands I went one better and got large exotic wood grips for it. My friend has tiny hands and finds the factory grips to be perfectly acceptable.

My friend is 5'6" with tiny but strong hands. His son is 5'8" with larger but weaker hands. I am 6'6" with large hands even for my size. My buddy's SP101 is a 3" with fixed sights.

For all of us, shooting 38 special target loads was no big deal. The recoil wasn't much. The son is recoil-shy by nature, but did not object to it. Even with my enormous hands and the tiny horrible factory grips I had no problems. My tiny-handed friend could have shot it for hours. At 7 yards all of us shot it with quite acceptable combat accuracy.

The 357's were a different story. The son shot one cylinder and that was more than enough for him. I think he would have preferred to set it down after one round! His dad joshed with him a bit and tried to get him to shoot one more cylinder full. The son was having none of it. He stuck to shooting 32's out of my 327 SP101 while his dad and I finished up the box of 357's. My friend didn't have too much trouble with them. The grips are the perfect size for his small but strong hands. He does not love recoil, grimaced a few times, and was not as accurate as with the 38's, but he did fine. I did okay. I couldn't get a really good grip on it, but I am used to heavier calibers and did not find the recoil to be painful or alarming. I was more accurate with the 38's, though.

So, after the long rambling story... I got my Hogue monogrips for $10 and most people find them to be an enormous improvement. 38 special is an effective round and far easier to shoot out of an SP101 (imho). The 327 version will shoot at least four different kinds of ammo. Shooting 32 H&R magnum out if it is a great choice if you want a round on par with 38 special in effectiveness, but with significantly less recoil. The 327 magnum round is supposed to be close to the 357 in effectiveness - I found it noticeably spicier than the 32 H&R, but nowhere near 357 recoil.

That was just my two cents. Here is a gratuitous picture of my 4" 327 with the exotic wood grips.

7139ec28-578a-4655-be3a-f30a26c85d74_zpsotqeajqm.jpg
I also have the 4" 327. Curious if you have found a holster to accommodate it.
 
Yep, that's a handful. Wifey and I only shoot +p's in her SP and it works just fine. I'd trust my life to it if I had to.
 
Last week, at the range I touched off a standard 357 mag in an SP 101 Ruger and almost dropped the gun. Tried again yesterday and same results. I can still shoot a J frame 38 special but not a hot load. I have an appointment with an orthopedist but I am covering all bases and thinking about A 32 H&R mag, a low recoil 38 Special, or a 22lr pt22 Taurus that I can point shoot well. Has any one here had experience with Liberty Munitions Civil Defense loads ? If my wrist continues to deteriorate I may have to go to the 22lr.

any advice appreciated,

blindhari
I have severe arthritis in my hands also...so shooting .357 loads is relegated to my Security Six. I shoot .38+P's thru my SP101 without any pain.

Remember, when it comes to recoil, weight is your friend, so I would consider keeping the SP101 in .357 and change its diet to .38+P's. You could also install a new set of grips that absorbs some of the recoil too.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top