Torn: Practical Or Fun

[pinetree64]

I've saved some b-day money and am torn between a 3" Ruger SP101 or 4" GP100 either in 357 - practical and a FN Hi-Power - fun.

I've always loved Hi-Powers and 9mm is so cheap to shoot. I'd like to use it in my clubs action pistol, but I never can make the meets. It it is too big to CC and would spend most of the time in my truck or safe. I have a couple of 1911's that I reload for but the HiPower would give me a similiar gun that has cheap bulk ammo for those time I don't want to reload.

The 357 is a powerful multi-use gun at home in the woods or in the night stand. My current snubby is a 38 and gets CC and nightstand duty and I really appreciate the simplicity of a revolver. I enjoy spending time in the woods and like having a sidearm. I usually carry snubby 38 or an compact 45.

But, the HP is sexy.

So many guns, so little money.

Thanks,
tjg

 

[SpookyPistolero]

If you think you'd get more use out of the GP, then I would get that. You'd have the same trigger pull in your hiking/bedisde gun as for your carry piece, and there is a lot to be said for that.

That said, are you sure the HP is too big for carry? I carry a 1911 and from those I talk to, the HP is at least as easy to carry in a good holster ( I don't have an HP). Unless you're worried about large 4-legged troubles, the HP would also serve you on the trail, not to mention the nightstand.

I think you'll be happy with either from the sound of things.

 

[DirksterG30]

I've always loved Hi-Powers and 9mm is so cheap to shoot. I'd like to use it in my clubs action pistol, but I never can make the meets. It it is too big to CC and would spend most of the time in my truck or safe.

I wouldn't say that it is too big for concealed carry. It all depends on the holster & belt you use. I sometimes carry a commander-sized 1911 (4" barrel) and have no problems concealing it. Many people carry a With the HP, you can also get a shorter slide if you'd rather carry a pistol with a shorter barrel (I believe the shorter slide is called the Detective).

 

[Vitamin G]

I carry either a BHP or a full size 1911. A nice shoulder holster or a brommeland will make either disappear. Other holsters make them disappear too, but those are my experiences.

 

[Jiml3]

If you are interested in buying new, Browing has a model they call "The Detective". It's a High Power with a shorter barrel & slide.

Good Luckwhatever you choose!

 

[donkee]

Get the FN. They aren't going to be around (new in box) for much longer. The Rugers will still be around.......

 

[Rob1035]

If you are interested in buying new, Browing has a model they call "The Detective". It's a High Power with a shorter barrel & slide.

Isn't that an aftermarket job? I didn't know Browning offers this version (at least not on their website)

 

[Shear_stress]

I think the "Detective" conversion is made by FM in Argentina. Sarco's got 'em. They'll sell you the whole gun as well.

 

[raghorn]

I'd choose the FN. As noted above, once they're gone, you've lost the opportunity, and you'll be kicking yourself for passing up a great deal. The Rugers will likely be around for a long time to come.

In an IWB holster the FN Hi-Power carries and conceals as easily as the shorter, FM-95 Detective. I started out with the Detective thinking the HP would be too big, but once I got an FN, I found that the difference was not noticeable. Now I only carry the FN.

Order the FN now, and starting today, put a dollar a day into a jar. Then you can buy yourself that Ruger for your next birthday.