Trade KelTec PF9 and Glock 22 for Springfield XD9sc?

Status
Not open for further replies.
D

dcdub

Member
Joined
Jan 23, 2011
Messages
108
Location
North Carolina
I love my G22. It was my first handgun, I shoot well with it, and I know that if I ever need to pull the trigger it's going to do what its supposed to do. Unfortunately, however, because of its large size it rarely makes it out of the house with me. That's why I bought the KelTec PF9 for CC, which I recently lost all faith in when the assembly pin walked itself out and sheared off at my last trip to the range. Also the magazine falls out after almost every shot. The one in the chamber always goes bang though!
So I want to upgrade my CC to a 9mm subcompact XD (I'm thinking it will make a nice nightstand gun as well with the extended grip mag) but I'm a little tight on cash as every extra penny we earn is going toward our upcoming Euro trip. If I want the XD now, I have to trade both guns in for it or my wife will use it on me. Should I tough it out for awhile and wait till I have all the cash or dump the KelTec asap (which also involves dumping the Glock)? What do you guys think?
-Thanks
 
I carry a Kel Tec everyday, but I'd either find a way out of that lemon, or send it back to KT for repair. They have excellent customer service, and I'm certain they can resolve the issue. Personally, I'd try that route first.

Therefore, I'd keep both of them, especially since you like the G22 so much. No need at all to dump that jewel. Just get the KT fixed. If a trip back to Florida doesn't garner your trust in the pistol, at least when you go to sell it, it will be in better shape than it is now.
 
Yeah I've been in contact with them. Their customer service is great, you're right. They sent me 2 new assembly pins, a mag catch, and a new mag, no questions asked. I haven't made it to the range yet to see if the new mag resolved the issue, and the pin could have been my fault, but I'm not comfortable carrying a gun that can fail like that either way. I'm a fan of the dummy-proof reassembly of the glocks. Even before I had these issues with the PF9 I wasn't too happy with it. I actually don't mind shooting it; the recoil isn't nearly as bad as everyone makes it out to be, and I get pretty good groups with the thing. Its a little too big for pocket carry for me, which is why I wanted it. If I have to carry IWB I'd rather have something a little easier to get a grip on with a few extra rounds as well.
 
I carry a pf-9 ever day and have run around 850 rounds through it no problems. If the parts they sent don't make it right call talk to the repair guys and have it sent back for repair while you'll are off travlin. Write out the problems and they tend to do well at make a problem go away. I also have a p-11 and a glock 27. Maybe trade your G-22 on a 27??
 
I love my G22. It was my first handgun, I shoot well with it, and I know that if I ever need to pull the trigger it's going to do what its supposed to do.
Click to expand...

If you can say this about a defensive gun, don't get rid of it.

I agree with coromo. Get the pf9 fixed. A lot of people are very happy with their pf9's. Hopefully keltec will make it right.
 
As much of a fan of Springfield I am, I say stick with what you have. The XD isn't that much of an upgrade, and you are already familiar with the weapons you have. To me, the XD still feels really wide when I CC, so it may feel just as awkward to CC for you as well. It is also short and stubby and when loaded, feels magazine weighted. Don't get me wrong, I like the XD9SC decent enough, but there is no special attachment to it.

Have you sent the Keltec back for service? I have heard that they have excellent customer service, but I haven't experienced it myself.
 
put that glock in service!

I think I would most definitely NOT go through with your proposed trade. Two guns for one that isn't of obviously more value has buyers remorse written all over it. And then you would be down one gun! I hate that feeling.

So I would take a look at getting that g22 in service if you can and are willing to make the investment in carrying a full sized pistol. A good iwb holster and good belt can make hauling that beast relatively easy. And the payoff for a little inconvenience seems well worth it to me - you will have a weapon you are proficient with that is more capable than the pf9 will ever be. FWIW, my everyday carry setup is a service size xd9 in a crossbreed supertuck and wilderness original instructor belt.

Oh, and get that kel tec back running! What good is a busted up gun? :D
 
There is no way I would make that trade. I would contact Kel Tec & get another assembly pin & magazine catch. Then I would save my pennies until I could get a subcompact I liked better.
 
Well I made it to the range yesterday to try out the kel tec with the new mag catch and new mag, still no good so looks like I'll be shipping it off to Florida, which I'm not crazy about but I'm sure they'll take care of me.
The range I visited happened to have an XD9sc rental which I'm really grateful for because now I know that I don't think I could carry it comfortably. I think I'll be looking into a g26. Looks like I'm going to have to think about dropping a few lbs to make room for the g22 while the pf9 is in Florida for 4-6 weeks. Thanks for all your help guys
 
Hi, this is my first post here. I hope it's a valid one. For my nickel I'd dump the PF9 in a second. While I don't own one myself, my best friend does and he's had a ton of problems with it, it drop mags every other shot or so, it's broken the last round hold open, the it's had the mag catch replaced. I personally own a Ruger LCP, Hi-Point C9, S&W 4516-1 and a Springfield XD40SC. I love my Springfield! This gun is my EDC, it's accurate, durable, and reliable. I've put about 500 rounds through mine without a FTF, FTE etc... WELL WORTH THE MONEY

DCDUB, what makes you think it would not be a good CC option. I'm 6'0" and 225 lbs it's never been a problem for me with my Kholster.
 
Don't do it. Keep your guns. Also, try the SR9c..... It will out shoot the XD any day of the week. I had a 4" XD and didn't find it to be very accurate or at least no more than a Glock, and a glock has polygonal rifling so your getting better ballistics. Try The SR9c before you buy the Springfield. The XD is a brick in the width department
 
It just felt like a brick to me, even next to a glock. I'm sure the right holster makes all the difference, but I just can't imagine myself getting used to it IWB.
 
That's why I bought the KelTec PF9 for CC, which I recently lost all faith in when the assembly pin walked itself out and sheared off at my last trip to the range. Also the magazine falls out after almost every shot. The one in the chamber always goes bang though!
Click to expand...

Have you sent it back to KT??
My PF9 went bonkers and trigger wouldn't reset.
KT replaced the gun. The "new" one shoots like a dream. Also, did you listen for the "click" the last time you put your PF9 together??? It's possible to put the pin in and think it's all the way in. That's why the PF9 manual says to listen for the click as the pin seats in.
 
I carry a PF9 80% of the time...Mine at first dropped mags as well...you may allready know this but when you slide the mag into the gun you have to hold the mag catch in otherwise it destroys the catch on the inside and results in that problem.. KT sent me a new spring and mag catch..I replaced them in a matter of minutes and have since put at least 1000 rounds thru the gun without a hiccup...
 
I'm about 99.9% sure I had the pin all the way. I want to believe that I didn't, I hope I didn't, but I'm pretty sure I did. Also 2 range officers inspected the gun before I shot it, I would think one of them would have noticed but I suppose its possible they did not.
I replaced the mag catch once already and it worked well for about 100 rounds, then it started happening again. I always depress the mag release when inserting. The pin could have been operator error but this mag situation definitely is not. I'm going to try to get it shipped off this afternoon. Hopefully the shop that sold me the dang thing will ship it for me because I really don't wanna have to pay ups big $$ to overnight the thing
 
Im not a huge fan of glocks, but if you are comfortable and proficient with it, the G22 would be a fine carry gun. A friend of mine caries one almost everywhere, and usually does so without a trace of a print. The PF9 is also a fine choice, actually the one my wife carries daily. I had the same issue with the mag release when her gun was new, but changing ammo to non +p, and adjusting my grip a little made the issue go away. Seems it was more a small pistol/big hands combined with a touchy mag release. it has since seen several hundred rounds without further issue. Trading the two pistols for one just doesnt seem like good math to me.
 
As to your choice of weapons for carry, that's totally up to you. But in terms of value (dollars spent for used guns), I think you miight do better by SELLING your two guns and buying a used Springfield.

(And you need to talk with Kel-Tec about the problems you've had with the PF-9 and at least let the factory fix it before you sell it.)
 
Somewhere near you there is a gun dealer drooling right now. If it were me, I would not even think of trading any Glock for any XD, there is just not anything under the sun that makes an XD worth as much as a Glock, and I own both. I got the XD for a little of nothing from a friend, and it is an adequate gun but nowhere near a Glock. Sell that KT and save up for a G22 or G27 or whatever.;)
 
Well I made it to the range yesterday to try out the kel tec with the new mag catch and new mag, still no good so looks like I'll be shipping it off to Florida, which I'm not crazy about but I'm sure they'll take care of me.
Click to expand...

I think you made the right choice in getting it fixed rather than trading 2 for 1. The 22 is the gold standard in the "ugly but performs" arena. The PF9 is much prettier but is also a performer. It probably just needed a trip back to the factory.
 
Alright so I'm definitely not getting the Springfield after shooting it. I'm going to hang on to my Glock. The Kel-Tec... I'm still undecided on. I called them today to see if there was anything else we could try before mailing it in so they're sending me a 3rd mag catch and a new mag follower. I would imagine I have the newest follower in the mag they just sent me last week, but I'll give it a try and see if it works. The lady said some of the catches and followers don't get along for some reason and that changing them out has fixed the problem for a lot of people. If I can get this thing up and running to where I trust it I might just try to see if I can talk my wife into carrying it AND get a G26 or something. If my math is correct, I will have more guns than if I traded 2 in for one. I think I got that right =)
 
I love my G22. It was my first handgun, I shoot well with it, and I know that if I ever need to pull the trigger it's going to do what its supposed to do. Unfortunately, however, because of its large size it rarely makes it out of the house with me.
Click to expand...

Why don't you cut the G22 handle down to G23 length? There is a local cop who wins dang near every pistol shooting contest in S. Fla with his carry gun: a G17 cut down to G19 length. That way you get G23 concealability and a G22 sight picture. Also you can still use your G22 mags just like you would with the XD you proposed purchasing.
 
Send in the Kel-Tec. Let the experts there fix it even if it costs a little something.

I agree trading will result in severe buyers remorse. Don't do it.

All the Best,
D. White
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

A
  • Locked
Keltec PF9. Shaving primers.
Replies
6
Views
433
evan price
evan price
C
  • Locked
Glock or HK Help!
2
Replies
38
Views
2K
onelastshot
O
W
  • Locked
So I decided that my XD9sc was a mistake, suggestions for fullsize?
2
Replies
26
Views
1K
WNC Seabee
W
L
  • Locked
Thinkin about trading my G19 for a xd subcompact
2
Replies
42
Views
1K
ForumSurfer
F
S
  • Locked
Area Man's Troubles with a Kel-tec PF9 Resolved by a Glock 26
Replies
11
Views
1K
JohnBT
J
Back
Top