CNYCacher
Member
Pulled into the hardware store today and as I got out of my truck, a lady getting into her car struck up a conversation with me. She had seen the parking sticker on my window for a club I belong to.
"Do you go to that shooting club?"
"Excuse me?"
-points to the sticker- "Do you go to that club?"
"Oh. Yeah I do? Are you a member there too?"
"No, I can hear the shooting from my house though. It bothers me."
She was very non-combative. She merely stated matter of factly that the sound bothered her. In an equally calm tone, I replied.
"Well, ma'am, that club is older than you are, which means you moved into the vicinity. Did you know the club was there when you moved into the area?"
"Yeah I did. . . I just didn't think it would be such a problem, they are shooting all the time. Couldn't there be posted hours?"
Now, this particular club is not heavily used. Unless the trap league is there for a practice or a meet, you are likely to find it deserted. Even on a Saturday afternoon on a nice sunny day, it is likely to be empty when I go.
"Yes, the hours are 8 am to sunset."
And then an idea struck me.
"Ma'am, if the sound bothers you, keep in mind that almost all shooters would love to put sound suppressors on their guns, except it is illegal under NY law. Perhaps your government reps would like to hear your opposition to that law."
"Well, that sounds like a much more fair plan than trying to get the club shut down. Some of my neighbors would like to do that, but I don't think it would be fair to you guys. I just don't like the sound is all.
Then she left.
Overall a nice conversation with a nice lady.
Has anyone else tried a similar "If you don't like the noise, try to get silencers [legalized,untaxed]." approach? How did it work?
This particular club fought off a big lawsuit to get them shut down a few years ago. Some guy bought the adjascent property and built a huge house, and then sued to get the club closed. He lost obviously. Club legend has it that most of the berms disappeared during the time that he was building his driveway
There is significant new construction going on around the club, we shall see how long they hold out.
"Do you go to that shooting club?"
"Excuse me?"
-points to the sticker- "Do you go to that club?"
"Oh. Yeah I do? Are you a member there too?"
"No, I can hear the shooting from my house though. It bothers me."
She was very non-combative. She merely stated matter of factly that the sound bothered her. In an equally calm tone, I replied.
"Well, ma'am, that club is older than you are, which means you moved into the vicinity. Did you know the club was there when you moved into the area?"
"Yeah I did. . . I just didn't think it would be such a problem, they are shooting all the time. Couldn't there be posted hours?"
Now, this particular club is not heavily used. Unless the trap league is there for a practice or a meet, you are likely to find it deserted. Even on a Saturday afternoon on a nice sunny day, it is likely to be empty when I go.
"Yes, the hours are 8 am to sunset."
And then an idea struck me.
"Ma'am, if the sound bothers you, keep in mind that almost all shooters would love to put sound suppressors on their guns, except it is illegal under NY law. Perhaps your government reps would like to hear your opposition to that law."
"Well, that sounds like a much more fair plan than trying to get the club shut down. Some of my neighbors would like to do that, but I don't think it would be fair to you guys. I just don't like the sound is all.
Then she left.
Overall a nice conversation with a nice lady.
Has anyone else tried a similar "If you don't like the noise, try to get silencers [legalized,untaxed]." approach? How did it work?
This particular club fought off a big lawsuit to get them shut down a few years ago. Some guy bought the adjascent property and built a huge house, and then sued to get the club closed. He lost obviously. Club legend has it that most of the berms disappeared during the time that he was building his driveway
There is significant new construction going on around the club, we shall see how long they hold out.