US Pastor Held in Russia over box of ammo

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Sep 4, 2005
Messages
3,213
Location
Amerikan Twilight Zone
http://www.themoscowtimes.com/stories/2008/02/11/012.html

Monday, February 11, 2008. Issue 3839. Page 3.

U.S. Pastor to Be Held for 2 Months

By David Nowak
Staff Writer

A Moscow court has ordered a U.S. pastor to remain in detention for two months while prosecutors investigate him on suspicion of smuggling ammunition into the country, a U.S. Embassy spokeswoman said Sunday.

Phillip Miles, a pastor of the Christ Community Church in Conway, South Carolina, was detained at Sheremetyevo Airport on Feb. 3, days after rifle rounds were discovered in his luggage.

Miles remained on Sunday in the airport holding cell where he was taken after being detained, the spokeswoman said, speaking on customary condition of anonymity.

At Friday's hearing, the Golovinsky District Court, which has jurisdiction over Sheremetyevo, ordered Miles be moved to a different, "interim facility," the spokeswoman said. It was unclear when that would happen.

"After [Friday's] preliminary hearing, Miles remains in detention on charges that may include trafficking, with a potential sentence of a monetary fine or four years imprisonment, and smuggling, with a potential sentence of three to seven years," the spokeswoman said.

Airport officials seized the ammunition when Miles entered Russia on Jan. 29. Officials allowed Miles to continue on his trip to Perm, where he met fellow church members, on the proviso that he check in with them at Sheremetyevo on the way back to the United States.

When he did, he was detained on suspicion of smuggling the ammunition, which he admitted he failed to declare, as required by law, according to friends.

The bullets were a gift for a pastor in Perm, who was a fellow hunting enthusiast, according to the embassy spokeswoman and Miles' associates.

Neither the law enforcement body that detained Miles nor the location of the court could be established as of Sunday. The embassy spokeswoman did not have immediate access to the information and calls to prosecutors, the Federal Security Service and the Moscow City Court went unanswered.

Two lawyers contacted Sunday said authorities' treatment of Miles was within the law.

"If he was unsure, all he had to do was approach a customs official and ask if he should declare the bullets," Sergei Melnikov, a lawyer who specializes in customs and immigration issues, said on Sunday.

"Checking one box on the declarations form could have saved him all this trouble," Melnikov added.

Igor Trunov, a criminal lawyer who deals with high-profile cases, said a number of factors could have compounded Miles' situation.

"It all depends on how he acted when he was stopped," Trunov said. "If it appeared to customs officials that he was trying to hide the fact that he had the ammunition in the suitcase, that would have aroused their suspicion," he added.

Friends insist that Miles' intentions were good.

The 60-days holding time was nothing sinister, Trunov said, because authorities would need the time to run complex background checks on Miles, which are complicated by the fact that he is not Russian.

"And his line that the bullets were a present would in no way reduce his responsibility," he added.

Dominic Starr, a friend and fellow church member, said by telephone from South Carolina on Sunday that Friday's ruling was "not completely unexpected" but expressed confidence that Miles' "record of total integrity" would lead to his release.

In a statement on its web site, the Christ Community Church called Friday's ruling a "temporary setback."
 
Hey, it's the law. He broke the law, and now he is suffering the consequences. If you break the law, it means you are a criminal. And we all know that criminals should always go to jail. It's just what you do. Don't question it.

-Sans Authoritas
 
Bottom line -- he tried to smuggle a box of ammo into the country. What's to debate?

This is very different than if a couple of loose rounds from his last hunting trip were found in the bottom of his suitcase. It's pretty well understood that even a single cartridge in your luggage or in the trunk of your car will put you in the slammer in Mexico. This wasn't an accident, that was a deliberate act.
 
Seems like the Russians are going through a lot of expense over the box. Yeah, they are well within their rights to investigate this guy, and he evidently needed merely to declare the ammo (in any case, he should have ensured he was complying with all rules and fundamentally is at fault). But this could have so very easily been cleared up with explanation. If he is a smuggler, then he is doing it in a most inefficient way. The Russians are doing some saber-rattling these days, and this is probably part of it.

Ash
 
I'm surprised that you can take ammo into Russia if you declare it. I was under the impression that people were only allowed to have ammo in the caliber they were 'certified' for or whatever.

I must say though, he was pretty stupid for bringing ammo in. I wouldn't ever transport ammo when visiting another country. I'd get my friend a different gift, or take him to a store to buy ammo while in the country.

I'd say Ash is probably right about the saber-rattling. The whole case seems like a colossal waste of time for everyone involved.
 
Russian gun laws are stupid in many ways. That doesn't make breaking them a smart idea. IIRC, you aren't allowed to have ammo for guns you are not licensed to own. I feel sorry for the guy, but he really should have been more careful.

"Can I send <some gun related thing> to my friend/cousin in Russia?" is a pretty common question on Russian forums, and the answer for ammo is "NO".
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top