U.S. Pastor Gets 3+ Years for 20rds in Russia

Status
Not open for further replies.

shdwfx

Member
Joined
Feb 3, 2008
Messages
579
Location
Go Bucks!
U.S. Pastor Given More Than 3 Years in Prison for Bringing Rifle Shells Into Russia

MOSCOW — A Moscow court on Monday sentenced a U.S. pastor to more than three years in prison for smuggling hunting ammunition into Russia.

Phillip Miles, from South Carolina, has been in custody since his arrest on Feb. 3. He was arrested several days after customs agents at a Moscow airport found a box of 20 rifle shells in his luggage.

The court sentenced him to serve three years and two months in prison, with the sentence calculated from his detention date.

Miles has said he brought the .300 caliber cartridges for a friend who had recently bought a Winchester rifle. He said he did not know bringing such ammunition into Russia was illegal.

Judge Olga Drozdova accepted in her 20-minute summation that Miles had brought the ammunition for a friend, "as they are both inveterate hunters."

The cartridges were not initially found as he flew into Moscow. They were detected a day later as airport security put his luggage through an X-ray machine while he was on his way to check in for a flight to Perm, a city in Siberia.

Miles was dressed in a gray jacket and clerical collar for his sentencing.

"I'm very disappointed. It's a strange sentence for one box of hunting bullets," he said as court bailiffs led him in handcuffs from the courtroom cage, where defendants in Russian criminal courts are held during trial.

His lawyer said the sentence was surprisingly severe.

"I hoped he would only be found guilty of the illegal possession of ammunition," Vladimir Ryakhovsky said.

He said the conviction for smuggling was unfounded as his client had acted without any intent to break the law.

An appeal will be filed within 10 days, he said.

Miles seemed relaxed throughout the judge's summation.

His interpreter struggled to keep up with the judge's delivery and stopped at various points throughout the sentencing. At one point, Miles tapped the interpreter's elbow to remind her to resume.

Miles has admitted bringing in the shells, but said he did not bother to check if Russian laws differed from U.S. laws.

But Drozdova said the court could not condone ignorance of Russian customs regulations and noted Miles had visited the country more than 10 times.

She also stressed repeatedly that information on baggage limitations was available in the airport in both English and Russian.

Ryakhovsky said, however, that leaflets in the airport contained no specific references to a prohibition on taking cartridges onto flights.

"The judge's finding on that front was dishonest," he said.

Miles will remain in a Moscow jail until the appeal.
 
Sigh. Other people's countries. I hope his appeal goes well, and he can leave that formerly (currently?) evil empire.
 
I hope that the people who post dumb ideas like, "I plan to go to country x and carry my gun because I got rights" will think again. That sentence was surprisingly heavy, but in some countries smuggling of guns or ammunition can bring the death penalty. And no, the Second Amendment doesn't apply in Africa or Asia or other backward areas like England and New York.

Jim
 
Another good reason to not travel abroad. The USA is a pretty fine country with deserts, forests, sub-tropical paradises, mountains, and fruited plains. Some of the most interesting geographic features in the world are here and I am convinced we have the best cities. Why go elsewhere anyway?
 
Let's just hope that something good comes out of this. Many Bible stories start with an unfortunate set of circumstances at the begining and end up with result only God would have planned. Pray for this man!
 
Well, as they write in the first few pages of our passports, when you're in a foreign country, you are subject to foreign laws. Although this is unfortunate, at the same time I think he should have known better to check whether or not his actions were legal or not. After all, most European countries take a ill view of anything related to weapons or hunting.

Flip side, it is Russia, and they are known to have some of the most byzantine laws on the books, close to the degree of you will break X law by following Y law and vice-versa.

The other thing is, bribery doesn't work too well in Russia, all a bribe will do is get people to process your paper-work faster. Its known in the business circles as one of the most ass-backwards bribery systems known to man. But, it does have the historical roots of civil servants being expected to earn their salary via bribes.
 
Today, 12:37 PM #12
Gaiudo wrote:


Still, three years for stupid?
__________________
Nicholas Ellis


No. Three years for smuggling ammunition. I imagine with 10 visits under his belt, the judge might have imagined he had gotten away with smuggling 10 times already.
 
When he was first arrested a few months ago it was reported that if he had simply declared that he had the ammo and that it was a gift - he would have been completely within the law. He just didn't know he had to declare it.

Sucks to spend 3 years in a Russian prison for such a little mistake. But since he is a minister and looking at it from a Christian perspective, who knows what kind of impact he may have to his fellow prisoners.
 
You think it would have been different had the Russian been coming to the U.S.?

Quite honestly, I don't know. It certainly isn't illegal to check ammunition on domestic flights. Not even for non-citizens. I imagine he'd get hassled by the TSA, but who knows?
 
Gee, I shouldn't call the (Russian) consulate (in the U.S.) about the legality and procedures of bringing ammunition into Russia?

Some people!
 
Still, three years for stupid?
No. Three years for smuggling ammunition.

Um. We're talking about a single box of ammo for a friend. 20 rounds. In ignorance (yes, I know that's not a defense).

Letter of the law? Yes, I guess that's "smuggling." But, that's why a court system has judges instead of a machine handing out sentences.
 
Ignorance of the law is not an excuse. When you travel to another country you should expect to be bound to the laws of that state. While it seems heavy-handed here in the United States, we are looking at a country that has very different views on the civilian ownership of firearms and ammunition.

He broke the law and should be punished according to the normal sentence for that offense.
 
Yeah, I guess if one guy had a bad experience traveling, I should deny myself the experience of enjoying all this world has to offer outside of our borders. Now that is a very sad, small way of thinking.
 
This goes to show that one should read all the forms. I find it strange that someone with an extensive travel iternirary did not know that ammo had to be declared.

P.S. I suspect that the judge though he was smuggling sniper rounds for the cechens. Hence the harsh sentence.

P.S.S. A friend had optics confiscated by Russian authorities several years back.

P.S.S.S. A moderator on guns.ru (who is a professional gunsmith) got several years for possessing a singe round of 9x18 mm

Russian gun laws are brutal, as is the Russian criminal justice system. It is a very bad idea to try and bring in or take out any gun related items.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top