Well, finally happened. Doozie of a claim.

Status
Not open for further replies.

hksw

Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2002
Messages
4,157
Location
OH
I've always read and enjoyed some of the outrageous claims made by people and related here at THR but I never really had one myself to contribute. The closest, IIRC, was a dealer at a gun show stating one of the rifles he was selling, an RPK parts gun built on an AK receiver, will shoot quarter (25 cent piece) sized groups at 200 yds all day long. That is, until today.

I had to watch a product being manufacture on the plant floor to try to determine the problem the customer was having with it. The operator working the machine is one I had talked to on occassion as I'm on the floor often. Previously, about a month ago, a co-worker friend had mentioned to hiim that I was at this year's CMP National Sporter shoot at Camp Perry recently. The operator struck up a conversation at the time concerning firearms and conveyed that he had a few and recently purchase a ".38 auto" for his wife. Immediately I was thinking ".38 Colt or.38 Super" and asked. He wasn't familiar with those so I helped him along and it sounded like he meant .380 ACP (gun was a Bersa). Conversation continued on small stuff, mentioned that he was in Desert Storm as a Marine, shot .50 BMGwhile there, etc. He wasn't too familiar with the laws concerning .50 BMG and thought it was illegal. Tried to set him straight but wasn't sure he understood.

Fast forward to today. Had to work with him again today. As we're watching the process, firearms again came up (by him). Asked what I like to shoot and mentioned that in the past 4-5 years I've been focusing on .22 lr and .17 HMR. Prior to that, it was probably .308/7.62. Then goes on to ask handguns and mention probably 9mm as it is the caliber I have the most platforms for. He had inquired how many I had and not being the type to divulge that information, merely stated, "a few". Goes on to say he has 12, a couple 9s, a .40, .45, etc. and mentions again (correctly this time) his wife's .380. From here on, things get interesting.

He mentions that he doesn't like shooting the .40SW because the gun is a Glock. At which I'm thinking it's probably the block shape of the girth of the grip as I don't like that feature much myself on my G34. Before I could ask if it was this and much to my surprise, he says he doesn't like grip safety of his Glock (indicating where the position of the safety is on the web of his hand). It causes him to grip the gun oddly causing inaccuracy in his shooting abilities.

Personally, I'm not the type of person who corrects a BSer unless the information is dangerous. I just like to sit back and let them dig their own holes and see how far they get. So, I let him run.

He goes on how when he was in the Marines how he was heavily into competition and has all of the gear needed for it. This included PMI clothing. Not being or having been in the military, I did not know what PMI was and inquired to which he describes its got padding on the shoulder, etc.
"Oh", I said,"a shooting jacket".
"Yeah, I've got all of that stuff", he says.
I ask, "You use a shooting glove?".
His reply was,"No, I like the feel of the trigger on my finger."
Personally, I've never seen a serious shooter with a shooting glove on their shooting hand but rarely ever see one without one on their weak hand, which is what I was asking about (I use one myself for position shooting). I let that little tidbit go.

Continues to describe how he has won 5 competitions in handgun (M9) and 10 in rifle while in the Marines.
I had asked, "With an M16 or M14?"
He says, "M16."
Goes on to give a few specs, muzzle velocity being "800 ft/sec". I asked again and he restated "800 ft/sec". I figure he meant 800 meters/sec but didn't correct.

To describe his abilities, he had mentioned that he was able to shoot 10 rounds into a group the size of a quarter (25 cent piece) at 500 YARDS! With an M16! Iron sights! I was proud of myself of being able to even suppress a smile and just complimented him on his skill. Asked where he was taught, mentions Quantico.
In fact, he (and his group)was taught by, "...what's his name....can't remember...he's a famous Marine sniper...he has a few books..."
I offer, "Hathcock?"
Him, "No...I think his name was Rodriguez?...wait...what's that guy's first name?"
Me, "Carlos."
Him, "Yeah, that's him, Carlos Hathorn." (Laughing inside.) "Yeah, met him in 2003."
At this point, I knew Carlos had passed away, didn't know when but was sure it was before 2000. I let him continue. I think he was a little iffy on that bit of information, particularly considering I at least knew Carlos Hathcock's name, and he started to backpeddle a little.
Him, "Wait, didn't he die before that?"
I feigned ignorance and say, "I don't know."
Him, "I'll have to check my records and get back with you tomorrow."
Him, "Yeah, I love shooting."

Some additional ancillary discussion not worth notingother than he still thinks .50 BMG, particularly the Barretts, are illegal for civilian purchase/ownership.

I could have corrected him along the way but would have risked gaining his ire to which he would probaly never speak to me again. Why would I want to remove a source of humor? I will certainly NOT invite him to the range to see his mad skillz as it will probably mean allowing him to try some of my stuff and I do not want him to try on my shooting gear and handle my CMP AR or any of my other guns.
 
Wow... you have FAR more restraint than I could have mustered on such short notice.


Seriously, I would have to practice my poker-face all morning in the mirror before having that conversation.


-- John
 
Talk him up and see if hes willing to bet son some shooting. I have made quite a bit of $$ doing this. I act all silly, let them talk their sillyness, then go on out... 5 bux a shot... Pays for a good bit of ammo, hee hee
 
CDignition,
That is the best idea that I have heard in a while.
I have a guy at work who was a sniper in the 1st cavalry in the army in 1991.
Said he would go prone on his Sherman's turret with a .270 M27???
BTW he has 347 confirmed kills!!!!
 
You can really hold yourself. I'm not the most knowledgeable guy but I'll sure keep my mouth shut if I don't know. Or if is a nice person I'll ask so I can learn too.
"There is no stupid questions just stupid people that don't ask". my professor said that (long time ago) lol
 
I used to work with a guy who was either a green beret or a ranger depending on what day it was. He was part of the force that went to panama where he was a sniper with a .50 cal semi auto browning A-bolt.:rolleyes:
 
YOU KNOW, BS IS PART OF BEING A MAN. or rather, a hunter, shooter, fisher, etc.

but when you BS to the point where you're embarassing yourself badly... that's just sad.
 
YOU KNOW, BS IS PART OF BEING A MAN. or rather, a hunter, shooter, fisher, etc.

but when you BS to the point where you're embarassing yourself badly... that's just sad.

Acceptable BS:

"I caught a fish _THIS BIG_!"

Unacceptable BS:

"I shot a fish _THIS BIG_! Yeah, that was back when I was a SEAL Ranger over in the 'Stan during Desert Storm in '93. Used my issued .218 M-16, 400 yards out in a 30 MPH wind, open sights, put five shots in 'im on full auto. All the while dodging sniper fire from the skinnys. Had to fight my way out with my .50 Desert Eagle, got ten gooks with my first mag. You should have been there, it was great. I miss the Marine life sometimes, though, and all the cool guns. Had to turn in the M-16, the AUG, the AK-101, the DD-214...but I was able to sneak out a bunch of captured TEC-9s. I wish the government had a record of me, but I was classified by the CIA."
 
Yeah, and I once saw a bull that could **** with so much rectal velocity that it could trim 1/2" off of a unicorn's horn a 1,200 yds. with a single nugget.

:evil:
 
As a former Marine, you don't ever want to tell me you were in the Corps when you weren't. I take that real personally.
 
Interesting co-worker you got there.

Some info for your next meet with this gentlemen. PMI may stand for Primary Marksmanship Instructor/Instruction depending on the branch of service or topic of conversation.:)
 
You have more patience than me.
I'd just cut him short.
I don't know alot, but I know enough to know a BSer most of the time.

And that guy sounds like one.

Reminds me of the guy at WalMart, telling me he didn't like the 17HMR because it was not accurate.
Further into conversation, he explains that his rifle is a .22Mag. Yeah, that's right.
He says you can shoot .17HMR in a .22Mag rifle.
He said it was the same as a .357 Mag and 38's.
I gave up and left.
 
As a former Marine, you don't ever want to tell me you were in the Corps when you weren't. I take that real personally.

With respect, sir, I submit that you still ARE a Marine.

I had something interesting happen at Perry this year (Pistol Championships). I was asked if I would be going to the USMC Dinner, held in (I think) Oak Harbor this year. I did not go.

The person that went returned; said the prime rib was delicious, as was the rest of the meal, and was sporting a T-Shirt that said USMC Shooting Team--seems that people got them as a part of the paid admission. It was a good looking shirt, too.

The fellow had an extra and asked if I wanted it. I replied, "Yes, I'd like it--but I can't buy it from you since I can't wear it." He asked why, and I replied, "I haven't earned the right to wear that shirt."

That's just the way I feel.
 
Powderman:

Well, if it said "USMC Shooting Team Supporter".... :cool:

I don't see anything really wrong with "generic" T's either - I've been thinking of buying an IDF T-shirt just to shake up the gang at the club. :evil:

However, back to topic, I had a friend who always seemed to be one-up. If I bought a .38, he bought a .45.... Things like that. Or at least he'd claim that he'd done it. Sometimes it was a little bit of a headache, but I just got used to it. I was a lot younger then.... :p

Regards,
 
I've got one of those guys at work. He's so darn proud of buying ONLY Colt products. On and on about what he's buying and selling this week.

I casually asked if he's done any further concealed carry training since he got the permit..."Nah, I can shoot fine".

Seems like the more someone talks, the less they actually know what they're doing.
 
hksw,

The guy that you were speaking with on shop floor sounds like a union steward that I used to know.

salty.
 
"I shot a fish _THIS BIG_! Yeah, that was back when I was a SEAL Ranger over in the 'Stan during Desert Storm in '93. Used my issued .218 M-16, 400 yards out in a 30 MPH wind, open sights, put five shots in 'im on full auto. All the while dodging sniper fire from the skinnys. Had to fight my way out with my .50 Desert Eagle, got ten gooks with my first mag. You should have been there, it was great. I miss the Marine life sometimes, though, and all the cool guns. Had to turn in the M-16, the AUG, the AK-101, the DD-214...but I was able to sneak out a bunch of captured TEC-9s. I wish the government had a record of me, but I was classified by the CIA."

LOL. Now THAT'S laying it on thick. I almost wet myself reading that.

As a former Marine, you don't ever want to tell me you were in the Corps when you weren't. I take that real personally.
I would be pretty upset too if I had served my country and heard some jack*** make a claim like that. Posing as a servicemember because you think it makes you look "cool" is pretty disrespectful to those who actually did serve.
 
With respect, sir, I submit that you still ARE a Marine.

I had something interesting happen at Perry this year (Pistol Championships). I was asked if I would be going to the USMC Dinner, held in (I think) Oak Harbor this year. I did not go.

The person that went returned; said the prime rib was delicious, as was the rest of the meal, and was sporting a T-Shirt that said USMC Shooting Team--seems that people got them as a part of the paid admission. It was a good looking shirt, too.

The fellow had an extra and asked if I wanted it. I replied, "Yes, I'd like it--but I can't buy it from you since I can't wear it." He asked why, and I replied, "I haven't earned the right to wear that shirt."

That's just the way I feel.

The difference comes in when asked
"Hey where'dya get that shirt?"
Admitting it was given to you by some friends on the team is alot different then claiming you got it as a super secret squirrel out teaching Marines how to shoot or something.....
 
Uh...I hate to break it to you but he could have been telling the truth. Hathcock's son, Carlos, retired as a Sergeant Major from Quantico in 2005. He spent many years teaching at the sniper school and he ran the Marine Corps shooting team. His son was on my son's soccer team. I was floored when I was talking with his wife and realized who he was.

So this guy may have been taught by the other Carlos Hathcock (who is now a government civilian working at Quantico!).

Jim
 
Well,

I have to admit, that, yes, I am the guy who can shoot the wings off a fly at 500 yards with a Ruger 10/22 with a bent barrell. I usually use my M-16 Aug that I got from the french after getting Charles DeGualle some wine.

The "switch" goes to 11.......safe, fire, full, 11.

I spent 12 tours in Vietnam as a fighter pilot/tunnel rat.... yep, was also a Ranger Seal.

Wow, gotta stop eating those genoa salami and pepper sandwiches.....and watching Spinal Tap.
 
In my experience guys on this program aren't worth discrediting. They are best to avoid as much as possible and should never be encouraged to handle weapons to help suppport their over-stated background.

So hksw, good restraint.
 
As a former Marine, you don't ever want to tell me you were in the Corps when you weren't. I take that real personally

I thought, once a Marine, Always a Marine?

I am not trying to be a wise guy here, but anytime I hear a Marine mention the Corp, they are still a Marine? Correct me if I am wrong.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top