What's the point of a big knife?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I dont have a ton of knives, the two largest I own is an older model CS bushman and a Condor Hudson Bay. I only use the condor on hog hunts and I havent used the bushman in a long time. My edc blade is a buck model 110 folder that rides in a belt sheath I had custom made.
 
I've lived where people didn't have the money for multiple knives. Literally did not have the money to buy a second one. People who owned the clothes they wore and maybe one more change of clothes.

Invariably what they owned was a machete style/size knife. They used it for everything from chopping down trees to butchering game to clearing brush to carving toys out of wood. They didn't own little knives because while carving is awkward with a machete, cutting down a tree or clearing brush with a little knife is not really feasible.
 
The largest fixed blade knives I have are 5 inches. My go to field knife is usually 4 - 4.5 inches. The nice thing about a larger knife is that you can choke up a bit for smaller/finer tasks. I also had at RAT Cutlery (ESEE) 5, and found I never really used it, preferring a BRKT Bravo 1 for that role.
 
I generally like around a 4 inch blade (give or take), and I actually like a fixed blade over a folder if I think I am going to be doing significant work.

I have a 5 inch fixed blade that is awesome, and has become my go-to kitchen knife.

Any bigger is what I consider "big". I have a knife or two that is bigger than the kitchen knife, but honestly I don't see myself using them. If I spent a lot of time dressing big game maybe that would be different. Still glad to have them, and they're cool to own.



As others have stated, this is outside the scope of the machete. I have a couple of those and they are invaluable for their tasks. In the machete vs. hatchet debate... make mine a machete please, thanks.
 
In the "One Knife" scenario, one of the advantages of a large knife over a small one is there is more edge to use before it will get dull and need sharpened. To me they are clumsy to use for small tasks and I have mostly small tasks anyway. My three go to knives are the Blackjack 125, Kabar Becker BK-15, and Dozier Pro Guides Knife at the moment (general woods carry). Like a smaller knife for hunting chores. The Spyderco Moran works for me as does a large slip joint (GEC #42).

By the way, I use machetes far more than "big knives" chopping. But it can be fun to beat away at a limb or tree with a knife from time to time. My cheaper play toys are the Condor Kumunga and Condor Moonshiner. But for business, I go with the Condor Pack Golok or Village Parang for chopping limbs and so forth or a Condor 18" El Salvador latin machete for general wacking in my rather undergrown world in the SE.
 
Last edited:
Lots of reasons have been cited; I'll add one more. Because my ancestors did. They called it a sax, or seax. Though I will admit a small (12-14") Kukri is more practical.
 
22-rimfire

Same here with machetes: far more useful than most big blade knives I have. My most effective one is a 14" Corneta No. 127 machete. It's very handy at clearing out bulrushes, tall grass, tree saplings, and underbrush.

002_zps7538334d.jpg
 
In was a joke in reference to the caliber debates(9 vs .40 vs .45)...didn't work :).

I chuckled when I read it.

I agree with most of the earlier posters in that my preferred generalist outdoor fixed blade length is 4-5 in. I've found anything larger to be pretty fumbly for the finer tasks such as disassembling game. I'll also add that I think the most useful folder size is right around 3".
 
22-rimfire

Same here with machetes: far more useful than most big blade knives I have. My most effective one is a 14" Corneta No. 127 machete. It's very handy at clearing out bulrushes, tall grass, tree saplings, and underbrush.

002_zps7538334d.jpg

My 14" machete is the discontinued Condor Puerto Rican. Used that one a lot until I got the El Salvador. It has been replaced with a 16" design by Condor known as the Swamp Master. If it seems like I like Condor machetes, you're right.

My big blades other than the ones mentioned tend to be right at 7-7.5". I switch to machete when I need something longer. I do have a Condor Hudson Bay which I think has a 8.5" blade. The handle is a bit thin for me.

A big blade is actually one of the ones I am planning to purchase in the coming year. May just go custom on this one. Brian Griffin had one made and I am thinking I may just talk to the maker (Dylan Fletcher) and get something made similar. It won't get used much, but I will have fun ooh and aughing it. Don't know if the maker will be at Blade as an exhibitor (4D I believe), but he's in GA and within driving distance if I need to talk.
 
Last edited:
Interesting thread.

The main consideration is to what use do you expect from it?
Hunting Knife, Skinning Knife, Survival Knife, Camp knife????

Look at hunting knives:
I carried a small hatchet to break heavy bones.
My favorite hunting knife is a 4" custom design that I picked up in Alaska back in 1980.
With the small hatchet, I don't need anything larger to quarter an Elk or dress a deer.

Skinning knives:
I used to carry a 2 1/2" blade skinning knife along with my (pre-1980) hunting knife while bow hunting. It was nice to use, but didn't do any better than my Buck 110 folding hunter, so I quit carrying it.

Survival Knives:
As far as survival knives go, because they are used in situations where you are cut off from other equipment, survival knives are tasked with more varied uses than a camp knife.

A look at knives used by primitive people show large knives.
They are more useful than smaller knives for heavy tasks, and can also be used for small tasks.

When I flew the bush in Alaska back in the 1980s, I carried a two knife system.
This was a large 10" blade, and a Swiss Army knife.

Flying in Vietnam, I was issued a "Pilot's Survival Knife" (Still have it and use it) that has a 5" blade. However, all flight equipment has a weight consideration. I believe that this was the smallest design that the government believed to be adequate.

Neither knife came to be used in a "Survival" situation.

Back packing also has its weight of equipment considerations.
But here again, how will the knife really be used?
Will you really need to drop a small tree for shelter when you are carrying you camping gear with you?
A 4" blade should do all you ask in such a scenario.

So, Big knife - Little Knife?

While there are the super outdoorsmen who can disappear into the bush with a pair of nail clippers and build a shopping mall, for us mortals a strong consideration of what tasks our knife will actually be used for should be our guide.

When I was in a situation where I could be in a true survival situation, I chose a large knife.

For everything else I personally like knives in the 4" blade range.

silverfox001.jpg

EagleStrip-BearinCamp001.jpg

My 2 Cents,

Steve
 
So, Big knife - Little Knife?

While there are the super outdoorsmen who can disappear into the bush with a pair of nail clippers and build a shopping mall, for us mortals a strong consideration of what tasks our knife will actually be used for should be our guide.

When I was in a situation where I could be in a true survival situation, I chose a large knife.

I'm certain that if I find myself fighting the wilderness for survival, I am hosed no matter if I have a four-inch blade or a ten-inch one. :D That's one of those scenarios in which I would love to rise to the occasion but would probably dehydrate first.

Nice pictures, by the way. What's the story on the second one?
 
Blade I carried on my last two deployments. (In addition to the above.) Yes I know the hooks look kinda corny, but the handle is the most comfy thing I've ever had in my hand, and the blade is awesome.

Genuine question: did you use that knife? I recall reading a thread (either here or at Blade Forums) in which military personnel discussed the knives they carried during deployment, and the overwhelming majority carried folders. I distinctly recall one gentleman saying that he brought a large knife and left it behind because it became a PITA. Was that your experience?
 
I am known for using (and sometimes designing) very large knives.

I never expect to do "camp stuff" like chopping wood when I'm deployed.
 
I skinned this deer with my large bowie type knife just to try it out for this purpose. But it was awkward at best. I sold the knife after that experience.

TR

knifebigbowieanddoe3.jpg
 
I'm certain that if I find myself fighting the wilderness for survival, I am hosed no matter if I have a four-inch blade or a ten-inch one. :D That's one of those scenarios in which I would love to rise to the occasion but would probably dehydrate first.

Nice pictures, by the way. What's the story on the second one?
You asked what was the story about the bear picture.
I’m not sure that this is the venue to tell that story, but will reply.
If it is inappropriate, hopefully the powers that be will move it to the correct location and advise me of it’s location.

Anyway, since you asked.

Back in the early 1980s, I worked as a helicopter pilot contracted to the BLM in Alaska.
Shortly after the gas embargo of the late 1970s, the oil companies began searching for oil all over Alaska.
The Alaska state government fearing that the big oil companies would just force the native Alaskans off their property, passed a law stating that all native Alaskans were entitled to a160 acre homestead.
All they had to do was show that they actually lived there and provide it’s location so it could be registered in their name.
Sounds simple. However it was soon learned that the only formal survey was a 20 mile band along the coast.
The native Alaskans had no way of defining where their property actually was.
Frantically, the BLM was charged with the task of providing a formal Cadastral (large scale marking township and range markers) survey of 92% of the land mass of Alaska.
The BLM hired a small army of surveyors and several helicopter companies to do the job.
I was one of the pilots hired.

Anchorage-Hero001_zps80d209e5.jpg
The Hughes 500D that I flew in Alaska

The picture in question was taken at Eagle River Air Strip above the Arctic circle in the early fall of 1982.

EagleStripAlaska.jpg
Eagle River BLM camp

Alaska-RedFox.jpg
One of the foxes that visited our camp.

The big oil companies would unload a large number of containers on skids and several bulldozers on the beach near where they wanted to explore.
When the winter froze the ground hard enough a crew was flown into the supplies and the bulldozers would form a cat train dragging the bulky containers across the frozen tundra to where the exploration was to be done.
Once there, they would literally construct an airstrip capable of handling large aircraft (C-130s).

When Spring arrived a crew and supplies were flown into the airstrip.
Three or four exploratory wells were dug.
After the company finished, all the equipment was dismantled and flown out.
The large containers were left behind.
You can see on the right side of the airstrip apron in the picture above.

The pilot’s tent was set back a bit from the rest of the tents a bit closer to the large wooden container.
That is where I was when things began to happen

We had been seeing bears around the are for several days after we set up camp.
Normally, they were several hundered yards away.
We didn’t pay much attention to them.

Then one morning, one of the surveyors started yelling “Bear in Camp! Bear in Camp!”
Thinking that a bear was probably getting close to our campsite, I rolled off my cot and went outside to see what was going on.
(Not expecting trouble, I left the 12GA in the tent).
When I got outside I didn’t see anything so walked towards the big wooden box so I could see the field behind it.
I got to about 20 feet of it when a bear came around the corner and sat down.
(Dirty Harry would have been impressed with the draw from my shoulder holster)
The sudden movement was a mistake!
The bear perked up his ears and looked at me (Lunch?)
I became a statue.
Knowing that we had been issued a 375HH Magnum rifle for bear protection and there were more that a few shotguns with slugs in camp, I waited for my rescue.
And I waited, and I waited, and I waited… No rescue.
I slowly turned my head back to see why I was left on the edge of Yogie’s dinner plate and saw the entire camp about 15 yards behind me.
No guns, everyone had a damned camera…
“look at the bear, look at the bear”.
Finally one of the pilots fird up a helicopter and escorted brother bruin out of the area.

EagleSDtrip-EscortingBearoutofcamp.jpg

After it was over I grabbed one of the surveyors and demanded a copy of the pictures he took.
That is how I came to have this picture.
(It was fortunate that it was taken from behind so the stain didn’t show.)

That’s the story.

Steve
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top