Which .357

[Hutch]

Another nod for the 27. The 4-incher is a bit rarer than the longer ones (except the 5"). After seeing the prices at the local gun show this weekend, I'd say that smith is a screamin' deal.

 

[YodaVader]

Deal wise the 27 sounds like the way to go. It would be the one I would go with. Have owned a GP100 4" , very nice and accurate. Currently own a 686 and used to own 3 previous to this one. But the GP100 and 686 are very common and easy to find - the 27 sounds like a hec of deal! As much as I like 686s - there is NO way I would pay $500 for a used 686. The GP would be my second choice - the price sounds right.

 

[SnWnMe]

Smith Y Wesson Modelo Veinte Siete

 

[only1asterisk]

The price on the Model 27 Smith is
Look at it HARD before you buy, but if it checks out BUY it. They will never make anything like it again.

The 686 should be less than $400!

The Ruger is priced ok, but you can ALWAYS get a Ruger.


David

 

[abdrdude]

Just to play the Devils Advocate here, last friday I bought a blued Ruger New Model Blackhawk 6 1/2 inch covertable in .357 Mag/ 9mm for $362 (Brand new from my favorite gunstore) plus tax. I realized long ago that I shoot revolvers best in single action mode,and rarely shoot double action, so it works for me. Plus, I get three choices for ammo instead of two. This gun balances well and fits my hand. I know that single action is not everyones cup of tea, but I like it. This gun will be more of a range and outdoor plinker as I have other firearms for defense.

 

[tbeb]

Of the three, I'd get the Model 27 (if it fits your hand).