Why I Don't Open Carry

Status
Not open for further replies.
Joined
Feb 25, 2010
Messages
21
Hello.

For my first post, I would like to share my first -- and last -- experience with open carry. While no one was injured, the chilling connotation and numerous “what-if’s” still haunt me 15 years later.

Although I frown upon the activity today, there was a time in my young life when dressing up in a costume to celebrate Halloween at work made sense. Dressing up as a cowboy was no trouble at all, given that I already owned the hat, boots, and fancy drop loop holster. I remember taking my shiny stainless steel Ruger Vaquero out of its box and dry firing it, thinking of how sexy it would look in my tied down holster.

But instead, I left for work with my deactivated Daisy BB revolver strapped to my leg. To the untrained eye, it could pass for a real Colt Single Action Army revolver. Anyway, my costume was a big hit that morning, so that afternoon I confidently strode toward one of the workshops feeling very comfortable with the sixgun at my side.

I had not heard a female coworker creeping up behind me.

My heart sank as I heard the distinctive sound of a gun being drawn, and spun around to face the muzzle of my own revolver. My hands instinctively flew up in the stereotypical surrender position. I’m sure the expression on my face was priceless, especially since the lady who had just disarmed me was a virulent anti-gunner. Dismayed by the appalling breach of firearms safety, I lectured her on why it is never a good idea to point a weapon at another living creature. Of course, the firearm in question did not function, but the concept remains valid.

She snickered, shook her head dismissively, and skulked off to engage in mocking the office pro-gunner with her female coworkers.

However, that was not the most disturbing part of the interaction. The thought kept running through my mind, “what if this had been a real gun?” I don’t believe that the person in question had any idea whether the gun was real or not when she so glibly pointed it at me. I don’t think it mattered to her, and the prospect of some clown on the street getting the bright idea to snatch my openly carried weapon for a laugh just makes my heart sink.

My point is, this kind of person, however rare, is out there. It may not be a realistic possibility to you, but I assure you this ignorant type of person is out there. Now imagine a group of three, and exactly what would you do if they decided to play “keep away” with your pistol?
 
Unfortunately, Open carry is not legal in Arkansas where I live. I am not sure I would open cary very much at all. But, I would like it to be my choice as a "legal/non-criminal.
 
Maybe a good retention holster would have avoided such a thing... I mean, yore open carrying wasnt the safest ever...

"buscaderos" holster are nice.. but they are a MOVIE invention.. nothing more..

Even real cowboy carried their revolvers high on the hip (mexican loop holster, or even a cross draw holster ) most of the time, under a vest, in order to protect it from the rain/dust etc..
 
Why didn't you have the hammer strap snaped? It seems to me you are the one that created the unsafe condition. Plus, being in costume suggests that your gun is also a prop.
 
That's why you maintain situational awareness and get a retention holster.

There's a reason a lot of cops have retention holsters and not old west gunbelts.


Also I'd agree that dressing in costume suggests the gun is a prop, thus the lady felt comfortable grabbing it. If it was a glock 19 in a serpa holster I think she a) would have not tried to grab it and b) the retention holster would have prevented her grabbing it.
 
Wow, just replace the words "Open Carry" With "Own a gun" and we've got an Anti gunner.


*sigh*
 
I dressed in drag once to work, because I said I would. My contract ended on the 10/30, and I told my boss that if she got me a renewal, I'd come in wearing a dress. She managed to do so the 11th hour, and conveniently the next day was Halloween.

As others have said, a movie-style dropped quickdraw holster isn't what real people carry real guns in. Even Cowboy Fastdraw competitors don't, in fact. I don't dress in drag normally, either, and it's about the same thing.

Your experience has no relevance whatsoever to, say, my wearing a thumb break holster with a revolver on my belt, on the way to the mountains.

I agree: I wouldn't wear a movie-style holster for anything but a costume, and I don't OC in crowds or packed rooms. But to conclude from your experience that OC is always a terrible idea makes about as much sense as someone who puts on a baseball cap, drinks a fifth of bourbon, hops in his car and drives it into a wall, saying, "Man, that's the last time I ever wear a baseball cap!":)
 
Wow, just replace the words "Open Carry" With "Own a gun" and we've got an Anti gunner.


*sigh*
Might sound far-fetched but it's true.

Every time we give up a right in the hopes of being "reasonable" we end up with one less right and nothing else.

Free men (and women) own and carry guns; serfs and slaves do not!
 
Wow, just replace the words "Open Carry" With "Own a gun" and we've got an Anti gunner.

Yeah... Replace "gun" with screwdriver and "holster" with toolbelt and we have an anti-electrician. That's why he wrote "open carry" and not "own a gun".
 
The OP wasn't talking about a right. He was talking about a tactic.

The problem with his conclusion is that he isn't thinking about the whole picture. Of course, there are many times when I'd rather have my gun concealed for the reasons he gives, and others. And I'd always rather have it secured better than he had that BB gun!

It just doesn't make sense to make absolute rules, when what is really required is intelligent thinking.
 
Why didn't you have the hammer strap snaped? It seems to me you are the one that created the unsafe condition. Plus, being in costume suggests that your gun is also a prop.




I agree. I open carry cause that's the only option we have here in Wisconsin. But even then , I'm always conscious of where I carry openly since not everyone is up to date on the legality of it. I've already talked to the local Chief of Police about where and where not I can carry. This not only informs me, but informs them in advance that I will be exercising my right to open carry, so when the old lady down the street calls in about the "man with a gun!'', they don't show up with 4 squads and guns drawn.
 
Just a way to pass time whenever I see a LEO with a sidearm, I look at how they carry and imagine how hard it would be to disarm them. Some of them look really easy, the weapon is hanging off in a certain way and or they're distracted or both hands are being used, etc. Retention and the ability to smack the living ^%^$ out of someone grabbing for your gun seems to be paramount.
 
Not even 20 posts in and this one goes off the rails.

Look, if you can't form an argument beyond "I disagree with you, therefore you're anti gun nyah nyah" perhaps you should re-examine your debating skills.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top