Would you take a shot at dusk?

Status
Not open for further replies.

SunnySlopes

Member
Joined
Nov 3, 2011
Messages
1,224
Just curious.

My schedule allows a morning and afternoon hunt. If I get a shot at dusk, it means tracking in the dark and trying to field dress by flashlight.

Would you take the shot?
 
If I can identify the deer and beyond, and I can get a good shot, I would.

That's the main reason I upgraded my scope: not enough clarity during the dusk.
 
Depends. I've killed lots of deer so nowadays I'm picky. If it's a nice buck I would for sure. But if it's a doe and it's Sunday night and i have to be at work then next day...I skip it...not worth it to me as I'd rather be at home than staying up late processing a doe. But than answer could be different for everyone...no right or wrong...just preference.
 
I'd say yes. If you can still see your front sight, can still see the deer, and you've got a good shot, that's just more meat in the freezer. Who knows.. may not get another opportunity for the rest of the season.
 
I've missed twice recently because I waited right till dark for the buck to come out and he didn't. Then when I finally decided to take a shot at a doe to fill the freezer, I could barely see the crosshairs. I've also made the mistake of tracking the deer immediately.. If you do take a late shot, or any shot for that matter, unless you see the deer go down you probably need to give it a few minutes to settle and die before you go in after it.. Good luck...
 
It's really up to you though if you would rather mess with a deer after dark or potentially not get one at all. I don't like messing with them after dark myself, but I'd rather do that than not get one so I'll shoot them when I can.
 
A good tracking light and a hands free headlamp for dressing should be with anybody who may have to deal with a deer in the dark.
 
I shoot in the middle of the night without problems. I field dress them using the bucket on the front end loader to hold them up, so the head lights provide plenty of light.

I do wait until morning to carve them up but it's generally pretty cold when I am hunting hogs to eat.
 
With a bow? No. I don't want to have to track it in the dark and if it rains over night the trail can wash away. With a gun? Yes! It tends to leave a larger, shorter blood trail if it doesn't knock them down right where they stand.
 
All the time, the closing moments of light are likely the best moments if the day.

Proper equipment solves all the issues with low light shooting. Tracking and skinning for me is no different daylight or dark. Again proper equipment like black diamond headlamps and stinger LED flash lights. LED rechargeable lanterns Easy to manage all the after dark recovery, skinning, and packing work.

If I gave up that last 15min of light I would bet my lifetime success would drop by a big percentage
 
If still legal shooting time then yes.
And therein lies the rub. In my area of New York State, I'm allowed to shoot between official sunrise and sunset, which today is between 6:57 AM and 4:43 PM. Believe me when I say there's plenty of light after 4:43 PM, so I have to force myself to unload my gun at 4:43 and climb down out of my stand. Perhaps the state figures on a margin of safety for walking out of the woods.
 
yup, opening day, i had about 60 seconds of legal shooting left when a doe walked out on my trail. wanting some meat in the freezer, i had a perfect broadside shot at 75 yards and armed with a good gun and scope, i had enough light to make out the silhouette and drop her where she stood. i just turned on my truck headlights at the tree i was skinning her in. not too bad at all.

tracking would suck though.
 
Deer at dusk

I have, a couple of times. As far as tracking a deer after the shot, I've killed only about 8 deer, none went further than about 30 yards after the shot. most dropped where they stood.
 
Would you take a shot at dusk?

Now you know why i am willing to pay more, and put Zeiss scopes on my "go to" guns, as "for me" they are much brighter in the lower light levels, especially when looking into the shadows.

I don't "aim" to have the deer run, especially in low light levels, and i don't use bullets that force me into "rib" shots either.

DM
 
I was just recently in that position during muzzlerloader season . I saw a albino doe come out just at dusk, in a small clearing to my right . I did not want to take her . As I watched her, I heard something behind her . It never came out where she did, but as I waited and it got darker, I could hear it circling to a clearing in front of me. I could no longer see good with my eyes, but I could see with the scope. I saw a large deer body come from the thick woods. As I watched it through my scope, it raised it's head and I could see that he had a nice rack . I could have taken a neck or broadside shot, but I could not see good enough for good shot placement so I passed .

I went back to the same spot 2 days latter in the morning . After I just finished a grunt call, I saw him come running up that same path in front of me . I had to make a noise too get him to stop . He was about 15 yards from me, quartering toward me when I took the shot .

Not making excuses for my poor shot placement , it was light as day . He took off, back the way he came like he had a rocket on his back . I thought that I missed him .

I came down from my stand and didn't see any blood . I walked the path about 20 yards and still didn't see any blood . As I was walking back ( to go sight my gun in ) I saw a clump of hair. When I bent down to pick up the hair I could see blood in a little cedar tree. So I started looking and tracking, almost on my knees for blood spots. I gave up 3 times and then would go back to the last spot that I saw blood and start over. After about a hour of tracking and a whole lot of luck I found the deer.

I would not have found this deer at dusk, but if I had made a better shot he would have dropped sooner .
 
i passed on a very large waterbuck at dusk in africa last june and i have relived that moment over and over, it was the right thing to do. but i think i could have made the shot. i never did get a waterbuck. eastbank.
 
i prefer to hunt in the afternoon. Here in OK legal shooting time ends 30 minutes after sunset. Sometimes there is enough light to shoot right up to the limit, sometimes not; especially on a cloudy day. Sunset today for this zipcode is 5:24.

My go to guns wear very good glass and my shots are picked carefully, many are bang flops.
 
Something to consider.

IF its cool enough, you can always go back the following morning and recover the deer if you cant find him quickly in the evening.

Oh, and for what its worth, field dressing by headlight isn't really all that difficult.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top