Would you trust a Taurus 1911 with your life?

Would you trust a new Taurus 1911 with your life?

  • yes

    Votes: 131 56.5%
  • no

    Votes: 101 43.5%

  • Total voters
    232
Status
Not open for further replies.
I know someone who owns one, and he likes it...so far. But for whatever reason, he only has 50 rounds through in the last three months. Honestly, I see no reason to buy one--there are plenty of other manufacturers out there with better reputations.

Taurus is legendary for failures and lousy Customer Service.

I have owned enough pieces of crap (not all were "value" brands, but most were) and I have no desire to buy another.
 
Had my SS PT1911 around 3 years now. My favorite range pistol. Almost 8,000 rounds thru it. I thought I had ONE malfunction - Felt like my best friend betrayed me. Luckily I discovered it was the ammo. there were 2 more rounds just like it in the box. The slugs had been WAY overseated and the lip of the casing actually gouged my feed ramp. I knew better than to buy Wolf ammo... but the shortage was so bad and I just wanted to go shooting. Dremel tool, polishing compound and a little elbow grease later she's good as new. Hated the straight 8 sights at first, after about 500 rounds I really got used to them. Don't care for any other sights now.
 
Without shooting it and becoming comfortable with the gun...NO. But that could be said for Glock, Kimber, Highpoint, jennings, Colt, Smith and Wesson, etc. Once a gun has demonstrated satisfatory performance and I become comfortable, THEN I'll worry about trsuting my life to it. Simply put, no gun is going to be "trusted with my life" until it has demostrated its up to the task. I think thats the standard most people should use. I DARN sure don't decide my level of trust in a gun based exclusively on who made it. Have seen highpoints that work and Kimbers that didn't....... A gun shouldn't be trusted until its proven its up to whatever task you are asking of it
 
It is up to the individual to make sure that their example of whatever brand,make, or model they choose is reliable at all times.
The PT1911 has shown to be such a gun.
http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?t=505509

There are many other examples that can be brought forth where this is the case. Many,many more.

However to say that all of a brand,make, and model are always reliable and have no problems is unreal and false. Matters not what the brand.

The magazines, internet,tactical, and police journals are full of documented cases where guns break, parts wear out, and QC lets one slip by.

Recent firearms recalls by a number of makers underscores that.

A lot of work has to go into assuring the indivdual's gun is reliable. Ammo brand,type, batch number, shooter techniques, gun break in, and a lot of other factors go into all this.

1911s as a whole have their good points and fallible ones as well. That's true for any type of pistol.

The good points and cons have been documented down through history and will continue to.

So it more important that the individual's gun, what ever make, or brand, be ready to go in time of need, more so than broad brush stroking a whole brand and type.

Any of the 1911 brands break and can fail. Seen it first hand and as documented truth. Doesn't mean that they should not be trusted. Just that the guns should be looked after closely and humans, being part of the fallible equation do their share of falling down on this as well. Happens to us all at one time or another.

I've been to many IDPA shoots where the highly prized top of the line 1911s choked,came apart ( it only takes one part), or went down for one or more reasons. In many cases it was one 1911 after another on the line this happened to. The record for me watching the others were 5 in a row.

Does that mean the 1911s are trash. No. Should One stay completely away from them totally. No.

However one has to be aware of these things and take them in stride.

Does this mean that traditional DA/SA autos are superior? No. They have their foibles as well.

All mechanical contrivances have wear and tear on them, wear out, and have parts break or have parts that need replacement. Guns are tools and mechanical contrivances. They have no magical out of the box abilities though that's what some expect, but should not.

All guns need a break in period of some kind. That's part and parcel of the whole pistol package.

If you have a 1911 of any brand, make, or model, then fine. Just keep up on it's maintenance and it'll serve you well.
 
Guys, jamming is not a problem in combat if you remembered you rail-mounted pistol bayonet.
 
Nothing wrong with a Taurus (or any other brand) that you tested before you carried it for SD.
I dont trust any gun completely.... seen firing pins preak OFF on revolver hammers and auto slides lock up solid on the range. Probably better to carry two or THREE at any time.. ;-)
 
Just like any gun it will need a reliability test with a couple hundred rounds. If it is up to your level of snuff then go for it. I see no reason why it should not continue to perform as it did in testing.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top