wlewisiii
Member
There are various posts about the merits of both of these weapons and each is fine in it's own way. The question I have to answer is which do I buy? Each has pluses and minuses relating to capacity, muzzle energy, sight radius, etc.
The revolver is a bit more expensive. It has a lower number of rounds however they can be +P. 5 158 gr LSWCHP +P from Buffalo Bore (1040 fps - 379 ft. lbs. from a 2" barrel) will put a crimp on most situations. I already own 2 .38/.357 4" revolvers so there is little difference from a training perspective and I am getting set up to reload both .38 Special and .357 Magnum. It is current S&W production and does have an internal lock. That does not bother me and even if it did, I know how to remove it.
The auto is somewhat less expensive. It has a larger capacity of somewhat lower energy rounds though I don't believe that .380 is sufficiently lower to be of concern and, once again, there is a Buffalo Bore loading (380 Auto +P Ammo - 100 gr. Hardcast F.N. (1150fps/ M.E. 294 ft. lbs.)) that evens things up a bit. Slightly larger it has a better sight radius however it is a semi-auto and so has a more extensive malfunction drill to consider. I intensely dislike the super compact semi-autos and this, about PPK sized, is as small as I care to go.
I'm inclined towards the 642 at this point, but am curious if anyone has any arguments to make pro or con for either of these. If my budget permitted, I'd probably be looking at a 3" Model 60 vs a blue steel Walther PPK, but I am budget constrained to this level instead.
Thanks!
The revolver is a bit more expensive. It has a lower number of rounds however they can be +P. 5 158 gr LSWCHP +P from Buffalo Bore (1040 fps - 379 ft. lbs. from a 2" barrel) will put a crimp on most situations. I already own 2 .38/.357 4" revolvers so there is little difference from a training perspective and I am getting set up to reload both .38 Special and .357 Magnum. It is current S&W production and does have an internal lock. That does not bother me and even if it did, I know how to remove it.
The auto is somewhat less expensive. It has a larger capacity of somewhat lower energy rounds though I don't believe that .380 is sufficiently lower to be of concern and, once again, there is a Buffalo Bore loading (380 Auto +P Ammo - 100 gr. Hardcast F.N. (1150fps/ M.E. 294 ft. lbs.)) that evens things up a bit. Slightly larger it has a better sight radius however it is a semi-auto and so has a more extensive malfunction drill to consider. I intensely dislike the super compact semi-autos and this, about PPK sized, is as small as I care to go.
I'm inclined towards the 642 at this point, but am curious if anyone has any arguments to make pro or con for either of these. If my budget permitted, I'd probably be looking at a 3" Model 60 vs a blue steel Walther PPK, but I am budget constrained to this level instead.
Thanks!