Is washing dirty range brass sufficient?

Status
Not open for further replies.
I've got a good bit of dirty and sandy range brass that I'd like to reload. Would washing the cases in a soapy solution clean them enough to not worry about scratching my dies? I don't have a tumbler.
Lol, almost nobody had tumblers when I started. I loaded thousands of 38, 357, and 45acp with nothing more than shaking in a pasta strainer to get range debri off, then hosing them off. If your spouse doesn't catch you, a basket in the dishwasher or a pillow case in the washing machine work too.
 
Yup, washing them in the sink or a bucket will work just fine. The only part that should touch the case during de-priming is the pin and shell holder. But dirt in the extraction groove will misalign the case mouth and make it more difficult.
Clean cases are happy cases.
Shiny cases are better!

Sorry, y’all, but I know for a fact these shoot better than dingy, dark cases.;)
index.php


“When you look good, you feel good. When you feel good, you do better.” ~ Grandma R.

“And if I don’t win, as least I’ll look good not doin’ it!”~ Me:)
 
As long as the cases are not groudy (80's Valley Girl slang) with corrosion or something similar, washing is fine.
I never would have guessed you were a Valley Girl in the ‘80’s. Go figure! :rofl:
I used to use a wet vac to “collect” brass at the range in Titusville. It picked up everything - brass, ants, butts, twigs - so I would just drop a hose in the bucket and let it overflow for a while. Toss some SteelBrite in after a couple of rinses and swirl it around a little. That got it clean enough to decap/resize. I had to stop doing that when a couple other members complained. Spoil sports. :(
This was back in the early ‘80’s - but I wasn’t a Valley Girl. :p
 
Thanks for the responses, guys!

I've seen where people recommend depriming before cleaning. Can brass be too dirty and sandy to run through a universal decapping die? I'm not talking about caked on mud, but a fair bit of dirt and sand that inevitably hangs around after being swept off of the concrete. I wouldn't imagine that it would matter if a universal decapping die gets scratched up as its only job is to deprime.
I don't deprime before tumbling, no safery/health reason, just don't. The universal depriming die I use doesn't touch the case sides, so no worries scratching the die. For me the very first step is inspection. I do a quick check of the case head, looking at the primer and a glance at the headstmp. Then the case neck and body for splits and while I have the case mouth pointed up, look for a single flash hole (for unknown headstamps). Then they go in the tumbler. Sounds like it takes too much time, but only 2 seconds per case. Saves time replacing decapping stems/pins or loading junk/split brass. And my press "captures" spent primers so no burnt debris gets on anything...
 
Last edited:
Yup, washing them in the sink or a bucket will work just fine. The only part that should touch the case during de-priming is the pin and shell holder. But dirt in the extraction groove will misalign the case mouth and make it more difficult.
Clean cases are happy cases.
Shiny cases are better!

Sorry, y’all, but I know for a fact these shoot better than dingy, dark cases.;)
index.php


“When you look good, you feel good. When you feel good, you do better.” ~ Grandma R.

“And if I don’t win, as least I’ll look good not doin’ it!”~ Me:)
It’s better to look good than feel good and you look mahvaleous!—Billy Crystal as Ricardo Montalban
 
I've got a good bit of dirty and sandy range brass that I'd like to reload. Would washing the cases in a soapy solution clean them enough to not worry about scratching my dies? I don't have a tumbler.
Yes. I usually have them in a bucket of soap solution for about a day, agitating the mix several times over that period. A couple rinses with hot water will remove the soap and help them dry faster. I separate the cases from the rinse with an old silverware basket from a dishwasher, but any type of screen will do. Spread the brass out on a towel to dry. A fan or heat source will speed up the drying.
I always de-primed brass before cleaning that way. Water gets trapped in the primer and primer pocket and take far to long to dry otherwise. I want the brass completely dry before adding primer and powder.
 
One thing to consider if you wet tumble sandy brass with SS pins, the brass will come out “brushed” rather than polished. It’s a different look, and I’m not judging, but I’ll do a quick 10 minute tumble then a good rinse to get rid of most of the sand, then the required tumble time to get it polished.
 
Long long ago in a galaxy far far away when I started to reload all I did was to wipe the brass off with a rag and tap it on the bench mouth down to clean it. No problems with scratched dies or ruined firearms here. Now I have the luxury of being able to clean my brass to factory new levels if I want to. Still sometimes when working up a load at the range I will use the same 10 cases over and over with only a wipedown if needed. YMMV
 
I've got a good bit of dirty and sandy range brass that I'd like to reload. Would washing the cases in a soapy solution clean them enough to not worry about scratching my dies? I don't have a tumbler.
Get a tumbler. Washing is a PITA. For dirty gritty brass wash, but for your normal pickups a tumbler is definetly needed.
 
FWIW; tumbling/brass cleaning seems to be one of the most talked about things in reloading. Most talked about, least important...
I still clean with a cloth and q-tip when I only have one or a dozen cases - like from load testing or a trip to the hunting field - just to keep my boxes topped off. Those cases probably have the most rounds through them since I always pull from the same spot. I’ve probably got two or more boxes of .357Max with two or three cases that have hundreds of firings and the rest are still on their first reload. :rofl::evil:
 
All I’ll add is start with hot water and let them soak a while. More agitation the better.

If they are really dirty, my first bucket would be just hot water and Dawn and stir well with a broom handle to knock the chunks off. Rinse well.

Then, Dawn or Car wash/wax and Lemishine in more hot water and let it soak. Stir occasionally. Rinse well.
 
I just rinse and wash with hot water and soap. I try to agitate and dump out and refill the water a few times. It takes like 3 minutes. Dump onto towel and then let dry. I've never had a problem.
 
I've got a good bit of dirty and sandy range brass that I'd like to reload. Would washing the cases in a soapy solution clean them enough to not worry about scratching my dies? I don't have a tumbler.
I'd recommend getting a wet tumbler. Harbor Freight sells a dual drum model for about $60 - doesn't take up much space and will get the brass squeaky clean.
 
I went quite a while before I got a tumbler(s).
I tossed the brass in a 5 gallon bucket filled with water swished around, dumped water, to get major dirt out.
Then I put in some dishwashing liquid and water and let it soak for a day or to swishing it every now and then.
Drain, rinse, dry.

No issue with dies and the brass worked fine.
 
If you wash all the foreign object from the case, that’s just fine.

For my most accurate firearms, I generally wipe the case off by hand and brush out the neck with a nylon brush. Tumblers help with are large volumes of brass but are not absolutely necessary.
 
After going through all the cleaning processes on my own, I ditched it all.
I have an acquaintance who I buy brass from, and I always admired how his brass is shinier than new.
He wet rod tumbles and adds a bit of orange oil detergent to the mix.
Anyways, I give him my brass about once a year and he runs it all through and charges me a small fee.
Too good to be true that I dont deal with any brass cleaning, in my opinion. I've always hated doing it.
 
I like shiny brass so I tumble. And to me, its easier to inspect clean brass. The main thing is to have no dirt or grit that can get inbeded in the die or your chamber. And it doesn't hurt to keep it off of the ram in your press either! But before I had a tumbler I used hot soapy water in a wide mouth bottle. About half full of brass, 3/4 full of soapy water and several minutes of shaking.

And yeah, we argue about tumbling, case lube, Lee equipment, bore solvent, ect ect. Its what we do!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top