Can a shotgun be "too much" for HD?

I have a pistol in our townhouse, too. I think it's a better choice. A shotgun's size and length would be a handicap here, with two stairways and a lot of sharp corners. At least with a single projectile, I can probably hit the target. With buckshot, I can hit the target with several projectiles and still send a few more through a wall or window.

And I'm a shotgunner. I hit fast-flying birds with the things. I like them. I just don't think that a shotgun is my best choice here, all things considered. Ditto for a carbine, though I have and like carbines, also.

Will a shotgun's length be a handicap in my smaller house?

Click to expand...

You aren't going to go running through the house looking for bad guys to shoot, are you?

not really, but a shotgun does present some advantages to a homeowner as well. In a smaller TH, loading the gun with say BB or T shot, will reduce the likelihood of hurting someone in an adjoining space, or if you hit a window with an errant shot, where as a 9mm out the window might hit someone across the drive or yard. a long gun, that is a combat shot gun is very easy to aim under stress and delivers a much more incapacitating blow.

depends on your place

Living in a townhouse, unless you use Glaser or similar "safety slugs", your pistol rounds will go through walls into the next place. Ditto for a shot gun with any appreciable buckshot in it.

My mantra for home defense is have a weapon--and hole up.

What I mean is, if you hear the bump in the night, arm yourself, and go to your kids (assuming you have them). Take them into your room. Assuming you're convinced that someone in is the house, call 911.

They can take the TV

They can take the stereo.

If they step into your room, that's their choice.

That being said, the sound of the slide of a pump gun being racked and a loud "get the F out of my house"! can do wonders to change someone's perspective.

I'm not clearing a house to see if there are bad guys there...nor to protect my possessions. I'll hole up and protect what is important.

Actually I see shotguns as perfect in rural settings where you have great latitude to swing and fire those buckshots and slugs and not worrying about where those pellets would end up.
A pistol is practical in apartments and urban setting. Just my opinion though.

wel if you share an adjoining wall with your neighbor, then being the neighbor I would rather you use a shotgun, I mean with the exception of a slug most pellets will be "stopped" or slowed enough after going through the wall not to kill me on the other side. where as even a 9mm more so than a 45 would travel right through most walls I have seen in smaller houses in cities

wel if you share an adjoining wall with your neighbor, then being the neighbor I would rather you use a shotgun, I mean with the exception of a slug most pellets will be "stopped" or slowed enough after going through the wall not to kill me on the other side. where as even a 9mm more so than a 45 would travel right through most walls I have seen in smaller houses in cities


I agree. Anything short of a slug would be better than most handgun rounds, at least 9 mm and larger. But double ought buck is pretty ugly.

I'm on this board because I recently got into shotguns. I've been wanting a gun for sometime and decided that a shotgun was the best and most practical as I heard it is better for less penetration. I took a shotgun class this past weekend. While the instructor makes a living training LEO and civilians alike (this was a civilian shotgun hd course) he said that a handgun is a better hd weapon. One of the main reasons was manuverability and he proceeded to show the class a shooter's turning radius with shotty vs. handgun. He also showed how a shotgun telegraph's your exact location as you go around a door whereas with a handgun you don't. He further stated that a bad guy sees you before you want him to see you with a shotty. He stated that a bad guy sees you with a handgun only when you want him to see you...presumbly right before you shoot him.

I told him that the only reason i got a shotgun was because I thought it the best option for preventing over-penetration. He said that was a lot of bs made up by shotgun and shotgun ammo manufacturers. He said that any bullet loses 80-90% of it's power upon impact with something substantial.

However, in my opinion, a shotgun is lesser penetration than a bullet fired from a high powered rifle or even a handgun.

Another thing he did teach was you have more movement shooting a shotgun from the hip vs. shoulder. It takes a lot of practice to aim right, but not only is it zero pain to your shoulder, but you get better mobility in a house fight.

That being said, I'm still probably going to get a handgun.

Colt 45 acp at bedside table with mag's full. Plus another mag's full.

If you choose a handgun for a true Home Defense situation, when you have a longarm available, Darwin has a place in history for you.

On your own ground, your home, you should know the difference from a bump in the night, and some one rambling around your house. If you don't, your defenses are suspect, and you must learn your own ground, intimately.

If you have folks in the house, only a Darwin wannabe would go looking for them, go defensive and wait for the cavalry. Even if it is a long time, by going defensive you will be fighting from cover and concealment with usually superior weapons.

Second, almost every hand gun round will penetrate to a greater degree than my #1 buck.

Go figure.

fred

Threecard
One of the first senseable posts I've seen on home defence.

Some one once told me that if you had to shoot indoors, do it from a kneeling position if it was available.

Or down or up a stairs.

That would make your rounds travel at an angle so that they were less likely to hit folks laying in beds next door or in adjacent rooms.

Always kind of thought that was good advice.

As far as shotguns go. Maybe try a low recoil tactical load?

My $0.02.....

I'm the only hardcore shotgunner at home. For the others, there's DA 38 and 357 revolvers everyone can shoot and has shot.

I prefer a shotgun because.....

They dump an incredible amount of energy into a target. Even the lowly 410's ME rivals the 45 ACP, well known as a stopper. One shot stop probability is about 99%. You don't get better than that.

Under stress, a shotgun's a lot easier to shoot well than a handgun.

Doubt that? Set up a COF at the max distance possible inside your home, run in place until you're breathing hard, then shoot the COF fast in low light.

Do this with both your shotgun and handgun using duty ammo. Even if your handgun's an accessorized custom piece blessed by both the Pope and Col Cooper, and your shotgun's a bone stock Model 88, you'll find the scores educational. Maybe frightening.

And note the misses. If there's none you're either truly a Bad Dude or the COF's way too easy, probably the latter.

Shotguns are terrific defensive weapons, when used by shotgunners. With all due respect, not everyone talking about shotguns on the Net qualifies.

loading the gun with say BB or T shot, will reduce the likelihood of hurting someone in an adjoining space

Click to expand...

As well as the bad guy.

Dave is right about energy dump of the entire load.

However, if the projectiles won't go through a wall, they won't go through a leather jacket all that well, either. With a shotgun, you're dealing with a lot of individual projectiles, not one. Each individual projectile has limited energy, unless you use large enough shot.

Join Date: 06-23-06
Posts: 16 depends on your place

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Living in a townhouse, unless you use Glaser or similar "safety slugs", your pistol rounds will go through walls into the next place. Ditto for a shot gun with any appreciable buckshot in it.

My mantra for home defense is have a weapon--and hole up.

What I mean is, if you hear the bump in the night, arm yourself, and go to your kids (assuming you have them). Take them into your room. Assuming you're convinced that someone in is the house, call 911.

They can take the TV

They can take the stereo.

If they step into your room, that's their choice.

That being said, the sound of the slide of a pump gun being racked and a loud "get the F out of my house"! can do wonders to change someone's perspective.

I'm not clearing a house to see if there are bad guys there...nor to protect my possessions. I'll hole up and protect what is important.

Click to expand...

Threecard you a dead on things are replacable also that plan puts the law the solidly on yourside

On your own ground, your home, you should know the difference from a bump in the night, and some one rambling around your house. If you don't, your defenses are suspect, and you must learn your own ground, intimately.

If you have folks in the house, only a Darwin wannabe would go looking for them, go defensive and wait for the cavalry. Even if it is a long time, by going defensive you will be fighting from cover and concealment with usually superior weapons.

Click to expand...

Taking the fight to an intruder puts you on shaky ground legally in a lot of places plus It may allow bad guy between you and loved ones witch is not acceptable
Cheiftain is also right on the fact that you should be able to walk though your home in the dark with a blind fold on IMHO A lock on the door of you defence room is a good ideal too
Never under estamate the intimadation factor of the sound of a pump gun racking a shell into the chamber it is all that is neede to end 99% of the confrontations
Roy
Disclaimer : this is the opinion of a middle aged hillbilly plumber that has been down the raod a time or two and are based on my personal knowledge and experiences offered to hopefully help you since we live in a free country you have the right to have a different opinion, Some one asked the question I am just trying to help

dont overestimate the sound of a pump racking a shell either.
it is a very intimidating sound but it also gives the bad guy a chance to know where you are

Better then Mythbusters.

http://www.theboxotruth.com/docs/theboxotruth.htm

Check out some of his tests on walls with various guns.

As Scout26 said... here is their article with the "Box O' Truth": http://www.theboxotruth.com/docs/bot3.htm

dont overestimate the sound of a pump racking a shell either.
it is a very intimidating sound but it also gives the bad guy a chance to know where you are

Agreed that it does give away your position. However, If I'm in my room with my family and racking the gun and giving some rather rude and loud commands don't make them leave but instead cause them to advance on me, I think it's likely they had more on their minds than just burglarizing my home from the beginning.

Agreed that it does give away your position. However, If I'm in my room with my family and racking the gun and giving some rather rude and loud commands don't make them leave but instead cause them to advance on me, I think it's likely they had more on their minds than just burglarizing my home from the beginning.

Click to expand...

BINGO!

If they leave great! if they don't you are ready for them. Either way the result will be the same. Your family is safe.

Go figure.

Fred

If you choose a handgun for a true Home Defense situation, when you have a longarm available, Darwin has a place in history for you.

Click to expand...

Yeah... at the top of the list of species that will survive. That is a very silly statement chief.

Why not both a handgun and a shotgun? Can't I have both?

In all seriousness the shotgun in the corner doesn't take up much room but can't really compare to the Glock under the pillow for little used space. Besides, I may not have time to reload!

In the grand scheme of things, we have to balance risks and rewards, costs and benefits.

A shotgun can end up in the hands of an intruder very easily, especially if I'm not at home when he breaks in. I don't care to come home to face the muzzle of my own 870. But if I put it in a safe, it won't do me much good if I really need it NOW.

A pistol, OTOH, I can lock up in a quick-access safe, keep it loaded and easily available to me at all times, while not providing a weapon to someone who might use it to kill me (or have it discovered by someone dumb nosing about my house, or by someone's kid looking for the bathroom, or whomever).

If you have a place to stash it, and your home lends itself to long gun use, by all means, use a shotgun. It will stop an intruder quite well! But there are other factors to consider in a real-world situation. And a gun that's not loaded and available doesn't do anything for you, either.

shotgun-defense, handgun-offense