Interview or Imagination?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Plan2Live

Member
Joined
May 17, 2011
Messages
2,183
Location
Columbia, SC
In putting this post together I realized it could be and maybe should be broken into three posts but I decided to keep it together in one post. My three points are; 1. Encourage more people to post their close calls, 2. Bring up the difficult choices of a concealed carrier on a first date, 3. Describe my close call as a learning tool for others.

I learn a lot by reading posts in this section and the feedback given by members in the after-encounter analysis. I encourage others to be more forthcoming so we can all learn more from these encounters.

Here’s what happened. I meet a woman I think I want to spend more time with. I ask her to join me for an afternoon out. This is our first date, I know very little about her or her opinions. Bringing up the fact that I often carry a firearm probably isn’t the best topic to tackle prior to that first date. Because of that and because we are going to the Museum, which posts a non-30.06 circle and slash sign on the door, then going to a restaurant that serves alcohol (a no-gun zone in SC) I decide to leave my weapon in my console. She lives 45 minutes away and volunteered to make the drive and meet me in the Wal-Mart parking lot. We left her vehicle there and took my vehicle on the date.

After an enjoyable afternoon we headed back to retrieve her truck. I insist on topping off her gas tank since she made the effort to drive. I had her drive over to the gas pumps and I pull in behind her, lock my truck and begin filing her tank. It’s about 4:30pm, there are a fair number of people at the pumps but as I scan the area while pumping gas I notice a man walking directly toward us. Her filler neck is in the usual place on a pickup and the man stops at the tailgate and asks us what we know about geese. My alarm bells go off. He is now between me and my weapon. As he launches into this story about earlier that day, some geese were over there in the grass and when he walked by they were chasing him and pecking at him. I quickly scanned the bed of her truck, no boards, sticks, bats, or anything else that could be used as a weapon. I scanned him for lumps, identifying marks, general description and began watching his hands and eyes. I also did a quick 360 scan looking for accomplices. These are all tactics I see reinforced here often. He edges closer. Not finding any other weapon I withdraw the gas nozzle from the filler neck, do a physical 360 rotation so the hose is not between the two of us and I bring the nozzle to draw retention position and generally point it in his direction while explaining to him that geese are territorial and that he was in their space. I explain that lots of animals, and some people, are like that. He gives me a once over, looks at the gas nozzle and says something like “oh, that explains it”. About that time another guy walks up from behind the row of pumps to my left, geese guy greets the new man and they turn and walk away.

I put the nozzle back in it’s spot on the pump, take my receipt and turn my attention back to my date who is standing there looking at me and she says, “what just happened?” I reply nothing, nothing at all. I thank her for the day, we hug and she drives off.

So what did happen? Maybe it was nothing but I think it was an interview. Maybe it was just going to be a panhandle. Regardless, I didn’t like it and I didn’t like the fact that I was unarmed. I don’t know what the right answer is about bringing up firearms too quickly with a new woman of interest but my lady friends tell me don’t go there too quickly if you want a 2nd date. But I do know that we can all take lessons away from situations like this so I am risking the criticism and airing it out. Feedback?
 
I would assume he meant no harm, realized you were uncomfortable or had finished his business, and decided to leave. At the same time, I would be confident that I did the right thing by excercising caution. Case closed, no harm done.

That's a mind set -- not everyone means you harm, but there's no harm in being cautious just the same. And if it all works out, there's no need to assume he was a bad guy. If it doesn't work out, well . . . .
 
So what did happen? Maybe it was nothing but I think it was an interview. Maybe it was just going to be a panhandle. Regardless, I didn’t like it...

With no more information than you have, I don't think you can know what it was at this point. Fortunately, other than it being a learning experience for you to some degree, it doesn't matter any more than that. Goose-man walked away, Sumdood#2 walked away, you drove away and your date drove away. No harm no foul.

It always makes my hackles go up to some degree when some absolute stranger approaches me deliberately in a focused manner out in public and accosts me. Most of the time it's something completely trivial. Someone who's not 'up to something' is usually going to maintain eye contact and not be glancing all around as they approach, they'll stop well short and engage in conversation at a respectful distance rather than 'pushing' their approach into your personal space.

You said, I didn’t like it. That could well be a major clue. Listen to your gut in this sort of situation, most of human communication is nonverbal and in a genuine interview, most (80%?) of what happens is nonverbal.

Take a look at the links in this post, if you haven't been over this material before:
http://www.thehighroad.org/showthread.php?t=650865&page=2

What if someone does cross the lines and really makes your spidey sense sing? Take a look at what Southnarc teaches in Managing Unknown Contacts - http://www.safeism.com/pdfs/SNContacts.pdf . Get comfortable with the idea of talking to a potential predator - Skip Gochenour's material at the link above (Talking to the Indians) is priceless.

In the interval between a predator's evaluation and approach, and the actual attack, there can be a space of time where conversation or negotiation takes place. The predator may want to size up the potential prey before committing to the attack. This is your chance to size up the potential predator as well, and work toward de-selection as a potential victim as well. It's best to be sufficiently aware to see the approach happening, sufficiently conscious to recognize it for what it could be, and sufficiently collected, self confident and prepared to react appropriately without escalating the situation yourself. Remember ADEE...

ETA - give this a listen, too: http://www.downrange.tv/blog/down-r...mplications-of-the-trayvon-martin-case/13837/
 
Again, this is a situation in which you allowed someone to close the gap between you and "engage" you.

Not sure about anyone else, but I never, ever allow someone to engage me in any way whatsoever. Maybe this is harsh, but having grown up outside NYC, this is how it is.

Simple tactic, before they even open up their mouth, as they are approaching, I put my hand up indicating I want them to STOP, then in a polite but firm voice, tell them I am not interested.

If it is some innocent person, I am sorry if they feel slighted, but I am not being insulting. I have been less then helpful to someone...which is unfortunate, but I am confident that I can tell the difference between a good guy and a bad guy. I will also be helpful when I can.

If it is a bad guy, then I have stopped them.

If they persist, I will issue another verbal warning for them to stay away.

If they move forward, I check out of whatever I am doing and depart or at least get into my vehicle in which I am in a better defensive position (and can ready a weapon if need be).

Very simple. This tactic has never failed me.

So, my rule #1, NEVER ALLOW THEM TO ENGAGE.

Once you have, you are playing by their rules and allowing them to employ THEIR strategy on you. Once they have been allowed to talk to you...they are now running their game on you. Their convesational tactic will be to make you feel badly if you do not talk with them. Case in point, the geese...how innocent is that? How foolish you would look if you refused to talk with someone about the nice little geese. But at that point, you are trapped in their game.

DO NOT ALLOW THE CONVERSATION TO START. That is the key to rule #1. No matter what they begin to say, stop them and say SORRY, NOT INTERESTED.

If they continue to try to talk, "Good day to you, sir!" In your best command voice.

My rule #2, if you have been engaged, either disengage or check out.

Hope this helps

Best

J
 
IMO............you should have cut off the conversation immediately.
Do you know anything about Geese......NO, NO, NO.
Not to be rude but if your Spideys are tellin' you......then it's always... NO.

Got a cigarette.....NO
Can I ask you a question.....NO
Do you know where.........NO
It's always.....NO.....and don't let them close the distance on you.....and keep movein'.


And it sounded like an Interview to me also.......
 
Something to keep in mind is that these types of people practice. A lot. They know exactly how to run their game.

So, you need to be ready.

They may not be taking a run at you. They may be just practicing. Seeing how they can engage what type of person and when. Trying out one approach or another.

So, you need to be ready. And you should also practice preventing engagement, even in the smallest, most benign circumstances. It will give you confidence to use your own techniques when you really need to.

I could see how being on a date, especially a first date, could make this difficult and awkward. They use that on you.

So, think ahead about what you are going to do and say. Including what you will tell your date.

If it seems awkward, you can always say:

"I have been told that it is not a good idea to let yourself be engaged in a conversation with a strange person that you do not know."

"I did not think it would be a good idea to begin talking with a stranger at a gas station [or insert wherever]"

"I got a very strange feeling from that person."
 
ps - if they do get a question out, one reply you can use:

"Sorry, cannot help you. Have a nice day."

[turn your back, do not answer the question, end conversation]

If they get a question out, or a follow up, one tactic to use is to never answer the question. Always have your own statement thereby not engaging with them (you, in essence are having two different conversations...but at least, you are not engaging in THEIR conversation).

Whatever they say, never reply directly to their question or statement. Never be in their conversation and thus maintain some control. But your tactic remains: prevent engagement or disengage.

J
 
Better safe than sorry, but not every "interview" is for an evil purpose. Maybe you looked like the kind of guy who knew about geese, so he came up and asked you. As it turns out you did know.

People sometimes ask me about pizza joints, and as it turns out I do know ;-)
 
I could see how being on a date, especially a first date, could make this difficult and awkward. They use that on you.

... you can always say:

"I have been told that it is not a good idea to let yourself be engaged in a conversation with a strange person that you do not know."

"I did not think it would be a good idea to begin talking with a stranger at a gas station [or insert wherever]"

"I got a very strange feeling from that person."

"Hey, sorry if that looked a little strange or rude on my part, but I got a weird feeling from that guy, and since I care about your well being, I figured that just ending the encounter with him quickly was the best choice."

Boo-yah! Second date slam dunk!

:D
 
Went home alive, if you made someone uncomfortable that's too bad but oh well.

I guess that's the benefit of being a tall/large guy I can generally be intimidating if I want to without any sort of show of force. (But of course I have the force if it's needed) :D
 
Being a big guy probably helps. But...really anyone can do it. I am not a big guy.

This is something taught in the military and, *I think* to LEO's. How to use your "command voice."

In the military, it is called, "Command Presence"

Does not matter your size. You can learn to act and speak with authority that makes people listen to you and follow your instructions.
 
I would ask "sprechen Sie Deutch?" in a loud voice, it also works when accosted by a vinyl siding salesman inside Home Depot.
 
Follow John Farnam's suggestion -- in a polite, but very firm, voice say, "I'm sorry, sir, I can't help you." This can be accompanied (augmented) by the universal "arm extended toward stranger with palm facing outward" gesture.

This works irrespective of the request (money, cigarette, directions, etc) and should cut off any further attempts to engage you in conversation.
 
Was there anything about you demeanor or your person that would have implied to a reasonable man that you could be, in fact, a world renowned Ornithologist specializing in the study of Branta canadensis?

Maybe the guy was "interviewing" you (likely) or he was just plain "different."
 
Lunchtime is not a date. I would call her back and make sure our next date was at night Whoops wrong advice... Good job though - you can't be too careful. I never understood why people would walk up to complete strangers and ask stupid questions until I started reading this forum. It all makes sense now.
 
Refusing to engage

Captain33036:
Not sure about anyone else, but I never, ever allow someone to engage me in any way whatsoever. Maybe this is harsh, but having grown up outside NYC, this is how it is.

Simple tactic, before they even open up their mouth, as they are approaching, I put my hand up indicating I want them to STOP, then in a polite but firm voice, tell them I am not interested.

Like the Captain, NYC taught me, early on, to be wary of being approached by strangers, especially skells.

But while in NYC one can get away with saying "That's close enough, Pal!" (an old GF of mine -- a true NYC woman! -- used to just point her finger at 'em and say "Stay the **** away from me!"), my years out in the rest of the country have mellowed me (somewhat) and helped me develop a line that is less likely to be taken as an affront or a challenge:
"Uh, I'm kinda busy right now, Pardner!"

I try to say it with a smile, but still with authority (and accompanied/reinforced if necessary by the "Stop" gesture at the end of an outstretched arm, body turned sideways). They almost always apologize as they withdraw!
 
A little over the top in my opinion. Some parts of the country are not as friendly as other parts (fact). Bigger populated not as much so as rural. I'm from a rural Southern community where just about everybody speaks to each other and that in itself does not mean anything other than someone being friendly.

I generally don't patronize panhandlers other than direct them to groups/that provide appropriate help. I have at times bought someone a meal when I felt like it. In our community we have several homeless folks who are a "little different," not really panhandlers just in that class of individuals who seem to slip through the cracks. So yea, I've bought the occasional Big Mac when they looked hungry.

I've never really felt threatened by either group. Are there dangerous individuals and places ~ Absolutely. Does one need to keep their guard up ~ No argument there. But, when I get to the point I feel like I have to put my hand on my gun, or scan for a weapon every time someone speaks to me; I just might be the common denominator in that picture.

Might be a time to take a critical look at where, when and whom I'm hanging out with.
 
I don't answer their questions, and once I get a quick appraisal of the area and what might be accomplices, I start to ask my own quesions. Pointedly and with force. 1/4 your gun side away from the perp., even if you are not carrying.

Females and guns are tricky-lots hate em, some love em, but they are a personal thing to me which is not really 1st date conversation anyway.

One debrief question for ya; did the station have security cameras in plain view?
 
You have to read the situation so as not to overreact in an innocent situation. Easier said than done, but the experience of living helps. Bottom line? If you have not led a sheltered life and feel something is wrong - something is wrong. Trust your instincts. You did, and got the desired outcome. I like your use of the gas nozzle as a field expedient defensive weapon. The prospect of being doused with gas, particularly in the face, would not appeal to very many.
 
I guess it's time I answered a few of these questions and responses.

We were at the gas pumps at a Wal-Mart. People often walk from their vehicle to the "store" to pay with cash. They walk right behind your vehicle, not a lot I can do to prevent that, just be aware. I always keep the driver's door open when I am filing up because it creates somewhat of a barrier in one direction, the pumps shield me from another, the vehicle another so that only leaves one opening. When I initially spotted Goose Guy he could have been just passing by but decided to pause at the tailgate and chat, about geese. That's the part that set of my alarm bells because no, I don't look like an expert on birds. I've been panhandled before, lots of times and this just felt differently.

Not to get too controversial here, but considering all factors, including the fact that we had a "hoodie march" downtown the morning before, I was already on high alert and not wanting to antagonize anyone. Tensions are running high around here so I decided that a quick, closed ended statement was less antagonizing than a "get back" response. It was an on the spot judgment call.

That was Sunday. We had lunch on Tuesday which was our third get together. Lunch went well so I decided to broach the topic of carrying a weapon. The next morning I received a text saying it was probably best if we didn't see each other again. Considering everything else was going well I am fairly certain the weapon was the issue. If so, so be it. When I made the decision to start carrying that was a lifestyle decision and one I won't compromise on long term.

It would be great to hear from the ladies here about their thoughts on when to bring this up. Maybe an entire thread devoted to that topic is in order.
 
Last edited:
Lunch went well so I decided to broach the topic of carrying a weapon.

My wife made it clear when I started carrying that she didn't want it to be talked about. She is supportive of it but she is worried. I don't hide it from her. At her request, I just don't mention it.

I wouldn't bring it up if I were dating. When she eventually finds about it, I wouldn't make a big deal saying it only it is a last resort tool if I can't back out of a situation. I'd offer to answer questions she has. I'd even offer to show it to her if she wanted. But I wouldn't push it.
 
P2L, I like the fact you pulled the nozzle for effect.
I am from Texas, so know what friendly really is. In SC, I bet you do too. But, if it feels weird, then break it off... I am glad the day finished well.
Too bad about the follow on.
 
"Why can't a woman be more like a man?" -- Henry Higgins in "My Fair Lady"

Plan2Live:
We had lunch on Tuesday which was our third get together. Lunch went well so I decided to broach the topic of carrying a weapon. The next morning I received a text saying it was probably best if we didn't see each other again.

A very wise man once taught me that women decide within the first few minutes of meeting a man whether he is a potential sexual/romantic partner. This decision is subconscious and the woman may not even be aware of it.
Nevertheless, she may exhibit one or more "tells".

These "tells" are also subconscious and can be extremely subtle, like on which side she holds her purse when she walks with you ('Sorry, but I'm not going to reveal any more about them here).

But if she's gone out with you three times, it's a pretty safe bet that the decision has been taken in your favor. At that point, the more unsolicited information you reveal about yourself, the greater your chance of blowing it.

And you blew it, Amigo.

Another very wise man (I think it was Voltaire) once said,
"The secret of being tiresome is to tell everything."

I'm a lot like you, Plan2Live. It's my nature to practice "full disclosure", lay my cards on the table, and let a woman know just what to expect. But that is not the way to win women's hearts and minds.

So don't tell 'em you carry. Don't even broach the subject.
Remember, also, why Popeye Doyle carried his Model 36 in an ankle holster: "So when ya meet a chick, and she rubs up against ya, she can't tell you're a cop!"
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top