G&A's 2015 list of best gun owner states

Status
Not open for further replies.
Jersey is worse than New York. They made their ranking based on NYC not the state as a whole. NJ is worse than NYC and it's statewide.

I live in Washington and their entry for my state is wildly incorrect on a factual basis. Makes me question the rest of these entries... Permits are issued for five years and at a price of $50, not $7 annually. That's so totally incorrect that I have major questions about other strange looking entries. Washington also has one of the strongest castle statutes in the nation as far as I'm aware and I am legally allowed to use lethal force to stop any felony. The passage of the universal background check bill was unfortunate but we had a mass school shooting literally the week before the election and I think it was a sure fail up until the shooting when everyone realized background checks stop kids from stealing their parents beretta.

RCW in question for those who doubt felonies make you fair game in Washington, and there are some pretty minor/technical felonies... http://apps.leg.wa.gov/RCW/default.aspx?cite=9A.16.050 (I plan to wait until lives are in danger to take any action, personally, but any theft over $50 is a felony in Washington just as an example. The statue as written gives very, very wide latitude)

ED: Seriously, NM is 36 and they have a maximum caliber for a carry weapon and no castle statute whatsoever? This list only seems to care about difficulty of acquiring ownership. I feel like the way their categories are set up a state where you could own any gun you wanted machine guns whatever, as long as you kept it in a locked box at the range and only fired it on sundays, would be the #1 state.
 
Last edited:
PA came in #20, I guess that's good. I can have my NFA items here so that makes me happy! Plus, I moved to PA from NJ so pretty much anything was an upgrade! Now if only we can get PA to approve semi-auto rifles for hunting I'd be a happy guy.
 
The neuonces between 40 and 4 are very slight and could change easily based on personal preference IMO.
The worst 10 and best 3 or 4 were not a surprise.
 
The top and bottom made enough sense, but those in the middle were blurred in my opinion... Opinion being the operative word. The piece certainly reads like opinion. Still though, it was interesting! Thank you for sharing it.
 
I currently live in AZ and love the old West tradition regarding guns. There is no requirement to carry a firearm concealed but I believe any responsible gun owner should seek training. Plenty of places to shoot including ranges, national forests and BLM land. Gun shops are plentiful and gun shows are frequent.
Recently I was 4-wheeling on the old gold mining trails and came across a one horse town of Cleator; the only thing there was a bar. I bought a beer and sat on the patio with a scruffy bunch of locals who had six guns holstered on their waist. It brought a smile to my face.
 
A decent general guide, but IMHO, far too subjective and ranking on far too many tangential issues to be "Gospel."

A state that has no firearms or carry restrictions should not be rated an non gun friendly because of lack of a stand your ground law.

OTOH, I'm a little biased because I have very limited respect for the for the "Keyboard Jockeys" at the gun rags.:evil:
 
The neuonces between 40 and 4 are very slight and could change easily based on personal preference IMO.
The worst 10 and best 3 or 4 were not a surprise.

yah, that's kinda what I got out of it too, but I'd say the nuances between 30 and 5 are pretty subjective.
 
Last edited:
The worst state to buy a gun, New Jersey.

You cannot just go down to the local gun store and buy a simple shotgun for self defense or a Daisy BB airgun without going through some of the most ridiculous, redundant and draconian processes of any state.

You have apply for a a Firearm ID Purchasers Card or a permit to purchase a pistol from your police department. An intrusive and draconian process that requires up to three references including a reference from your employer in some towns. Some towns like Jersey City required your references to give their social security numbers out. Other towns might require a reference to be notarized. Some towns add their own requirements to the application.

Then there is the mental health check, the criminal check, you must be fingerprinted (yes fingerprinted in order to buy a gun-even a Daisy BB air rifle or a black powder rifle). All hand guns including a black powder, air pistol as well as regular pistols require a separate permit to purchase a handgun. You can only buy one per month and requires a separate permit to purchase. Once you spent $90 in fees for the paperwork, permits, background checks and fingerprinting. Be prepared to wait anywhere from a month to 4 or 5 months to get your paperwork.

When you finally get your FID or your permit to purchase a pistol. You can now go purchase your desired firearm. However it better not be on Sunday, because the state NICS is closed.

By the way, they are also closed State Holidays and whenever there is a bad snowstorm that closes the state. Also be aware that the State NICS closes at 5:00 pm Saturday. And are only opened up till 8 pm during the week.

Did I mention that there ia an additional $15 mandatory state NICS fee at the point of sale? Silly me, I forgot to mention that there is tax on that $15 fee too.

And New Jersey residents have the privilege of paying $15,000 to $20,000 a year in property taxes for the status as being the worst state to own a gun....Of course that is if you ever get your FID card or Pistol Purchase permit. Remember that even though you have a clean record, the police chief can still veto your application.

And lord help you if you ever move to another town and have to get another FID card with your new address. Be prepared to offer up references and again and pay some more fees and wait months for your new card to arrive.

Now it goes downhill from here. Obtaining a carry permit is impossible, unless you want to become an armed guard and have a letter of need from the employer to prove it....in front of a judge.

I won't mention the assault weapons ban, the very limited places you can shoot your legally bought pistol, or the very limited ways you can transport your legally bought pistol back and forth to the range.

.
 
As a person who lives in Pennsylvania and travels to North Carolina on a regular basis, I find it preposterous that NC outranks PA in terms of gun ownership friendliness.

PA is far more friendly to open carriers, there is no 'going armed to the terror of the public' law which can be thrown at someone who is peaceably carrying.

PA has no duty to inform police officers that you are carrying if you are stopped.

PA requires no permit or license to purchase a handgun.

The list of off-limits places where you are not allowed by law to carry, in North Carolina, is HUGE. I have stopped bothering to carry while I'm out and about in NC, because practically anywhere I go is off-limits. In Pennsylvania, I can go pretty much anywhere except a post office while carrying, including a courthouse (where they are legally required to provide lockers for me to check my sidearm while I'm there).

I would easily place PA in the top ten.
 
Good to see Kentucky made # 5. We have been open carry I think even before we became a state. All NFA allowed. Sheriff required to sign off NFA application in 15 days. No purchase permits. No waiting periods. No mag restrictions, no handgun roster, no AWB. Strong self defense laws. Open and vehicle carry without a permit.

If you do get the permit, it also covers all concealable deadly weapons besides pistols. Including knives and clubs, blackjacks, nunchaku, shuriken, and brass knuckles. We also have KRS § 237.104 which prohibits the state from seizing firearms from private citizens in the event of a disaster or emergency.

While you have to be 21 years old in Kentucky to get the concealed deadly weapons license. The next state over in Indiana the age requirement is 18 to get a carry permit. Plus Indiana offers a lifetime license.
.
 
Iowa placed 16th in G&A’s last “Best States for CCW” ranking, with full recognition of out-of-state permits and strong use-of-force laws. Despite those strengths, the five-year retraining requirement for CCW and pistol permit to purchase hurt the state’s score.

Bit curious as to why this hurt Iowa so much. Your CCL acts as a permit to purchase in addition to allowing you to carry literally any weapon legal in Iowa; openly or concealed. Not too upset since I plan on moving to Colorado or Utah in a few years.
 
They should have stuck with the 5 best and worst and left the rest alone, not enough difference to matter, it's just splitting hairs.
 
Re: Hawaii, ammo is also difficult to obtain locally. My son lives there, and I'm not permitted to mail him any, nor is he permitted to buy any online.

FAA regs do permit ammo in your checked luggage, guess what I bring when I go there? :rolleyes:

Nice outdoor range though just outside Honolulu at the base of Koko Head.

I wonder if the strict firearms laws date to the totally illegal coup staged by American merchants without initial US govt. consent to seize control of the islands from the royal family? Really a black mark in our history. Keep the natives down, forever?
 
We can see from Professor John Lott's website, Hawaii and New Jersey take the prize. :rolleyes:

Hawaii,183 permits, with a population of 1.42 million..

New Jersey, 1212 permits, with a population of 8.93 million.

It's close. Both are incredibly dismal.

Maryland looks better,14,198 out of a population of 5.97 million. But only by degree. :scrutiny:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top