I'd like to apologize for my frequently long posts, but, at least I strive to provide for proper sentence & paragraph structure, punctuation, spelling, and over-all readability, so here you go...
I have a 5.5" blued and a long barreled stainless '58 Piettas. I bought them both on price alone.
I have learned a few things about these guns since, which I will try to convey here.
Due to my middle finger getting battered by the trigger guard I will be carving up the grip strap and trigger guards for clearance as Prairie Dawg outlined for me.
I just don't think I'd be willing to modify the frame,grips and trigger guard like this on the much more expensive Uberti guns if those were what I had bought initially.
I'm not certain if the fabled grip size difference between the two brands addresses this VERY real problem or not. The Pietta definately suffers (or might make you suffer) from this clearance problem.
If I were in the market for a new stainless framed '58, I would most certainly be considering the Uberti though because of thier better engineering of the dovetails on the barrel for the loading ram catch (it's a BIG deal), and the muzzle end site block. Being able to adjust windage is an important variable that I wish I'd been aware of before I'd spent for the stainless gun
Since I figure on carving the recoil shield of my s.s. Pietta for a gated conversion, I may likely spend the bucks to get the Uberti dovetailed sight and the loading ram catch & modify my gun to accept those parts. That's how strongly I feel about that bit of difference between the two brands.
The loading ram catch on the Pietta is a dowel/pin type fit that may or may not be soldered onto the barrel, I have read some accounts of them popping off, If that were to happen to mine, I will most certainly change to Uberti's method.
I've also heard that Uberti does a bit better job of the placement of those uneccessary warning and manufacturer's logo & country of origin lettering (on the underside of barrel, ect.). If I remove my s.s. Pietta barrel for dovetail work (or any otherwise) I will expend the effort to defarb that awful & unneeded signage from the barrel. All and All, I will end up with a Pietta s.s. '58 that will probably be more expensive that if I had bought the Uberti to begin with (that is, before the conversion cylinder & related parts).
You should consider buying the Uberti through the Beretta web store.
If you sign up for thier email promotions, you qualify for some signifigant discount. If you find and register to the Beretta forum, and search for the link to register your forum membership to the Beretta web store, you can qualify for an everyday 15% discount at the Beretta store also.
I suspect that there might not be a better deal for a stainless Uberti '58 New Army ANYwhere else, It would likely be worth your time to check it all out though.
One last thing comes to mind. The Uberti s do, where the Pietta s don't, have access to hardened screw sets as made available by the VTI company.
I know that I just hate worn/buggered screw slots, and even though I have and religiously use the proper size slotted screw bits, the slots still suffer damage eventually.
Now I HATE the fact that the hardened screws are priced somewhere between the value of platinum & silver, but I will ONLY buy a replacement screw ONCE if it is the hardened variety, where the normal factory screws tend to get worn enough for me to consider discarding them after about every eighth to tenth heavy torque event.
I wish VTI would supply the Pietta fitments for these HARD-ass screws, but as of now I don't believe that they are readily available.
Since we are talking black powder guns here, and that dismantling them entirely for proper cleaning is an almost every-use event, the cost of the hardened screws will be offset easily if you are concerned about the appearance of the screws on your guns.
I have a 5.5" blued and a long barreled stainless '58 Piettas. I bought them both on price alone.
I have learned a few things about these guns since, which I will try to convey here.
Due to my middle finger getting battered by the trigger guard I will be carving up the grip strap and trigger guards for clearance as Prairie Dawg outlined for me.
I just don't think I'd be willing to modify the frame,grips and trigger guard like this on the much more expensive Uberti guns if those were what I had bought initially.
I'm not certain if the fabled grip size difference between the two brands addresses this VERY real problem or not. The Pietta definately suffers (or might make you suffer) from this clearance problem.
If I were in the market for a new stainless framed '58, I would most certainly be considering the Uberti though because of thier better engineering of the dovetails on the barrel for the loading ram catch (it's a BIG deal), and the muzzle end site block. Being able to adjust windage is an important variable that I wish I'd been aware of before I'd spent for the stainless gun
Since I figure on carving the recoil shield of my s.s. Pietta for a gated conversion, I may likely spend the bucks to get the Uberti dovetailed sight and the loading ram catch & modify my gun to accept those parts. That's how strongly I feel about that bit of difference between the two brands.
The loading ram catch on the Pietta is a dowel/pin type fit that may or may not be soldered onto the barrel, I have read some accounts of them popping off, If that were to happen to mine, I will most certainly change to Uberti's method.
I've also heard that Uberti does a bit better job of the placement of those uneccessary warning and manufacturer's logo & country of origin lettering (on the underside of barrel, ect.). If I remove my s.s. Pietta barrel for dovetail work (or any otherwise) I will expend the effort to defarb that awful & unneeded signage from the barrel. All and All, I will end up with a Pietta s.s. '58 that will probably be more expensive that if I had bought the Uberti to begin with (that is, before the conversion cylinder & related parts).
You should consider buying the Uberti through the Beretta web store.
If you sign up for thier email promotions, you qualify for some signifigant discount. If you find and register to the Beretta forum, and search for the link to register your forum membership to the Beretta web store, you can qualify for an everyday 15% discount at the Beretta store also.
I suspect that there might not be a better deal for a stainless Uberti '58 New Army ANYwhere else, It would likely be worth your time to check it all out though.
One last thing comes to mind. The Uberti s do, where the Pietta s don't, have access to hardened screw sets as made available by the VTI company.
I know that I just hate worn/buggered screw slots, and even though I have and religiously use the proper size slotted screw bits, the slots still suffer damage eventually.
Now I HATE the fact that the hardened screws are priced somewhere between the value of platinum & silver, but I will ONLY buy a replacement screw ONCE if it is the hardened variety, where the normal factory screws tend to get worn enough for me to consider discarding them after about every eighth to tenth heavy torque event.
I wish VTI would supply the Pietta fitments for these HARD-ass screws, but as of now I don't believe that they are readily available.
Since we are talking black powder guns here, and that dismantling them entirely for proper cleaning is an almost every-use event, the cost of the hardened screws will be offset easily if you are concerned about the appearance of the screws on your guns.