But we all know carrying a loaded Colt SAA on the "safety notch" a real bad idea today.
Yeah, but we're not talkin' about the '73 Colt. But, I'll play.
If a bunch of cowpunchers noticed a Commanche raiding party on yonder hill...do you think they slipped a 6th round into their revolvers and reholstered with the hammers on the quarter-cock notch...or not?
Tactical/fast-draw aside...Why is it such a bad idea to carry a holstered 1911 on half cock? The notch is stronger by far than the hammer hooks. You can pull the trigger until the stirrup bends and not be able to fire the gun, and no gun is as "safe" if it's dropped as it is if it's not dropped. We can "What if" until we talk ourselves out of even loading one.
The pistol wasn't designed to be carried in any one specific way. It was designed to provide a choice, dictated by the situation.
It has an inertial, spring-loaded firing pin that's shorter than its channel...so it can be carried with the hammer down on a loaded chamber.
It was designed with a captive half-cock that disables the trigger/fire control group.
It was designed with a manual safety that blocks the sear and a passive grip safety that blocks the trigger, so it can be carried at full cock.
It can even be carried at full cock with the manual safety disengaged...aka "Condition Zero"... if so desired. The grip safety still blocks the trigger and the half cock will still arrest the hammer.
Your choice.
Again...I'm not advising or suggesting anything. The bottom line is that it's a gun. It's not safe.