aaaRRGGH!! Why do Sigs rust so darn much!

Status
Not open for further replies.
S

silverlance

Member
Joined
Jul 11, 2005
Messages
2,142
Location
In my Foxhole
My sig keeps rusting! i polish, oil, etc, rust again in a few months.

arrgh!

esp that little round piece (mag release, right side)!

other than that it shoots realy well. it's a USED piece and i can easily put a hole right through the one before it using iron sights at 25 feet using cheapie CCI. amazing, really.
 
What has worked for me with all of my firearms is when new I literally soak them in Breakfree CLP, just let it sit and soak in for 15 or 20 minutes. After that I clean normally and about once a year or so I do it again. I have only had a tiny bit of surface rust on the hammer of my SIG P245 in a spot that rarely gets wiped down and probably sees it's share of sweat.

I also clean my guns after every range session and they are stored indoors, not in a garage.

Chris
 
silverlance said:
My sig keeps rusting! i polish, oil, etc, rust again in a few months.

arrgh!

esp that little round piece (mag release, right side)!

other than that it shoots realy well. it's a USED piece and i can easily put a hole right through the one before it using iron sights at 25 feet using cheapie CCI. amazing, really.
Click to expand...

Duke and I have shot our 226s in the rain and so far my Sig looks great. How do you store your pistol?
 
I think part of the problem lies in the fact that it is used. It probably is a carbon steel slide with a blued finish. I have two new Sigs with Nitron over stainless finishes and one new Sig with Ilaflon on carbon steel. Both show no signs of rust. I also have a new Sig P228 with blued over carbon steel. It hasn't rusted yet. They may have improved their corrosion control efforts in recent years on those guns. Normally, blued over carbon steel doesn't provide a whole heck of a lot of corrosion resistance.
 
The only things that have rusted on my current SIGs ( 239,232,2340) have been the grip screws and I really should replace them,but they sorta give some character.My old 225 looked _rough_ by the time I traded it in though and I never carried the 220 so it still looked new.

ETA: obviously there are no grip screws to rust on the Pro!
 
I find it interesting that my P220 has never had rust issues. It is a carbon stamped slide, blued. The bluing on the slide rates a 60% coverage, maximum. I carry it 7 days a week, at least five o fthose in an open, exposed holster as a LEO. Rain, sleet, snow, sun, doesnt matter, its exposed. I wipe it down once a week, never had a speck of rust.
 
I gather NYPD had some rust issues early on with their Sigs. I understand the problem has been resolved.
 
Well the Navy SEALS use them so... maybe the oil you're using isn't meant to stay on very long or something? Because I know blueing by itself does nothing to stop corrosion, it simply provides a base for oil to stay on. Its the oil itself that actually stops rust.

Have you considered that it might be your sweat that is corroding it? Some people have extremely corrosive sweat, that just dissolves unprotected metal in a few days.
 
silverlance said:
My sig keeps rusting! i polish, oil, etc, rust again in a few months.

arrgh!

esp that little round piece (mag release, right side)!

other than that it shoots realy well. it's a USED piece and i can easily put a hole right through the one before it using iron sights at 25 feet using cheapie CCI. amazing, really.
Click to expand...

What parts are you polishing? If its the finish you'll polish thru the finish to the bare metal? Explain please.

No problems with rust on my SIG either. Light coat of oil does wonders. :)
 
This is odd, I've had a P229 since 1996 and live a mile from the ocean, (and only wipe the gun with an untreated cloth after each handling) and have never had any rust in almost a decade here.

Is this a newer Sig issue?

.
 
The decock and slide release levers on my older 239 rust badly. The rest of the pistol is stainless steel and aluminum alloy, but those d@mned levers are blued carbon steel and they rust on me. I had several pistols in Tennessee with me in September and had rust problems on the carbon steel components of all of them -- hammer and trigger on the J-frame, sights on the S&W 4013, and sights (XS Big Dot), mag release, and levers on the Sig. High humidity, carbon steel and I don't mix. :cuss:
 
16 + sigs since 77-8 and never a spot of rust ....

makes no sense to me , even in the rainforest of the PNW in an open holster , never a spot of rust ... how very strange...:confused:
 
The only places any of my SIGs rust are those dang grip screws.

I carry one daily and even in this Dallas heat that's the only place I've run across it. I wipe down the finish with a clean, dry cloth. I might give it a little light going-over with a dab of oil on a cloth maybe once every 6 months or so as far as exterior surfaces, but nothing extraordinary. Mine are all standard garden-variety factory finishes. Either I'm not as naturally juicy as you, or there's something funky about your sweat :D

Regards,
Rabbit.
 
dunno

It's not me, I got it used this way (stupid me for not looking it over VERY closely).

The rest of the sig is wonderful, it's just that little spot where the mag release button thingie shows on the right side of the gun (it's circular, right next to the grip). and it's not major rust, just spotting. but it won't come off. =(

I think i'll just ignore it until i have to replace the mag release, and then i'll worry about finding a gunsmith then.

the rest of the gun is fine - i use breakfree clp.
 
Put a coat of turtle wax car polish over it after you remove the rust next time. That will protect it nicely.
 
Hmmmm, I carry a Sig P-220 two-tone .45 in all kinds of weather, rain, snow, sleet, humid to A/C and back.......not one speck of rust on my gun. And I'm a LEO so I'm standing out in all kinds of crap, especially in the winter here in the northeast.
 
My guess is you have one of the older blued finish guns? If so, the rust is going to be part of life unless you get it refinished. I had one of the Nitron coated 220s and my buddy had one of the older blued guns. We worked at the same place and did the same job and carried them the same way but his would rust and mine wouldn't. You just probably have a gun that is going to be a LOT more prone to rust than some others.

My advice, sell it and get a better finish and poof, all your rust problems will be over.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Similar threads

B
  • Locked
Cant believe the rust\damage on this Ruger LC9
2 3
Replies
64
Views
9K
TimboKhan
TimboKhan
jhb
  • Locked
p238 hd rust problems and holster........
Replies
4
Views
2K
jhb
jhb
J
  • Locked
Sig .22 conversion unit
Replies
3
Views
618
Ohio Rifleman
O
mongoslow
  • Locked
ATI 1911 Commander size
Replies
3
Views
529
rdnktrkr
rdnktrkr
Miami_JBT
  • Locked
Darn Kids these days have it good regarding CCW Options
Replies
22
Views
1K
Mr. Mosin
Mr. Mosin
Back
Top