Accidental discharge wasn't

Status
Not open for further replies.

belercous

Member
Joined
Jan 19, 2010
Messages
299
Location
edwardsville, ILL
I have always maintained that there is no such thing as an "accidental" discharge. (in my younger days I would have argued the converse, except that such discharge did not involve a firearm.) Anyhow, a fellow at the range last year said that he has experienced a couple accidental discharges (of firearms, get your mind out of the gutter) not due to human error (cold weather, grease & firing pin and a sear that just let loose.) I still maintain that it as it was known that the firearm was loaded, and as such, there was no "accidental" discharge. Carelessness or negilgence perhaps, but it wasn't an accident.

I've had two unintended disharges (again, of firearms, not of a hormonal nature), both with my Soviet SKS. As I knew the rifle was loaded and it didn't go "Bang" when the trigger was pulled, I kept the muzzle pointed down range and waited 15 seconds. It could have been a hang-fire. Then I tapped the bolt forward. "Bang." No problem, the muzzle was pointed down range.

The second time it happened, well I knew not to tap the bolt forward, so, pointing the muzzle down-range I jacked the bolt back to eject the unfired round. The bolt closed, chambering a fresh round. "Bang."
I learned something. If an SKS does fire not when the trigger is pulled, still wait 15 seconds, but then don't piss with it. Point the muzzle toward the ground and unload the magazine, then jack the round out. In this order.

Those were my only unintended discharges (of a firearm) in over 30 years of gun ownership (my mother had issues with guns so I was a late starter.) Please keep in mind that I still maintain that there is no such thing as an "accidental" discharge. If the gun is loaded, an accidental discharge is rare (a sear letting loose counts as accidental, but where the muzzle is pointed is not an accident) any damage done is not an accident.

Now, I've always been fairly saftey consciuos with guns, espescially so when others are around. I've found rounds chambered in guns handed to me that the owner forgot about as I always check the chamber upon being handed a weapon. Even when the person handing me the gun has just unloaded it.

Well, lemme tell ya, don't trust yourself. I've dry-fired my S&W Model 36 snubbie which I keep next to my computer hundereds of times, just to keep up on my skill. Last night I tilted it up and to the right, released the chamber then tilted it straight up. The cartidges dropped out as they always had. Two problems here. I got complacent. First, I didn't count the rounds that dropped. Second, I didn't double check the cylinder. You can see where this is going.

I leveled off, and using one hand, cocked the pistol. I took aim at a guitar about 7 feet away (I didn't have my glasses on), focused on the toggle switch, and slowly pulled the trigger. I then heard a satisfying click and saw that I was still on target. (hey, this dry-firing ain't for nuthin')

I then re-cocked the pistol and took aim at the same switch on the guitar. Slowly I pulled the trigger. Well, the pick-up selector switch won't bother anyone on this Earth anymore. I liked to jump out of my skin when I heard the Bang, saw the flash, etc. Certain of my bodily products did however seem fit to proclaim their liberation upon this event, and did so in a big hurry.

My ears are still ringing. This was in not an "accidental" disharge. It was a discharge due to Stoopid, or as I prefer to phrase it, due to carelessness or laxity. But on my behalf to be sure.

Now pardon me for saying this, but "carelessness or laxity," while not accidental, is however, stupid. Distracted also counts as stupid. A little matter of personal responsiblity here. Guns ain't nothing to be lax or casual around. The weird thing is, the projectile was never found (Hornaday .38 SPCL 125 gr XTP). It only went thru about 1/2" of wood, 3/16" of plastic pickgaurd and 1/4 of the metal selector switch. No mark could be found on the wall behind the guitar (although the projectile exited) and I cannot find the copper jacket or whatever was inside it. It wasn't in the guitar or on the floor. Weird.

Why I'm telling the world about my stupidity is not intelligible, nor to my benefit. However, it happened to me. Someone I would have never thought could happen to. Now, I shoot about 4,000 rounds a year, pistol & rifle.
When I was an A&P (aircraft mechanic) I've had many pilots tell me that there are two kinds of pilots. Those that have landed with the gear-up, and those that will. I thought that was b.s. as I always used the checklist when I flew. But then again I quit flying after I got lost once. But still, their point applies here; Do something long enough and your rote actions or laxity could bite you.

The gist of this post is, don't get complacent; you are not above making a mistake.
 
I'm not sure what all the double entendre about ejaculation added to this discussion.

That said, it's true that many people say "accidental" when they really ought to say "negligent." Regardless of the term, it's a serious offense that needs to be critically examined. I have never personally had a ND, and I strive and hope never to get complacent enough to do so.

By the way...what does "cold weather" have to do with a ND or AD?
 
That's called learning the hard way. Unloading, then closing the action of a revolver without looking in the cylinder is worse than racking an autoloader without looking at the chamber.

Glad no one was hurt or arrested. I hope you find that bullet, though. Isn't that bugging you? :)
 
I concur with texas bulldog, some things written that could have been left out. With that being said, we are not here to 'grade' what you wrote, so I will move into what I wanted to say and that is:

Excellent Write-up! It all makes sense and it is all true. No disfire of a firearm is accidental, yes, they happen, but it is not accidental but rather more a lack of safety when handling weapons (in this case the weapon being a firearm).

This would be no different than slicing your hand on a kitchen butcher knife as the last person who laid it in its place did so with the sharp edge of the blade in a prone-to-cutting position. Either that person or the next person reaches in and there is a hand against a razor-sharp knife! Accident? No, no accident, but rather poor thinking on the person's part who stowed the knife away in such a manner!:uhoh:
 
The problem with dry firing practice is that people choose targets that aren't that important. TVs, guitars, whatnot. Start dry firing at your foot, you'll check the chamber or cylinder real good then,
 
I'm not sure what all the double entendre about ejaculation added to this discussion.

I concur with texas bulldog, some things written that could have been left out. With that being said, we are not here to 'grade' what you wrote, so I will move into what I wanted to say

It is the poster's way of adding levity to a scary and disconcerting event. Cut the man a break...he surely feels bad enough and is only trying to caution us all.
 
While I agree that, in most instances, unintended shootings are Negligent, not Accidental, I do not believe that that is always the case. There are such a thing as Accidental Discharges.

Take the example of a hunter, carrying his rifle, when he trips, slips, or falls. The rifle is dropped and the impact sets it off. No one is in control of direction and the trigger is not pulled. This is almost certainly Accidental. One could argue that the hunter should have purchased a rifle without this flaw, though it could well be impossible to tell any firearm had such a flaw before the purchase.

What if that flaw isn't present, but the hunter's dog, excited by the unexpected fall and concern for the hunter, steps on the trigger before the hunter can regain either sense or weapon control. Is this Negligent because the hunter owned a dog? I can hardly say yes.

How about a soldier in combat? The magazine in his weapon takes a hit, cooking off every round inside it as well as the one in the chamber. Is this Negligent because the soldier shouldn't have been in combat? What if that soldier is a conscripted and has never had any choice about going into combat?

One could easily claim that these situations are extremely unlikely and may never happen, and I would agree, but that doesn't mean that they aren't possible. I firmly agree that most ADs are, in fact, NDs, but I can't support the hypothesis that ALL ADs are actually NDs. Accidents do happen. Not everything is someone's fault.
 
ac·ci·den·tal (ks-dntl)
adj.
1. Occurring unexpectedly, unintentionally, or by chance.

Sounds like it is both accidental and negligent.
 
One could compare this to having a motor vehicle collision.

There are people who believe that motor vehicle collisions are not accidents. When you investigate any motor vehicle mishap, you will find that if something was or was not done a certain way, this would not have happened.

If you spin out on an icy bridge, it could be argued that you were driving too fast for conditions. If the driver says "well, I thought it was above freezing out" - that still does not matter as the driver should be aware of the road surface he is on.

I think, instead of referring to something like happenstance as an accident, it should really be referred to as an incident.
 
Negligient discharge - caused by the shooter (ex - finger on the trigger when it shouldn't be)

Accidental discharge - malfunction of the weapon (ex - the Remington 700 rifle)
 
I am an old old old guy...have had guns and shot for over 55 years...the older I get the more cautious I get when handling any weapon. Tis true familiarity breeds complacency and it takes work and a mind set to handle any weapon as if it is waiting to go off unexpectedly. Never had a ND/AD so I might be due one, so even when closing the bolt or chambering a round I expect it to go off; confirmed empty or not...not paranoid just do not want to have my first unexpected discharge...ego?.. Thanks for the post and honesty..
 
The issue with your SKS sounds like a slamfire. Have Murray's put in a firing pin return spring and that won't ever happen again.

Other than that, thanks for sharing the story and the reminder.
 
To texasbulldog, I believe what belercous was getting at with the cold, is that depending on how cold it is, the type of firing mechanism and type of oil/lubricant being used can cause issues. I have experienced, though only once an issue due to the cold not that it caused any safety issues because I was well aware. I was shooting a round of trap back in early January with an old bolt 16, yes I know its not a trap gun I just wanted to see how it shot. The gun was a mossberg 195. When I recieved the gun I completely stripped cleaned and resembled. Everything functioned as it should. I went to the range and fired several round without a hitch aside from being no where near the little clay birds. After one shot, I worked the bolt pulled it back and pulled it right out the back of the gun. Due to the cold the oiler stiffened up and didn't allow the trigger to return to forward to the position it would catch the bolt. I new it was a possibility due to not using a different oil and took the precautions, however I can see how depending on the function of a particular action design, weather effects upon the oil can cause things to snag or be stiff and not function properly. That being said, I would assume in most instances like that the result would be a failure to fire and not a random fire. But thats why we check actions, count rounds and always point the muzzle in a safe direction. I'm a revolver guy, there have been a few times at the range where I thought I fired 6, but I always squeeze the trigger one more time before swinging the cylinder out, every once in a while there is one more hole in the paper. That being said I always treat it as if it is fully loaded and live. Hope I didn't get too off topic.
 
Dont feel bad, i did the same thing about 20-some years ago , i was doing something with my ruger 10/22 and i think it was i had the scope mounted not-perfectly level on gun so i was in my bedroom pointing the gun towards the mirror in the bathroom across the hall and i must have chambered a round before i dropped the clip out and normally i dont dry-fire ANY weapon (i dont care how many people say it dosent hurt them) but i did,, and it went thru the medicine-cabinet mirror-door,thru the wall and what fragments remained lodged into the neighbors steel-siding !! i snuck over there after dark that night and filled the hole with caulk so as not to draw attention to my obvious stupidity,, i have never had an incident since ,, i think the fact that it scared the SH*@ out of me helped etch the 4-rules into my head,, glad to hear no-one was hurt !!
 
The problem with dry firing practice is that people choose targets that aren't that important. TVs, guitars, whatnot. Start dry firing at your foot, you'll check the chamber or cylinder real good then,

Yeah, please lets don't take this advice as serious, anyone.:eek: That would be pretty much a clear violation of Rule 2, as if destroying the guitar wasn't a big enough one already.

How about we agree that, if the quoted statement was intended as a joke, we probably should not joke about such things on a forum where not everyone is as experienced or wise as the poster?
 
When I was in the poice academy there was a man that was charged with murder because while he was driving in his truck with his cousin, his gun that was propped up between the console "somehow fell to the side and fired." It hit his cousin in the face almost point blank. Because his story was so unbelievable they took him to jail. The detectives put the rifle in the same spot leaning up in the center console and without anything in the action tried to duplicate his story. The detective said that nine times out of ten the rifle would fall and discharge exactly like the man had said. The man went free.

I should mention that the detective was still suspicious that the guy probably knew what the gun would do if he leaned it up like that, but there was no way for him to proove it.
 
Accidental Discharge
Negligent Discharge
Unintentional Discharge

I'm amazed at the time and effort people spend getting bogged down in semantics.

I see it all the time on another forum where people are all anal about the license/permit debate. Sheesh, they attack people when they use the wrong term.

Your SKS insidences are due to faulty feeding of the ammo, and poor firearm design (pulling trigger without cartridge fully seated allows sear to disengage upon pushing the bolt forward). These are design flaws that you properly handled by keeping your gun pointed in a safe direction.

Your .38 issue is due to poor technique(didn't visually inspect chambers) as others have point out. Lesson learned the easy way, nobody was hurt and a minor financial cost replace what you shot. Call it whatever you want, your technique was highlighted in a flash(literally).

I want to ask you if alcohol had anything to do with you shooting your amp with guitar.38?
 
I've had two unintended disharges (again, of firearms, not of a hormonal nature), both with my Soviet SKS. As I knew the rifle was loaded and it didn't go "Bang" when the trigger was pulled, I kept the muzzle pointed down range and waited 15 seconds. It could have been a hang-fire. Then I tapped the bolt forward. "Bang." No problem, the muzzle was pointed down range.

The second time it happened, well I knew not to tap the bolt forward, so, pointing the muzzle down-range I jacked the bolt back to eject the unfired round. The bolt closed, chambering a fresh round. "Bang."
I learned something. If an SKS does fire not when the trigger is pulled, still wait 15 seconds, but then don't piss with it. Point the muzzle toward the ground and unload the magazine, then jack the round out. In this order.

This means there's something wrong with your firing pin assembly. Most likely it's dirty and the firing pin is partially stuck, which is causing the slam fires. Your rifle is capable of firing every time you chamber a round now. Not only when you have a "failure to fire". I would fix this problem first before loading the rifle again.
 
The definition of "accident" does not speak to cause one way or the other. If you did not intend for the gun to fire, the shot can be correctly referred to as an "accident". The cause, be it negligence or not, is not germane to the "accident" reference.
 
Same thing almost happened to me. I dry fire regularly. I took my GP100 out of the safe, ejected the rounds as I always do (except for one this time). Didn't check the cylinder and didn't count. Carried it down stairs and happened to see a round was in the cylinder when viewed from the side.:eek: I was lucky it was not on the right side of the gun.

It was a real wake up.

Now, I eject the rounds, look at the cylinder, spin the cylinder, and close it. It is a little routine that helps alot.
 
Certain of my bodily products did however seem fit to proclaim their liberation upon this event, and did so in a big hurry.

Now, was this accidental discharge of a hormonal nature? :D

Kidding aside, I'm glad no one got hurt (aside from your ears :(), and thanks for the reminder that anybody can have an ND if we let our guard down. I haven't had one of my own, yet, but I don't mind being jolted every so often out of any complacency that might have surreptitiously crept into my handling of firearms.

The gist of this post is, don't get complacent; you are not above making a mistake.

Yep, when one starts believing that they can't is right about the time when one actually does. :uhoh:

Now, I eject the rounds, look at the cylinder, spin the cylinder, and close it. It is a little routine that helps alot.

As I've often said, when we do make mistakes in handling firearms (and we're only human, after all), if anything can save us it would be our habits--things we do without even thinking about them. Always reinforce safe habits and try to break unsafe ones.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top