Are the gun safety rules flawed ?

Status
Not open for further replies.

karhu

Member
Joined
May 22, 2006
Messages
24
Hi,

First i would like to say congratulations for this informative forum.


After reading lots of posts about negligent / accidental discharges that happened to persons that have been handlings firearms for many years (and know for sure the rules for safely handling firearms), I was wondering if we should come to the conclusion that guns are inherently dangerous and it is just a matter of time before an AD/ND will occur, or maybe the "gun safety rules" are flawed and they contribute for AD/ND to happen.

I know that unless a massive mechanical failure happen, guns will never fire unless we press the trigger and it is impossible that a gun fires if there is no round in the chamber either, so something must be wrong with the rules, otherwise AD/ND wouldn't happen at least to the experienced members of the gun community, but they happen…


These are the 4 rules as found from the Internet:

------------------
Rule # 1
Treat all guns as if they are loaded.
Unloaded guns cause the more accidents than loaded ones. Always treat all guns as if they are loaded.

Rule # 2
Never let the muzzle of a gun point at anything you do not want to destroy or kill.
This rule is especially important for those supervising novice shooters. When a child holds a rifle for example, if he hears a noise to the side, and turns his head, the weapon tends to follow. Similarly, if you make a great shot, and look back to brag to your friends, don't let the weapon follow your gaze.

Rule # 3
Keep your finger straight and off the trigger.
At all times you must keep your trigger finger straight, and off the trigger. Only once you have aimed and have your target in the sights should you permit your finger to gently rest on the trigger. This prevents accidental discharges should you stumble, trip, or be subjected to some unexpected event.

Rule # 4
Be absolutely sure of your target, and what is behind it.
-------------------------


The main problem with these rules is that they do not acknowledge that humans make mistakes (and guns can have mechanical failures) : a finger can slip and press the trigger, an external safety can be disconnected (and we think and act assuming it is still on), a thumb can slip while decocking a gun, the trigger might get pressed when holstering/unholstering, a round can be in the chamber even after we are "sure" the gun is empty, dry firing (and/or cleaning) a supposedly unloaded gun… racking the slide with the finger in the trigger… slam fire, mechanical failure in the decocking system, … etc, etc…

If you read carefully, you can notice that none of these potential 'deadly' scenarios are covered by the 'gun safety rules'

Then, my question is:


Can we create a short set of rules that complement/replace the current 4 gun safety rules ?

At least for me, rule #1 sounds ambiguous, and it should be replaced with something more simple like: "never dry fire"
maybe adding a 5th rule like: "keep your gun in its holster and only unholster it in the range, for cleaning, or to defend your life - no exceptions allowed ! "
and increasing the safety of rule #3

Then, what do you think about this set of rules?

----------------------------------------------------------------
Rule # 1
Never dry fire
You can't be 100% sure 100% of the time that there is no round in the chamber. So if you dry fire, you might/will end up with a AD/ND - it is just a matter of time.

Rule # 2
Never let the muzzle of a gun point at anything you do not want to destroy or kill.

Rule # 3
Keep your finger straight and off the trigger. (and if carrying an autoloader never carry it with a round in the chamber - the safety could be turned off when you least expect it)
At all times you must keep your trigger finger straight, and off the trigger. Only once you have aimed and have your target in the sights should you permit your finger to gently rest on the trigger. This prevents accidental discharges should you stumble, trip, or be subjected to some unexpected event.

Rule # 4
Be absolutely sure of your target, and what is behind it.

Rule # 5
"Keep your gun in its holster and only unholster it in the range, for cleaning it, or to defend your life - no exceptions allowed ! "

------------------------------------------------------------------



Opinions? Can we create a set of rules that will reduce the number of AD/ND ?




regards,
 
If you read the four basic rules, you will see that you have to break more than one at a time to cause injury or damage.

I have seen rule 1 and rule 3 accidental discharges.
I have seen rule 2 and rule 4 competitor disqualifications.
But nobody got hurt because they didn't break but one safety rule at once.

Your rule 1 is ridiculous. A day without dryfiring is a day without learning.
 
I was wondering if we should come to the conclusion that guns are inherently dangerous and it is just a matter of time before an AD/ND will occur, or maybe the "gun safety rules" are flawed and they contribute for AD/ND to happen.

I smell a troll. If I am wrong you have my apology in advance. I have never had an AD/ND discharge. I have never even come close. My wife calls me the safety Nazi when it comes to firearms. Accidents will happen, but every AD/ND I have read about the safety rules was broken. I do not think the rules are flawed. I think people become overconfident in anything they do and become lazy when following rules, just watch how some people drive.
 
ccw007 said:
I smell a troll.

I don't think so. I'll give him the benefit of the doubt and say he's overly cautious.


karhu said:
Rule # 3
...and if carrying an autoloader never carry it with a round in the chamber - the safety could be turned off when you least expect it

I don't expect this one to fly. Look up any of the threads on whether or not to carry a round in the chamber on that one. And frankly, I agree with them. I carry a Glock. There are no active safties. The safety is ALWAYS "turned off." Just because there is no active safety doesn't mean the gun will fire on its own. Sure, fingers slip and safties come off, but if you are careful you can avert most of those problems. I've carried for three years now and never (knock on wood) had a ND. And my ability to defend myself efficently outweighs the small possibility that I will have a ND.


karhu said:
Rule # 5
"Keep your gun in its holster and only unholster it in the range, for cleaning it, or to defend your life - no exceptions allowed ! "

So I guess my best friend and I taking our guns out and disassembling them all over the couch because we are bored is a bad idea, huh?



My philosophy is basically that safety is a lifestyle, not something that can be distilled down into a few discrete rules that must ALWAYS be followed at every time in every place. The four rules are a good place to start, but if you break one that probably doesn't mean it's time to sell your guns.
 
The rules are fine. Additional tampering makes them unwieldy.

Besides, as I am fond of saying: "Some idiots are beyond proof", or: "Make something idiot proof, and someone will make a better idiot."

For example, taking the rules to their logical conclusion, one would never field strip/clean either a Glock or a Kahr (and possibly others) since you have to pull the trigger to remove the slide. Now, if I always believe that all guns are always loaded, I wouldn't pull that trigger. Likewise, since I don't intend to shoot, I wouldn't even put my finger in the trigger guard. However, when I am cleaning my Glocks or Kahr, I drop the mag, rack the slide, examine the chamber, examine the chamber again, and then pull the trigger. I have just, technically, broken all of the rules. I treated the gun as if it was unloaded, I pointed my gun at my bookcase, I put my finger on the trigger, and my neighbor could be in his yard just beyond my wall.

As a result, do we need a new set of rules? No, instead we need rational people making rational choices and acting responsibly. The rules are really guidelines, and messing with them makes them unmanageable.
 
The rules work, and they acknowledge the fact that people make mistakes. Find me an example of a ND that results injury where there weren't at least two rules broken, and we can discuss it. If you can't follow 4 simple rules without breaking 2 of them, do you really think you are going to do any better with 6, or 10 or 100?
The rules aren't flawed; people are.
 
hi,

thanks for your comments.

i think everybody is entitled to his own opinion, and mine says that something must be wrong with these rules for so many AD/ND to happen


here is a collection of AD/ND (collected from just a few threads in this forum)



regards,

===========================================




----------

-I cleaned my pistol one day and left it empty-empty magazine and empty chamber. Left it on my nightstand. Went to work. Came home and picked up the pistol. Aimed it at the floor, cocked it, and pulled the trigger. BOOM! My father had loaded it while I was at work for some unknown reason.
----------

-Was going to do some dryfiring and emptied my S&W 13 and failed to count cartridges or look at the cylinder, and shot my TV,
----------

- I have. A 1917 30.06 Eddystone. I was getting ready to go hunting. The bolt was open and I decided to put the safety on in mid action. I then closed the bolt. When I took the saefty off the gun fired without pulling the trigger.

----------

- Year before last though, on a hunting trip, my Dad (who is honestly the safest guy I know when it comes to guns) had an AD that was a real wake-up for all of us.

We'd been hacking and beating our way through some really heavy brush, and our assumption is that a branch or something must have pushed his safety off - he hunts with a Remington 7400 in .30-06, and it has one of those push-button safeties behind the trigger. The gun was hanging from his right shoulder, and he reached around with his left hand and grabbed it near the trigger to take it down. It was around 5 or 6 degrees that day, and he had a heavy pair of gloves on, and apparently grabbed the trigger in the process.

Thank God the gun was pointing straight up in the air when it went off, but it was pretty scary. Dad's hat landed a good 10 feet away from him, and he couldn't hear much out of his right ear for a few days.


----------



- Yes, was clearing my Jennings J22, thought I had the last bullet out and pulled the trigger and it went off. thought I had killed the cat.

----------

- Dry firing my S&W 66. Didn't count the rounds that came out, before pulling the trigger. A 125 gr .357 makes a "bit" of noise when fired in a bedroom.
----------


- Not me, but my friend's brother accidently shot his .40 cal S&W Sigma through the ceiling of his sister's living room. He went to chamber a round with his finger on the trigger.
----------

-I blew a .410 hole thru the front porch decking.
a rangy feral cat was hunting birds at the bird feeder so I quietly slipped out the front door with my old single shot. While thumbing the hammer back, my thumb slipped off and it discharged.
----------

- Yes. Recently in fact. I had just installed an extension on a shotgun and wanted to be sure there were no feeding hangups. I loaded the gun and began to cycle rounds through it. I counted the ejected rounds, there were 7-that's normally how I keep my guns-empty chamber and a full mag tube.

I actually put my finger physically on each of the rounds that I had put on the table, counting them out loud as I did it. I pointed the gun at the window and pulled the trigger and heard the loudest sound I have ever known! There was flying glass and a dead window shade.

Somehow I had loaded an extra round into the gun, still not sure why or how. That will teach me to do a physical chamber check before dropping the hammer.


----------

- I was dry-firing in my bedroom (in the basement). I finished, loaded the pistol for the night, and set it down. My brother's dog came downstairs to maul me for a minute, and then went back upstairs. I thought, "What was I doing? Oh, I was dry-firing." I picked up the pistol, and pointed (not aimed) it at my bedroom door, which covers my closet when opened.

I was concentrating on a slow, steady squeeze when it went off. The strange thing is that I didn't hear it -- complete auditory exclusion -- but I did see the fireball at the end of the barrel, and the hole that developed in the door. The bullet lodged in a stud inside the closet, where it has remained.

The gun was an FEG Hi Power in 9mm.

I'm absolutely anal about double- and triple-checking that guns are unloaded now.


----------



- Yes, I live in a rural area, I had until recently, a 100 yard range in my yard, I was sighting in a winchester 9422 Magnum for the approching squirrel season, when I completed the sight-in, I pulled the magazine tube, dumped the cartridges into the bench, jacked the one out of the chamber and casually pointed the gun downward and pulled the trigger-----I never thought about the cartridge rideing on the carrier,,,,,,a sudden awakeing I assure you, fortunately no damage was done other than ego!

----------

- I had just bought a Security Six and I was reading a book on how to shoot. I decided to practice dry firing like it said in the book. I unloaded it and sat in my lounge chair and aimed at the gas valve handle on the fireplace. It clicked four times and then fired. I was so shocked that I couldn't move for a few minutes. Fortunately, the gun shot a little low and to the right and I just missed the valve. It went though the tile and the dry wall in the closet in the next room. It was loaded with a 38 special. Now I look into every chamber in my revolver and stick my finger in the chamber of my 1911 before I do anything.

----------

- Never have had it personally happen but when I was in Army Basic Training we had an AD happen in the barracks while cleaning rifles. It was at the end of the cycle and we had to clean all of the weapons to to an asine level of cleanness so every weapon in the arms room was up there. Well one of the weapons that was issued to a soildier that got chaptered out somehow had gotten turned in a round in the chamber thankfully only a blank(though it sounded like a regular round w/o the blank adapter on the rifle. So one of the guys in my platoon pulled the trigger before he started to take it apart and that weapon went bang

----------

- I bought a $10 .22 rifle from a pawn shop 25 years ago for some reason the round would not chamber so I bumped the bolt with the palm of my hand and the round went off. My finger was no where near the trigger.
About an hour before I was doing the same thing but my wife kept walking in front of the gun and making stupid comments so I put it up.
From the angle from where I was sitting to the bullet hole in the wall and her height the bullet would have hit her in the forehead if she had been standing there.
----------

- New pistol + finger on exceptionally light trigger too soon = bullet hole in range floor a few feet form the line and slightly irritated RO
----------

- My father shot his ceiling once with an "unloaded" .22 rifle. First he pointed it at his foot, but he wised up, (somewhat), and decided to point it at the roof instead before pulling the trigger. BANG goes the rifle.
----------


- The closest I have come personally to a ND was when I was at my friends house when I was 15, and he let me look at his shotgun. He didn't tell me it was loaded, so I worked the action to find the feel, and I saw a cartrage pop up to the bolt. Not knowing how to stop it from feeding, I racked the round, and couldn't figure out how to dump the chamber, (I never handled a shotgun at that point). So I just turned the safety on, and handed it back to him, saying "here you go". Darn I felt like a fool.

----------

- Dad shot a hole in his headboard with a PPK once. It was the first (and last) time I saw dad work the action of a gun with his finger on the trigger.
----------


- 2 months ago i was at my local range firing my G26. When i was on my last magazine of the day, i decided to strip the gun and clean it. I removed the magazine, and foolishly forgot to rack the slide. I pointed the muzzle downrange, and squeezed the trigger. To my surprise, the gun went bang. I was a bit startled (thankfully i did have my ears on) and then embarrassed when i realized my mistake.
----------

- Pulled the mag from my Glock 19 pulled the trigger in preparation to dissassembly for cleaning and...you guessed it BANG!.
----------


- All my pistols are kept loaded and ready to fire but I have never had had a negligent discharge. Before I disassemble a pistol I remove the magazine, rack the slide and remove the chambered round, visually inspect the chamber and magazine well, rack it three more times and inspect the chamber and magazine well one more time. Otherwise I keep my finger outside of the trigger guard. Do that every time and your chances of a negligent discharge should be zero.


Reply: I haven't read all of the posts on this thread. I did read where one poster kept all of his weapons loaded. I once did this. And it led to a negligent discharge. I unloaded the weapon and visually checked that it was unloaded. A few minutes later, I had a negligent discharge and shot the central air conditioner unit. What happened? I have several revolvers that are exact duplicates of other revolvers I own. Thinking I was handling the unloaded revolver, I picked up its loaded twin. The event convinced me to do two things: only load weapons intended for immediate use, carry, or home defense...and to check the status of any weapon every time I pick it up...no matter how many times I've already checked.

----------

- I came very close.

My father had put a rifle away in the gun safe, with the box magazine full, but the chamber empty. This is because he needs it for quick access to shoot groundhogs.

Under the assumtion that guns are generally unloaded in the safe, I pulled it out, opened the bolt (noting the lack of a round flying out), and even stuck my pinky in the chamber to verify a round was not stuck in the chamber (extractors can fail...I picked up this habit from my 10/22 that had a failing extractor).

Then I shut the bolt and put in on the bed. Of course, this stripped a round from the magazine and loaded it

I later went to dryfire it, and actually had my finger on the trigger, when my psychotic safety tendencies forced me to double check the chamber. What do you know, a Hornady Vmax sailed across the room, and and I about wet my pants.

----------


- I had a brain fart a couple days ago.

I was working on a 1911, got out my Taurus automatic, set it aside and finshed working on the 1911.

Grabbed the Taurus, pointed it at the floor, racked the slide and ejected the chambered round, which I knew was in there.

What I forgot to do was remove the magazine first! I realized the slide sounded funny when it closed, so I racked it again and another round came out, that's when I saw I had left the magazine in it.

Since I had pointed it at the floor, I couldn't see that the magazine was still in the weapon.

----------

- Had a defective safety on a P38. Ended up with a hole in the floor when i applied it.
Never carried a DA/SA auto since either.

----------

- My first and only AD was when I was 12 and hunting ducks with my dad and using an Iver Johnson 16 ga single shot, which I still have. I had pulled the hammer back and did not shoot so was going to lower it. It was colder than blazes, so I had thick gloves on. The muzzle was pointed down and right in front of me and my dad. When the shot pattern appeared in the dirt, he simply looked at me and said something about "that is why you never point a loaded gun at something you do not intend to kill."
----------
 
and a few more AD/ND


=============================================




- I have never AD/ND'ed, but I did do something stupid once.

I used to keep my ruger 22/45 handgun in my room because i liked to shoot at squirrels/birds with it from my back porch. I didnt keep it loaded but i kept a loaded mag next to it.

One day i grabbed the mag and gun, went out on the porch, loaded it and shot at a squirrel ( i missed ). Took out the magazine, racked the slide to eject cartridge and put it back in its holster in my room.

A couple of days later i went to shoot at another squirrel. So i grabbed my gun and put the magazine but didnt rack the slide. I went out on the back porch and went to rack the slide. I pulled it back, let it go and it only went forward about 1/8th an inch and stopped. Wierd, i thought, must of stovepiped. Tried again. Until I actually looked at the chamber and found a round already in the tube and a round right behind it that i was trying to feed. I sat dumbfounded for a few seconds until i realised what i had done. The day before, I didnt visually inspect the chamber to ensure the round ejected. My ejector had failed.

Easy lesson learned: ALWAYS visually inspect the chamber.

----------


- A young man was killed in SE Arkansas recently in a firearm accident. He and a friend were firing a Norinko SKS which became jammed. While trying to clear the jam, the round in the action (not chambered) fired and all or part of the casing was ejected and struck the boy killing him.
That's a surprisingly informative story. Apparently it was a piece of the shellcasing that entered the boy's body, rather than the bullet. The sheriff says (and I agree with him) that this was an unforeseeable accident.

If you have a missfire, leave the bolt closed and point the firearm downrange for a minute. Then unload the rifle and sharply eject the round so that it lands in a safe area. Then leave it be for a bit before disposing of it.

If your firearm is malfunctioning, unload it entirely before working on it. Keep chambers clean.
----------

- After a morning of typical classroom safety instruction, we headed out to the range for the "live fire" portion of the class. I was having a bit of a problem with the brand-new Springfield XD I was using (turned out to be an ammo issue) and I was in the process of putting it away during a ceasefire to swap it out for my GP-100 when suddenly I hear a "BANG!" so I'm thinking, whoever that was just got into deep squat with the RO instructor. Well, guess who? It turns out the cute lil' gal with the Ruger .22 was having a problem/question so one of the big, brave, knowledgeable instructors was helping her when he cut one loose on accident. Fortunately the other three rules were being followed and no one was hurt, but he sure got some looks.

That is the ONLY ND I have ever witnessed, and done by an "instructor" who was no doubt "distracted" while handling a loaded firearm.


----------



- I was unloading my Winchester 1890, my backyard squirrel gun. We had company coming over and he was a hunter, so I thought I'd show him my guns, so I was unloading this one before they got there. I had just helped my wife lotion her back, so my hands were a little slippery. Add to that, I was rushed and not thinking. Instead of taking out the magazine tube and dumping the .22s out first, I was racking the pump slide for every round, then lowering the hammer with my thumb. Well, after 2 or 3, my thumb slipped off the hammer. It lodged into the bottom of the baseboard, just where it meets the carpet, about 3 or 4 inches from the sliding glass door.

Here's what really shook me up about it. My wife was on the couch to my right, and my daughter (2yr old) was walking up behind me to see what I was doing. It took me about 20 years of gun handling to become complacent, but it got my attention for sure!

----------

- Not in the house. Knock on wood,(my head for one), the only AD I've had was when I was 15 (I'm 48 now)and rabbit huntin with my BIL. I had an old Mossberg 20 gauge, bolt action, with 2 round magazine and adjustable screw on choke. (It's since been stolen). Anyway, I couldn't remember if the slide safety was up for safe, down for fire, so I put it where I thought it was safe, and had the gun pointed down. Pulled the trigger and dang near blew my bil's foot off. He's about 6 years older than me, and short of beating the snot out of me, he got his message across pretty good. It was good lesson for me. Thankfully no one got hurt.

----------


- i have shot the ceiling of the indoor range i go to. i was embarrassed when it happened but then didint feel as bad when i looked at the ceiling and noticed many holes in it.


----------

- We were in Hunters safety course and the high dollar Fenwerkbau pellet gun discharged as I closed the breech. Another new hole in the ceiling tile. Instructor was mad, guy next to me saw the whole thing and told the teacher I did not have my finger anywhere even near the trigger and was simply closing the action. One hand was on the forend of the stock, the other on the long pump like arm that closed the breech and pumped up some air I suppose. Bottom line, both hands were at least 1 foot away from the trigger during discharge. Good safety lesson, bad gun.


----------


- When my Dad was a kid he had a bolt action .410. It's in my cabinet now, hasn't been shot in ages. Here's why. Dad was getting ready to go bust some bunnies and tree rats, figured he'd just top off the mag (detachable box) before putting on the gloves and stepping out into January weather. He works the bolt, BANG! upon closing. He'd put so many rounds through it that the sear is worn WAY beyond safe limits. If I take it out of the cabinet now, work the bolt and put the safety on, I can drop the firing pin by tapping the trigger SIDEWAYS.


----------

- My near ND was shortly after returning stateside from the service. Single life as a civilian was agreeing with me, had a job and apartment all to myself. Shotgun by bedside, out of habit. One night I'm laying in bed, sound asleep, when I here a "Whump!" and I come up with the shottie, I actually really woke up when the bolt went foreward. That's when I saw the laundry I'd stacked up had fallen over. You know, single guy, last pair of skivvies, 8 baskets of clothes to do all at once. Stacking them up gives a Tower of Pisa effect.

----------

- Up until recently I had not had any sort of mishap in 25 years of
shooting/handling a firearm. I had become complacent, lazy, although
I thought I was being safe and knew exactly what I was doing I obviously
did not or else I would not be posting this now.

A high velocity Remington .40 is rather loud when it goes off in a small room.

I was getting ready to go to the store to buy some groceries, my CCW is the
last thing I add when I head out the door. I have an IWB holster that I
altered to carry my HK .40 upside-down in a cross draw manner down the back
of my pants. I put it in place and tightened my belt but something did not feel
right.

Mistake #1., I drew my HK (adhering to the 4 rules) adjusted my
holster and re-holstered my HK without loosening my belt.

..... the holster should have been removed, adjusted and reseated with the
HK holstered.

Mistake #2., I did not check my decock when the HK was re-holstered.

The HK still did not seem to sit correctly so I upholstered it again (adhering
to one less rule than before) and a ND occurred.

Mistake #3., repeating previous mistakes.

Mistake #4., My finger was not held out of the trigger guard.

It was an odd feeling when it went off. I automatically hit the decock and do
not even remember it. I was pointing it at the dresser draw I kept it in when
I discharged it.

----------

- Ok, so about 2.5 hours ago I had my first negligent discharge. To make it worse, it was in my house. Like everyone on this list who has never had an ND, I assumed that it would never happen to me.
The incident:
My wife and I attended a Christmas party tonight and I was carrying as usual, a Para LTC 1911 in an IWB holster. Over the course of about 3.5 hours I had ~5 drinks, 4 beers and a mixed drink to be exact. When we returned home, we talked with our friend who was watching our 17 month old son. After a few minutes of chit chat, and before our friend left, I engaged in what is my normal procedure, drop the mag, disengage the safety, rack the slide with the chambered round ending up in my hand and then drop the hammer (I know you can see it coming).

I make it a general practice to load/unload my gun before/after leaving the house. I do not feel the need to keep a loaded gun in the house, but I do like to have a gun on hand just in case. We live in a very secure gated community, but I recognize that anything can happen. That being said, I like the security of having a gun on hand when I am out and about. Likewise, I make it a practice to shoot all my ammo when I hit the range, so that I have no rounds possibly in my non-carry guns when I return home.

Anyway, I surmise that I disengaged the safety and racked the slide before dropping the mag, resulting in a live round being chambered when I dropped the hammer, despite there being a loaded round in my hand, resulting in the ND. After the round went off, I immediately dropped the mag, racked the slide and placed the gun in its normal storage spot without touching the trigger and checked to make sure that everyone was ok. Fortunately for all involved, including those not in the house, everyone was ok. After some investigating, the round ended up inside an air duct after passing through the drywall. It was at ~30 degree downward angle from my chest, entered an interior wall at about my mid thigh and would have ended up in the basement. There are no exit holes on the other side of the wall or in the basement. I pushed a rod through the hole and can see the rod where it entered the air duct and it looks like it didn’t leave. Unfortunately, I can not track down the bullet without braking down the HVAC to be 100% sure. I am yet to find the spent casing.

Aftermath:
My wife and son are safely asleep right now, which I am very thankful for. I do not know what I would have done if anything happened to one of them or any other innocent bystander for that matter. Bottom line, I feel completely terrible and sick to my stomach.


----------

- Mine was in combat - back at the fire-base. Very similar situation, identicle results - no one hurt, me with a load in my shorts!


----------


-When I was a kid on the farm, I was dry firing a .22 lever action in my room. Popped it off maybe 3-4 times, then started doing the "Rifleman" quick rack of the action.

About the 2nd or 3rd cycle, a live round jumped out. The round had hung up in the tube feed.


----------
- I once shot out a window with a .357 from the second story of my home, aiming an "unloaded" gun at a piece of paper on the ground on the prairie behind the house. Holy Crap! My ex-wife came running upstairs to see if I had shot myself on purpose, but I couldn't hear what she had to say for a little while. No substance abuse involved, just my normal brain cells at work.



----------
- I bought a filthy M1 Garand at an estate sale for a bargain price and spent hours cleaning it up. I got it clean, dry fired it, then wanted to see if it would chamber a round. It slam-fired when I released the operating rod. My bad.

The bullet (ball ammo) went through a wall, a hardwood floor, subfloor, and floor joist, then put a divot in the concrete basement wall. I'm not sure if my hearing ever fully recovered.


----------
- last weekend my wife was shooting my M1 and the bolt closed instead of locking open and she pulled the trigger and it went off before she handed it back to me Luckily it was up in the air


----------

Only had one, a long time ago. Chambered a round in a Luger in my apartment, and it went off! Round entered the floor, where it did no damage. Finger was off the trigger. Turned out the pistol had a bad sear.


----------

- I heard of this sort of thing happening at a firearms retailer near me. Someone went into this store with his rifle and a round in the pipe from deer hunting the previous year. The man had the rifle on the counter and intended to dry fire, but BANG!!!. No one was hurt.


----------
- I have never had an accidental or negligent discharge in the home but I have been at the range where I squeezed the trigger expected the gun to be empty only to have it discharge. Scared the bejezzus out of me.


----------
- I've had one AD at the range. I chambered a round in a Makarov and then removed the magazine to top it off. I laid the pistol down with it pointed down range, and then had to do something else for a minute, I forget what. When I picked the pistol back up, I pointed it at the target without a magazine inserted, forgetting that the Makarov doesn't have a magazine safety. I pulled the trigger and then cussed for a full minute. Luckily I was observing the safety rules. At least I hit the carboard target holder.


----------
- I pretty much dropped a pistol once, and like an idiot I caught it. BANG!


----------
- Yup. Lowering the hammer on my .357 revolver and didnt ride it down slow enough. Hit the primer with enough force to set it off. Had .38+P loaded in it at the time. Round went thru the wall and into the kitchen cabinet where it stopped.


----------
- Thirty-some years ago, my wife was loading her Colt Huntsman. It was all she had and was her home defense piece. She loaded the magazine and chambered a round. Well, we had this ritual of pointing the gun downward in a certain spot that was an outside, brick wall. Well...

BANG!


----------
- when i was 18 i went with my uncle to an indoor firing range and shot his custom 1911 until about 3 in the morning. at about 2:55am I was holding the gun, kinda sleepy, not really totally focused, when i suddenly got REALLY sleepy and my gun hand drooped to the point where i damn near dropped the gun. being very sleepy i pulled my hand back up and my finger unconsiously got inside the guard, touched off the extremely light competition pull trigger, and send a .45 acp into the ceiling.

----------
- I had a "stupid" discharge once. I was in a local IPSC club years ago, and the "hot" thing to do was modify magazines to hold 8 rounds. (1911 Colt) I came home from the range, dropped the magazine, stripped off 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8. That's a full load. Pointed the gun at the bookcase and dropped the hammer. BOOM! Forgot the one up the pipe. No damage except to the bookcase, the tops of several books and the frame around the sliding glass door.

----------
- Thumb slipped lowering the hammer on my superblackhawk.
Muzzle was pointed downrange at the time. No harm done. Just a wakeup call.


----------
- Many years ago at the range I loaded a magazine into a Jennings 22 cal, retracted the slide and let it fly forward. The firing pin was jammed through the firing pin hole with some debries. The pistol went full auto and emptied the magazine.
After the incident, the rangemaster came over and he figured out what had happened. He said he had seen this happen before.
All it takes is a little speck of brass in the firing pin hole.


----------
- Two. Both with long guns.

First one occurred when I was 14 with a Win. M-94. I was deer hunting by myself and had climbed half way up a mountain and had stopped to rest. I placed the butt of the rifle on my thigh while holding it by the wrist of the stock. I had a round chambered and started playing with the hammer and trigger, cocking the hammer and then easing it down while looking around. At some point my thumb slipped off the hammer spur firing the rifle. Fortunately, the area I was in was remote enough that the bullet wasn't likely to hit anyone or anything on re-entry, but it still scared the bejeezus out of me. I wonder "what if" for quite a long time.

The second occured when I was about 21, with a Stevens 5100 SxS. Me and some buds were hunting jacks out in the desert and I had just shot one and was reloading. The gun then fired as I closed it. I found out later Stevens recalled the 5100 for firing when bumped or when closing the breech. Fortunately the barrels were pointed to the ground when it discharged.

----------

- I had one at the range many years ago when my Uzi model A was still pretty new. I was shooting some lead reloads using a "brass catcher" and had a stove pipe jam. As I removed the empty the bolt slipped stripping a round from the mag and firing same as the open bolt SMG was designed to do (hey, I thought the ATF required mods was supposed to prevent this!). Gun pointed safely down range at the time but it sure scared me and burned into my head to always remove the magazine as the first step of clearing any malfunction!


----------

- I had a .22 rimfire semi-auto Iver Johnson pistol years ago that was built like a Walther. One night I loaded a magazine into the weapon, chambered a round and put the decock safety on. The hammer went down, as always, but this time there was a loud BANG. Fortunately I had the muzzle pointed at the floor and only injured some carpet. Finger was NOT on the trigger. Unloaded it, put it into the gun safe and never loaded it again.


----------
- I had a chinese broomhandle mauser clone go full auto on me once. It litterally squirted 20 rounds downrange so quick it was just plain amazing. I did it twice just to see. I then tried it with only 5 rounds and it still did it. I finally took it back.


----------
 
and these ones...


================================================



- Was handling an unloaded Browning Hi-Power in 1974 while drunk when it fired, putting a hole through the ceiling of my friend's apartment. Fortunately he lived on the top floor.


----------
- Lessee....one slamfire with a CZ52. #$&* who handed it to me knew it was prone to that but didn't tell me. Luckily it was pointed downrange

----------
- Mine was on a day that I was having a migraine. I sought the more comfortable, dimmer light and quiet of my bedroom in the basement. I grabbed my FEG Hi Power to dry-fire to relax. I dry-fired for a long while, decided that I was done, and reloaded it for the evening.

The phone rang, and I went upstairs to answer it.

I came back downstairs, thought, "what was I doing? Oh yeah, I was dry firing." Sat back down, took aim again and sqeezed the trigger. Didn't even hear the report, just saw the ball of flame at the muzzle and the hole in the closet door, and I knew that I was a massive idiot.


----------
- I have been present when it happened twice. Both witht the same type pistol. Walther P22 (POS), the safety will drop slightly while firing and cause the gun not to fire and will not extract the last round. Twice the slide has locked back as if empty, the safety being engaged prevented he live cartridge from firing and then someone pulls the trigger BANG!


----------
- I had one a while back at the range. I had been shooting my SKS trying to get a feel for it's accuracy or lack there of. I loaded the mag up of 10 rds with a stripper clip. Sat down at the bench. Put the stock against my shoulder and then proceeded to release the bolt. Upon releasing the bolt, the entire mag emptied out in a few seconds. So I guess you could say it was 10 A.D.'s in a row!

The firing pin had stuck and it was slam firing.

My slamfire on my SKS was one that was due to alot of rounds being shot through the weapon. It was pretty clean at the time, but the firing pin had become worn so much it was wedged in a forward position. Enough so tha it would discharge a round. The firing pin in the SKS is free floating all the time, but mine was not! I have since replaced it with a spring assisted pin to save the danger and embarressment.


----------

- I've got a good one it wasn't me though, my dad and his friend got back to their hotel room after hunting once. Well his friend is unloading his .300 win mag in the room, and holding the trigger down while working the bolt. To keep the fireing pin from cocking I guess anyways it went off. The round bounced off the cinderblock walls and out through the ceiling luckily aparently no one else was in the hotel.



----------
- I've never had an ND but i did have to shoot a mattress that was attacking me. One 148 gr swc .38 dropped that sucker on the spot. I thought it was pretty good shooting for a ten yo. Dad wasn't impressed one bit. It was his mattress.



----------

- Uh, I need a catagory for "Breath-taking Stupidity"...I lieu of that, I will select "decocking accident". Cuz it was sort of a decocking accident...sort of...

----------
- Mine happened because of a failure to understand the mechanics of the firearm.

It was an old Winchester gallery gun in .22 WRF. It's a tube-magazine-fed pump action with an exposed hammer. I had come inside from shooting and was unloading the gun. From prior experience playing with it unloaded I realized that I could hold the trigger down and pump the gun. The hammer would follow the bolt down as the pump closed.

I thought I could do this safely to unload the gun, since the hammer just slowly followed down. I did not think there was enough force to fire a round. I had even done it without incident before when unloading for real. This time, however, the gun fired on about the second or third pump. Thankfully, I had it pointed in a safe direction. It put a small hole through the exterior wall of the house. Nobody was home, so I just patched and painted the hole. To this day, not one person in my family knows of this incident


----------
- I have only had one AD, it was on a back up pistol when I was loading it, the safety was on, I inserted the magazine and jacked one into the chamber, for some unknown reason the safety flipped off and it discharged, I tried repeatedly to duplicate it but never was able to. The gun was unsafe and from then on that backup pistol has gathered dust in the safe.

----------
- I might tell about a Highway Patrol trooper that I knew, he shot his testicles off with a 45 acp.

The officer involved was a very experienced shooter, known for giving shooting demonstrations and for fast draw demos, he was always extremely cautious when doing a show. He was at a local police department pistol range practicing his shooting with a 1911, for some reason he wasn't thinking, he put his cocked and loaded 1911 on half cock, and shoved it in his belt in front, the pistol discharged, he got that ball of flame in the lower abdomen, shot his testicles off along with a lot of other serious injury, he got back in his patrol car, radioed to the dispatcher that he had been accidentally shot and was driving himself to the hospital, he drove to the hospital, walked into the Emergency Room, laid down on a gurney, they took him to surgery and he was in intensive care for a couple of weeks, but he did live and was able to return to duty.

He doesn't understand why he did what he did, he knew that half cock wasn't safe and the 1911 can fire if the hammer slips off of half cock, that was a pretty high cost for a moments lapse of common firearm safety rules. He has been dead for a number of years now, I know I won't ever forget that story.



----------

- When I was about 10 or 11 though, I did. I was intensely interested in how my Dad's lever action Marlin .22 fed a round from the tube magazine into the chamber. So in order to observe it, I covertly obtained a round, and began dropping it down the tube, and loading it into the chamber; and subsequently ejecting it.
After a few permutations of this, it was chambered and somehow I accidentally pulled or snagged the trigger. It shot into the floor, thankfully no one was downstairs at the time, but subsequent probing showed it failed to penetrate the floor, stopped by a joist perhaps.
My parents thought I had popped a balloon; but I fudged on the truth a little and said I didn't know it was loaded. I received a lecture on the 4 rules, checking the chamber, etc.. But I was scared enough by the incident to be much more responsible with guns from that time on.

----------

- Slamfire due to broken spring that holds firing pin to the rear on a Mark II. It was at a range and the gun was pointing downrange when I dropped the bolt.

----------
- "unintentional double-tap" -- happened twice, same day, two different Glocks. I was trying to practice the subtle trigger reset thing, and as the day wore on I started to get recoil flinch which caused the second shot to fire as the gun rose from the recoil of the first round (using a G36 and a G32). I was at an indoor range, both unintentional shots went into the ceiling. Luckily the ceiling is designed to catch bullets -- made obvious by the hundreds of holes in the soft sound baffling and no rain getting in.



----------
- My Dad owned a Marlin Model 39A lever action .22, and that's what I learned to shoot with. I have it in my safe now. We lived near a river, and we'd sometimes take walks through the woods that lined the river bank, shooting at tin cans and an occasional rabbit. He'd let me carry the rifle, with muzzle always pointed at the ground. I was probably about 11 or 12, and we were out one day for an afternoon of target practice. I spied a can I wanted to plink, and as I brought the rifle up out of the fold of my arm and started to swing it up to firing position, I recklessly let the muzzle cross my Dad. Instead of waiting until I had lifted the gun, I had also started to pull the hammer back to cock it, as I knew that there was a round in the chamber. My Dad's back was turned to me, and just as the muzzle cleared my Dad by about a foot, my thumb slipped off the hammer, and the rifle fired. I immediately began to bawl like a baby, thinking about what might've happened if the gun had fired a moment sooner, and I was shaken for a long time because of that incident. Dad was cool about it, and he used it to reinforce the gun safety message. I'm 52 now, and to this day, I've never had another AD.

----------
Exact same rifle (Marlin Model 39A lever action .22) I had an ND with when I was learning to shoot with Grandpa. We were shooting prairie dogs (and feeling cocky, cause that little Marlin could shoot! )and at the end of the day, Grandpa hollers and says, "let's go to the house." I tried to lower the hammer slowly on a loaded chamber, and BANG! At least I had it pointed down in front of me. Scared the bejesus outta me!


----------

- Sort of a cleaning accident while disassembling something. That's all I'm sayin and stickin to it.



----------
- My only AD happened in 1998 at my house. I was in the bedroom closet, the wife in the kitchen on the phone with her brother and my girls were in another bedroom on the other side of the house.

The weapon was a S&W 686 loaded with Remington Gold Saber .38 special +P ammo. For some stupid reason (still dont know why) I locked the hammer back. As I let the hammer down with the thumb I didnt ride it down with enough strength and the hammer struck the primer and "BANG".

The wife was screaming to see if I was alright. I was sitting on the bed with a look of disbelief, ears ringing and eyes watering from the blow by. Wifey thought I'd shot myself and was afraid to come into the room for fear of finding a bloody mess.


----------
- I was checking out a revolver with live ammo (MISTAKE!) and forgot that the Colt cylinder turns the opposite from a S&W cylinder. No harm except a hole in the shop drywall and a couple of hours of saying "Huh?" a lot.


----------
- I closed the bolt and brushed my finger against the trigger while putting it in the trigger guard and I released the striker. Fortunatly it wansn't loaded.

----------
- I had to vote gun went off broken defective part.Of course it was a 1911 and it was the first time I'd ever stripped one.I thought I put it all back together right.This is when I learned to funtion test a firearm first empty,and then with only one round and so on.Thank god I was still smart enough to have it pointed in a safe direction.
Oh,some how I got the main spring in wrong and the sear wouldn't engauge the notches in the hammer.


----------
- i guess i have... no had.... this ability to shut off my brain..

i just picked up the gun, aimed it at a point on the wall, flipped off the safety, and pulled the trigger....

i'll never un-holster a loaded weapon in the house again... at least not for S&G's... the sound that a .40s&w makes out of a 3 inch barrel in a small confined space, will make a person remember that event forever...


----------
- I was 14 years old, home alone, decided to get Dads 9mm Llama out. I knew this gun, had shot it and could field strip it. Dropped the mag, racked the slide and let it go home. Unloaded now, right?

Pointed it at the far wall of the living room and pulled the trigger. KABOOM!

When I opened my eyes there was a hole in the living room wall about 9mm in diameter. Turned on the light in my parents bedroom I could hardly see for the plaster dust. There was another larger hole in the wall there, about an inch above the dresser mirror. There was a gash in the ceiling about a foot long and another large hole in the opposite wall. Outside the house a chunk of slate siding the size of a baseball was missing. Don't let anyone tell you 9mm ball ammo lacks penetration!
I tried to make up a good lie to tell the parents when they got home but settled on the truth.

What I failed to do was physically check the chamber. The gun had always been a jam-o-matic, a round stuck in the chamber and a weak extractor left it there.

Besides learning how to patch plaster I learned to always, always check the chamber before assuming a gun is unloaded.


----------
- For those who say "Won't happen" let me tell this tale;
I have this uncle who will turn 70 this month. He's been shooting, reloading & bullet casting for over 50 years, never had a ND.

Until a few weeks ago that is. He had returned from a hunting trip and put off cleaning his rifle for a couple of days. Decided he better get it done, placed the gun in a cleaning cradle touched the trigger and sent a 7mm STW round into the basement wall about three feet away.

I was at his house the next day when he told me about it. He couldn't believe he left the gun loaded in the first place. Couldn't believe he didn't check the chamber in the second. 50 years of good habits and following the rules and it still caught up with him.

I couldn't believe it had happened to him! Ask him when he did it, he said "Yesterday, still can't hear worth a damn. Oh, yeah, your Aunt doesn't know anything about it and she don't need to either".

----------

- I was out trap shooting with my Uncle's 12ga Stevens bolt action (don't laugh, he left it to me and I can regulary put down 23 out of 25 with it). I pulled the trigger forgetting to take off the safety, pointing down range, I pushed the safety forward and BOOM! Took it into the gunsmith, hasn't been a problem since....



----------
- I had just finished cleaning my CZ50 when a realtive walked in and asked to see it. I new it to be safe so I handed to to them and went on about taking apart my Firestar. When he handed it back the hammer was cocked. Instead of letting it down, like I always do, I (still seeing it as safe in my mind) pointed it away and pulled the trigger.....BAMM! Thankfully I only eneded up with a hole in the garge wall and a small spot in the yard.
Never again will I ASSume anything with my weapons.



----------

- I was taking a breather while deer hunting when I was about 14-15. I had stopped about half way up a hill I was climbing. While resting, I put my foot on a log and was resting the butt of my .30-30 on my thigh muzzle up. While looking around I started playing with the hammer and trigger cocking an decocking the hammer. On about the third or fourth repetition the woods above the Back Fork of the Elk River echoed from the sound of a Winchester. I imagine my face was momentarily frozen with an astonishingly stupid look on it.


----------
- Double tap on a Garand at a local match. It was not slam fire, since the primer had a normal indentation. I was not sure what caused it.



----------


- My double was also with a Garand.

The gun was inspected and no flaws were found. I attributed it to my technique. I was benchresting the gun and firing with a very gradual trigger pull. I think I just managed to bump-fire a second round. The second round did not hit paper.

----------

- It was a decocking accident. I was about 11 or 12 and was squirrel hunting with my father. I had the gun cocked, didn't get the shot I wanted, so I had to let the hammer down (no manual safety on it BTW) and I just let the hammer slip out from under my thumb. Of course my father had already been drilling the gun handling safety rules into my head for years at that point, so he was behind me and the rifle was pointed at the ground. The round struck the dirt about 4ft in front of me, and of course I got a good lecture about seeing exactly why it's important to keep a gun pointed in a safe direction at all times.

In hindsight, seeing as I had done the correct thing by having the rifle pointed safely at the ground and no one was hurt, it was probably the best thing that could have happened to me, as it showed me just how important keeping the gun pointed in a safe direction is.

----------
- I was outside cleaning a Kahr and a Glock. Those of you familiar with these firearms know that you have to drop the hammer to remove the slide. So I do the normal....lock the slide back, confirm no round in the chamber, slide forward, hammer down, remove slide. Clean the Glock, reassemble, rack the slide a few times and hammer down put on the table.
Unless I'm carrying it or shooting it I leave guns unloaded. There was no mag in the Kahr so I rack the slide look in the chamber, slide forward hammer down BOOM!! Guess I didn't look close enough.
Don't know why the round wasn't ejected when I racked the slide, but the fact remains that I didn't look close enough
If it wasn't for myhabit of not pointing muzzles at anything Idon't want a hole in, who knows where it would've gone. This one left quite a gouge in the top of a heavy table and off into the wilderness......not far, since I was pointing down about 45 degrees.


----------
- First round I ever shot was almost into my left foot... I was 8 (?) or so and shootign with my father behind my grandparent's house out in the sticks. I'd held the rifle up , shook too much to hit anything, and relaxed into a muzzle down position. .22LR went "thunk" in the mud about a foot from my shoe.

Chalk 1 up for finger accidentally in trigger guard. The rifle's meager weight was enough to shift it in my grip and depress the trigger against my finger.


----------
- I lost a great uncle years ago. He had duck hunted a few days earlier and had put the single barrel 12 ga. behid the seat of the truck. He had failed to unload the gun before putting it there. To take the gun out he reached behind the seat, grabbed the barrel and pulled it toward him.

Evidently the hammer snagged on a seat spring or cloth and snapped back.

----------
- After watching the "Saturday Afternoon Western Block" shows on the TeeVee, I tried the fake 'hand it over, butt first, with finger inside the trigger guard, then quickly twirl it up and snap-fire a round' to pop one into the Bad Guy.

Forgot I had the .357 Blackhawk loaded with CCI 'Rat shot'

A LARGE can of spackle, a gallon of antique white paint, and a trip to the glass shop fixed the mess

----------
- I had to vote gun went off.
I was DRUNK at the time. Missed my foot
----------
 
Yet another vote for the existing 4 rules.

Any one of them, if broken, won't result in an injury; the other 3 will save your bacon ("dry" firing a loaded weapon will only result in offing a mattress or concrete wall). It's only when you go breaking 2+ rules that you shoot yourself or somebody else.

The rules understand that you aren't perfect, and neither is your gun. If you worry about the mechanical condition of your gun, then have a good gunsmith give it a look over.

Your rules make me think that, if applied to automobiles, we would only drive at 20mph because our brakes just might possibly fail.
 
Proof the 4 Rules work.

Two good thing about this thread.....

1) Puts many N/Ds and a few A/Ds (mechanical issue) in one thread for review.

2) Proves the 4 rules work. Either one failed to hold true to 1 or more of the
rules or by holding true to some of the 4 rules greater damage was avoided.

Since you referenced my post I'll restate my greatest error.

Mistake #4., My finger was not held out of the trigger guard.

Had I upheld this rule all other errors would be moot but since I kept Rule # 2
no injury or over costly destruction ensued.

Keep the 4 rules true and they keep you safe and alive.

Mods.... can this be a sticky for N/D A/D review?
 
Yep, people who break two or more of the existing rules end up shooting things they shouldn't. Sometimes tragically.

Incidentally, you can and should follow the Four Rules while dryfiring. See this page for more about that.

pax
 
So, karhu, what is your point?

Reality is tough, we don't live in nerf world.

Thousands of traffic rules and laws, yet 50,000 Americans are killed each year in car crashes, and many tens of thousands of others are seriously hurt. Children drown in swimming pools and five-gallon buckets. Lightning falls from the sky and kills people every year. People fall off of ladders, dismember themselves with power tools, and cut themselves with knives.

Firearms are tools, and need to be respected. Accidents happen, but we don't need any more rules. We need, as in all things, a healthy respect and responsible handling.
 
The 4 rules are fine as they are.

People just insist on breaking them.

People have a habit of ignoring or breaking safety rules.

People also insist on driving faster than the speed limit,
driving drunk,
driving without wearing a seatbelt,
driving while distracted by adjusting the radio or using a cell phone,
driving while tired,
driving with mechanically flawed or broken vehicles,
driving on icy roads,
driving across bridges that are covered by flood waters.

Do we also need a whole new set of vehicle safety rules?

Don't even get me started on how people ignore chainsaw safety rules......


hillbilly
 
4 URFS

Karhu,
This not a perfect world, there are no free lunchs and there are no guarantees that you are going to get through this world alive...!!! These 4 Rules are just fine in their present form. ND's occur , and will continue to occur, because people get careless, distracted and/or otherwise abuse the Rules. It is a situation similar to our anti-gun friends.....they blame the gun for the shooting rather than examine the shooter. Stop blaming the Rules and look at the ND perpetrator. He was the negligent party. Don't fall for this fatalistic mindset that says that if you are around guns long enough, you will have "your" ND....!! Just stay focused and vigilant to your every action with your weapon...do not get distracted and forgetful as to your responsibility with that weapon..... While you are working on or handling your weapon...CHAMBER CHECK it a half a dozen times to reassure yourself that you indeed have an empty weapon.......
 
I was wondering if we should come to the conclusion that guns are inherently dangerous
Well DUH!!! If they weren't they'd be pretty useless.
And for a long time we have known that they aren't nearly as dangerous as automobiles, drunk drivers, or for that matter, baseball bats in the hands of children. Since some years they've caused more fatal accidents for kids then guns did.
But since you might be living in the USA you have a perfect right not to buy one. And perhaps it might be a good idea if you didn't drive either?
 
All you've demonstrated is that people break the 4 rules. :banghead: You have yet to show us how adding more rules is any safer. You seem to assume that your rules will be followed... but they won't be. The 4 rules are all you need, if you follow them. If you aren't going to follow them, how does adding more rules help?
Anyone can come up with a laundry list of rules to cover every circumstance they can imagine. Distilling out the essentials into 4 simple rules is genius.
I don't know if karhu is overly cautious, or an infra-bridge denizen, but either way, I'm done feeding him.
 
This is my last post on this topic.

For every instance of "bullet through the wall from the neighbor", I can share 50 "car through the wall on the nightly news" events. Heck, we just had a police officer crash through a fence and kill an elderly woman sitting at a picnic table here in Albuquerque. Maybe we can come up with 20 more rules on how police officers should drive in order to keep this from happening again (not).

Just what makes you think that another "rule" would keep some idiot from pointing a loaded gun at a mirror in an apratment complex and shooting through the wall?
 
Kahru,

That last post of yours was interesting, but only as a lesson of what happens when you start breaking the four rules. That guy pointed a weapon in an unsafe direction and pulled the trigger. Do you really think that you could have made him any less of an idiot by teaching him *your* version of the rules?

Remember, Ignorance can be cured, but stupid is forever. Some people simply refuse to learn.
 
Jeff Cooper's Take on The 4 Rules

Jeff Cooper's Rules Of Gun Safety

[...] I have lived a long and active life, and I am still alive because I have always been very, very careful.

RULE I: ALL GUNS ARE ALWAYS LOADED

There are no exceptions. Do not pretend that this is true. Some people and organizations take this rule and weaken it; e.g. "Treat all guns as if they were loaded." Unfortunately, the "as if" compromises the directness of the statement by implying that they are unloaded, but we will treat them as though they are loaded. No good! Safety rules must be worded forcefully so that they are never treated lightly or reduced to partial compliance.

All guns are always loaded - period!

This must be your mind-set. If someone hands you a firearm and says, "Don't worry, it's not loaded," you do not dare believe him. You need not be impolite, but check it yourself. Remember, there are no accidents, only negligent acts. Check it. Do not let yourself fall prey to a situation where you might feel compelled to squeal, "I didn't know it was loaded!"

RULE II: NEVER LET THE MUZZLE COVER ANYTHING YOU ARE NOT WILLING TO DESTROY

Conspicuously and continuously violated, especially with pistols, Rule II applies whether you are involved in range practice, daily carry, or examination. If the weapon is assembled and in someone's hands, it is capable of being discharged. A firearm holstered properly, lying on a table, or placed in a scabbard is of no danger to anyone. Only when handled is there a need for concern. This rule applies to fighting as well as to daily handling. If you are not willing to take a human life, do not cover a person with the muzzle. This rule also applies to your own person. Do not allow the muzzle to cover your extremities, e.g. using both hands to reholster the pistol. This practice is unsound, both procedurally and tactically. You may need a free hand for something important. Proper holster design should provide for one-handed holstering, so avoid holsters which collapse after withdrawing the pistol. (Note: It is dangerous to push the muzzle against the inside edge of the holster nearest the body to "open" it since this results in your pointing the pistol at your midsection.) Dry-practice in the home is a worthwhile habit and it will result in more deeply programmed reflexes. Most of the reflexes involved in the Modern Technique do not require that a shot be fired. Particular procedures for dry-firing in the home will be covered later. Let it suffice for now that you do not dry-fire using a "target" that you wish not to see destroyed. (Recall RULE I as well.)


Rule III: KEEP YOUR FINGER OFF THE TRIGGER UNTIL YOUR SIGHTS ARE ON THE TARGET

Rule III is violated most anytime the uneducated person handles a firearm. Whether on TV, in the theaters, or at the range, people seem fascinated with having their finger on the trigger. Never stand or walk around with your finger on the trigger. It is unprofessional, dangerous, and, perhaps most damaging to the psyche, it is klutzy looking. Never fire a shot unless the sights are superimposed on the target and you have made a conscious decision to fire. Firing an unaligned pistol in a fight gains nothing. If you believe that the defensive pistol is only an intimidation tool - not something to be used - carry blanks, or better yet, reevaluate having one around. If you are going to launch a projectile, it had best be directed purposely. Danger abounds if you allow your finger to dawdle inside the trigger guard. As soon as the sights leave the target, the trigger-finger leaves the trigger and straightens alongside the frame. Since the hand normally prefers to work as a unit - as in grasping - separating the function of the trigger-finger from the rest of the hand takes effort. The five-finger grasp is a deeply programmed reflex. Under sufficient stress, and with the finger already placed on the trigger, an unexpected movement, misstep or surprise could result in a negligent discharge. Speed cannot be gained from such a premature placement of the trigger-finger. Bringing the sights to bear on the target, whether from the holster or the Guard Position, takes more time than that required for moving the trigger finger an inch or so to the trigger.


RULE IV: BE SURE OF YOUR TARGET

Know what it is, what is in line with it, and what is behind it. Never shoot at anything you have not positively identified. Be aware of your surroundings, whether on the range or in a fight. Do not assume anything. Know what you are doing.

SUMMARY:

Make these rules a part of your character. Never compromise them. Improper gunhandling results from ignorance and improper role modeling, such as handling your gun like your favorite actor does. Education can cure this. You can make a difference by following these gunhandling rules and insisting that those around you do the same. Set the example. Who knows what tragedies you, or someone you influence, may prevent?
--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Excerpted from: The Modern Technique of the Pistol, by Greg Morrison, Gunsite Press, Paulden, Arizona, ISBN 0-9621342-3-6, Library of Congress Number 91-72644

This is really all there is to it. Nothing more needs to be said. Either a man gets it or he doesn't. If he doesn't get it, I hope nobody dies when he learns the hard way. Eventually, he will learn the hard way if he continues to handle guns while ignoring the four rules. The four rules are fail safe simply because you must violate more than one to create a tragedy. Many people violate one of the rules at some point, even frequently. The other three rules save them.

Learn the rules and follow them. You don't have to be a 4 Rule nazi screaming and crying anytime somebody sweeps you with a gun, but if you incorporate them into your own behavior, you will have a long, safe life handling firearms. Either you get it or you don't.
 
I'm new here and I like this forum a lot. Now, that being said here's my 2 cents worth.

The "rule" of assume a gun is loaded is akin to "the rule" of assume a standard shift vehicle is in gear when cranking...crank with your foot on the clutch and break or it will lunge forward and hit something or someone.

These are all ways of saying use your noggin when handling a potentially dangerous weapon. Nothing is ever 100% certain.

When someone says to me that guns need to be outlawed because they are dangerous, I tell them if that is the case then so do cars, swimming(people are eaten by sharks or drowned), smoking, drinking, um what other millions of things people do everyday that can be a hazard to someone's health or life? Unfortunately there aren't a lot of people out there that own guns and have common sense to boot and it makes those of us that do own guns and have common sense look bad. I hope I didn't get too far off subject but it seems to me that it's right there in front of everyone's face and only responsible handgun owners can see it.
 
Hmmmm ok.....

I'm waiting for him to say "Do it for the children. Think of the children!"

I too think the 4 rules are fine. I mean, come on! Never dry fire?

But there is another thought. Perhaps the OP is making a joke or trying to be funny?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top