Best auto for CCW

Status
Not open for further replies.
Glock 19, M&P shield, commander size 1911. You have a lot of choices. Your best bet will be to come up with a list of requirements and see what fits. Also try renting a bunch of different guns at the range and see what you like. A good IWB holster will allow you to carry a slightly larger gun without sacrificing comfort. I carry a full size glock in one of my IWB hybrids every day.
CBFD8407_zps888ea087.jpg

And here is one for an LCP
BA162120_zps2bf22982.jpg
 
Last edited:
Depends on the wearer

If you are going to carry concealed, the first question is how will you conceal the weapon and the second question should be how big a gun you can conceal?
I am 5'8" and 210 pounds, so wearing a full size or even compact gun like GLOCK 19, SIG 225 or similar size gun is out of the question without a vest or jacket. Both SCREAM I HAVE A GUN.
If I were 6"2" and in good shape, then I would have a lot more options.

In Florida where I live, the largest gun I can conceal without wearing something that looks like I am concealing a gun under it, is either a J-frame revolver, S&W 36 or 38, CHARTER ARMS Undercover or TAURUS 85 or a PPK size semi-auto.
I prefer the additional rounds of the auto and carry a SIG 232 most of the time, but when I cannot, I go with the BERETTA Tomcat in .32ACP and accept the downgrade in power.

The micro 9m.m. pistols like the RUGER LC9 or KAHR CW9 are small enough, but the recoil is unpleasant to the point that I do not wish to shoot them.
If I do not want to shoot them, I will not get enough practice with what is a difficult to control weapon. Hence, the SIG 232, which shoot like a dream for me.

Interestingly, I recently shot a BROWNING 1955 (same as the BROWING 1910) and it was easy to shoot and control, hitting the target despite the "guttersnipe" sight. This is a grove in the top of the slide with a nearly invisible front sight, but it works at close range.
It is all steel, but weigh only 19 ounces, so it could be carried in a pocket.
It is noticably shorter and with less than height than the SIG 232.

It comes down to a trade off of how much you can conceal, whick will depend on fashion and situation and how much recoil you can accept.

Jim
 
Maddog, I agree with you 100%. But don't forget the 4513. I have a 3913 and a 4513. Both are outstanding. I have to say it. I feel they are better than the Sig P228 I just bought. Clearly in their more compact size but in shooting aspects as well. Even with the SRT on the Sig the trigger pull and reset on the 3rd gens beat it.
 
The Walther PPS was incredible to shoot and carries better than anything that can shoot tight groups at 25 yards.
 
I think you need two guns.

Glock 26 for when you can conceal it with appropriate summer clothing.

Kahr PM9 or CM9.

Or, perhaps go as low as a .380. I like the S&W Bodyguard .380.
 
A Glock 20 or 29, if not maybe a Kimber in 10mm or Colt Delta Elite if you want something thinner.
 
I currently carry a 357 mag.
Wanting something of comparable knock down power.
10mm/150 grain JHP. Mine clock at 1,400-1,450 fps with a max load of AA#9. 15+1 in my G20; 9+1 in my Smith 1006.
 
I now choose to carry only what I can action shoot best. That adds size and weight from the ultra compacts (e.g PM9). And, in 9mm I want capacity as the trade off. So, I find a way to make a 10+1 G30, 7+1 4" 1911 or 14+1 CZ 75c work.
 
I carry a kahr pm 45 it is small like a pm 9 yet it shoots the 45acp.It is also thinner than a glock or xd,weighs 18 oz.empty.I have carried it for 4 years and it has never failed to go bang.I think that the gun that works and is also comfortable to carry makes it more likekly to have it with you.Only minus is round count 5 in mag one in tube is not enough for some folks but i do carry a 7 round xtra mag.imho
 
I long ago settled on the Glock 26. Sometimes a larger gun, once in a great while a smaller gun (J-frame) but usually the 26.

2e9e3e92.gif
 
I have 4 small guns "size wise" small enough to pocket carry, or hide easy enough. My backup started as a seacamp in 32, to an lcp in 380 to an lc9 in 9mm, until I saw how poorlly the gun was made, this as I installed the calloway trigger, "short throw" trigger in mine. I literally could not believe what my life was hinging on.
The parts are "as most know" are all plastic inside. But the hammer spring and trigger bar setup is the poorest excuse for a firing system I ever saw, and the rear sight holds down the firing pin stop, so if this comes loose, "and it did", while shoting, you are out of business. the trigger spring is misaligned and not as thick as a thin paper clip.
All this rests with no secure part of any kind holding it against the bottom of the trigger bar.
It is an accident in the making. Even field stripping the gun, "which is simple, requires you to place a key"used to unlock the built in lock" in order to be pressed directlly against the trigger bar, Thus pulling it away fron the hammer spring. I "needles to say, traded mine back to the same dealer whom I purchased it from, and bought a shield in 40, this and my EMP, along with a Glock 30 and 26, now round out my 4 carry guns.
Being I always have 2, the shield will fit in nicelly, with the 26 riding in the number 2 position.
Unfortunatelly it takes time to get to know a gun, even renting one won't give you the same experience as having the use of it for a few months to really see how it fits your lifestyle.
As an old timer for many of the younger shooters, I would say stick with the well known better made guns. I have 4 decades of switching back and forth and have gone through more than my fair share of guns. The well established names are usually the ones you will keep.
I may be biased to Glock, but only because out of 6 that I have owned, I have never had a problem with one, the M&P, is a similar story. You don't want something that is just not made well when it comes to your life. No need to spend a thousand plus, "unless you choose to"But don't short change yourself, by saving a few bucks on something this important, So far every gadjet gun I bought fell short.
By that I mean too many do-dads, "more stuff to break". Lasers and lights are nice if you buy quality equiptment, but don't think you can get everything in 1 gun. And honestlly I have done a 180 on the 40 caliber, you get more bang for the buck, and now they are the same size in most models. If you have a choice, pick up the 40.
 
I have a Kahr CM9 and freaking love it. Frankly I think you will too if you are a revolver guy... due to the VERY nice DAO trigger.

There is also the CM40 if you want more oomph.

Next sizes up are the CW9 and CW40... they have +1 capacity(7 and 6 rounds respectively) over the CM9 and CM40(6 and 5 rounds). I originally wanted a CW9, but the dealer had a CM9 in stock, so I bought it along with an extended magazine, so I have a slightly shorter barrel and a grip size that can be changed depending on carry attire/situation.


My gun of choice is still my 1911 for home defense, but I do not feel under-equipped with my CM9 which will be carried everywhere possible/legal since it's considerably lighter and easier to conceal.
 
Based on prior experience with a Glock G27 and a G29, I am considering a G26 and a G29sf for future purchases. The .40 S&W, in Glocks, was just not my cup of tea, and the G29 was just too big for my hands, for which the short-frame Glocks should be a remedy. (I have short fingers and thumbs attached to my large hands.)

FWIW, in 2002, when I bought my G27, it was unable to displace my SP101 snubby. I sold the G27 and bought a second SP101, and started toting the two snubbies when I needed little guns, and carried my Glock G22 duty pistol when I felt like dressing around a large
pistol.
 
Have you tried the shield yet? If you were near me I would let you try mine, I think it fits right in that gap. Slimmer than the glocks 1" at the thickest point on the slide. And since it's a single stack, it slides just about anyware.
 
I have a cs45, nice guns, same weight as a glock 23, I like the shield because of the thickness it even carries better than my 26, and the 26 is really smaller except for width. that slim width makes such a difference. I am trading my EMP for an xds and some cash, that will round out my carry squad, 2,45's a 2,40s and 2 nines. All can be carried easily depending what you feel like.
Honestlly the EMP is the coolest of all, but it's so sweet, I am afraid of scratching it up.
Finally an ar and a shotgun round out everything I should ever need except a 22.
After all how many guns can I use unless I get into long range shooting in my retirment years.This becomes a mans version of shoes and handbags that our wifes do. They wear some once and save the special ones for those rare occasions that we tend to not want to go to anymore.
When my wife says why do you need all those guns, I tell her sam reason you need the shoes, I want them, and if someone breaks in, your shoes aren't going to do us much good.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top