TTv2
Member
- Joined
- Mar 31, 2016
- Messages
- 5,025
The thread for the 1862 Police barrel length got me to thinking about how barrel length with the NMA is more critical than the Colt percussion revolvers because the Colt's can have their barrels easily changed while the 58's... not so much.
I own both a 5.5 and an 8 inch Pietta 1858 and I have to say that the 8 inch doesn't feel much more heavy or cumbersome than the 5.5 does and it's certainly accurate. I haven't shot the 5.5 yet, but when I do, I'm planning to only use a conversion cylinder for it.
Planning to buy a 12 inch Buffalo model when I find a steel one for a good price, but I think they're too large for most people to shoot them.
I've seen snub nose versions that people have modified. I have to say those look great, but due to the frame size, they're still bulky and heavy.
Overall, I think the 8 inch is the best, which is the traditional length.
I own both a 5.5 and an 8 inch Pietta 1858 and I have to say that the 8 inch doesn't feel much more heavy or cumbersome than the 5.5 does and it's certainly accurate. I haven't shot the 5.5 yet, but when I do, I'm planning to only use a conversion cylinder for it.
Planning to buy a 12 inch Buffalo model when I find a steel one for a good price, but I think they're too large for most people to shoot them.
I've seen snub nose versions that people have modified. I have to say those look great, but due to the frame size, they're still bulky and heavy.
Overall, I think the 8 inch is the best, which is the traditional length.