That's the problem Daniel,
Many guys are brainwashed into thinking a fight without rules, on the street, is predictable, and that they are invincible.
Look I'm not knocking what you do. But consider for a moment what the vast majority of the martial arts community is doing. They are selling you their services to "train" you. They are getting money from you. Do you think most of them would risk threatening their main form of monetary income and tell you that you suck? No, they simply move you through the process of gaining the next belt color, which if you ask the reasonably honest artist he'll admit that belt means nothing.
So many of these dojos are simply processing people through a system that gives them a paper and pushes them out the door. That's all well and fine, but to many trainees this gives them a false sense of security. They think they're pretty tough now. This is like browsing the internet with an Anti-virus package installed, but is expired. Or an Anti-virus that only protects you against SOME threats. Yeah, you got it's Anti-virus, but it's not going to protect you very well, and even less so as more time passes.
Same thing with hand to hand skills. What if you come up against a guy with a knife, and he knows how to use it? AND you've never trained for this. I'll tell you this much, you won't know he's got the knife until he is on top of you. What if you are a grappler and go down to the ground? Now you got a guy who is armed, on the ground way too close to you for comfort. I'll give the armed guy the advantage.
Anyway, you don't fit the average. It sounds like for you it's a constant conditioning process. So you got that going for you. For most though it's not.
I myself used to train about 4 fours a day, nearly every day when I was younger. Nope, not anymore. I would be very apprehensive about getting into any kind of physical fight.
You know I would like to hear some of the details of your fight(s). I always like to play barca lounger quarterback.
Were you jumped? Were weapons involved? How many vs how many? Etc. If you don't care to talk about it I won't be upset either.
[Edit]: P.S. CSI? I guess a TV show? Sorry I haven't watched regular broadcast TV in over a half a decade now. I think the last show I followed was Cheers. TV is pretty hokey anymore...