Black powder fouling is not corrosive...

Status
Not open for further replies.
Wow lots of big words in that article. Looks like the writer did lots of research. So the bottom line..., clean your muzzleloader regardless of what type of propellent you use. I think that's what it said. :confused:

LD :D
 
Great article. It confirms what I have observed and suspected over the years. I live in NW Colorado where the air is very dry (low relative humidity, <30%). Ideally, I start the cleaning process at the range and finish when I get home. I can go for several weeks before cleaning a muzzle loader when I get distracted and forget to clean after a shooting session, with no apparent harm to the bore - no rust when I clean the barrel finally. When it's moist out, the rules change. I was shooting at the local range this Fall under the covered benches with my flintlock during a rain storm. I could actually see the moisture forming in the pan after each shot within 10 seconds after a shot, just from the moisture the dirty pan was absorbing from the air. I had to wipe the pan clean and dry between each shot. During dry hunting seasons, I can leave a charge in a muzzle loader for a week and still get it to fire the first time, flint or percussion. When its wet out, even with the muzzle taped and the vent/nipple plugged, the load can pick up enough moisture in a day to misfire. That includes both Pyrodex and black powder. So....., clean your black powder shooter soon after shooting, and put a fresh charge in daily when hunting to prevent missed oppurtunities. My 2 cents.
 
Black powder fouling is not corrosive, it's extremely hygroscopic. That is, it attracts and retains moisture. That moisture is then held in close proximity to surfaces on your gun that you would rather not have in close proximity to moisture.
Black Powder Fouling + Moist Environment = Moisture in your gun.
Moisture + your metal gun = :( .

If the environment is dry enough, there's not enough moisture to be attracted and retained by the black powder fouling.
Black Powder Fouling + Dry Environment = No moisture in your gun.
No Moisture + metal = :D .
 
If the scientific part is a little too much, skip to the conclusions at the end: Heavy shooting (meaning a hot gun, not necessarily powder volume or number of shots) produces tougher fouling. It's almost all water-soluble, so hot water and scrubbing will get it clean. "Dirty" powders come from "dirty" carbon. Higher purity results not in less fouling, but an easier cleanup. High relative humidity causes faster corrosion. It is the physical properties of the fouling which cause this, not the chemical properties like you'll find with corrosive milsurp primers.

And, of course, Clean Your Guns! Quickly! Unless you live in an arid environment (hot or cold), they'll rust fast.
 
corrosiveness and marketing

I gunsmithed and sold black powder firearms and supplies back in the 1970's to mid 1980's and convincing folks that their "Paradox" (yes I know it's spelled wrong) powder is corrosive...saw many damaged bores and confused looks.
 
Nowhere in the article cited was it stated that one need not/ should not clean a black powder firearm.

The article was an examination of the when and why of the corrosiveness of black powder residue.

I found it interesting. If you read it and think it advocated not cleaning your black powder firearm, you should read it again.


Steve
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top