Perhaps including those details in your original post would be helpful and would help avoid you from receiving unwanted suggestions.
Just a suggestion.
Although I think his reasoning is silly and based on a poor understanding of economics and globalization, he did clearly state that he had narrowed it down to the mini or the AR.
Others suggested a third option and what is likely a better choice for his inteded use. No harm there. He explained why that choice didn't interest him. No harm there either or need to get uptight on either side.
Go with the AR even if you need to save up a little longer. Considering the rifle will last longer than you it is worth a little extra $$$ upfront to get what is IMO a much better riffle.