Building a reliable AR

Status
Not open for further replies.

.Scarecrow.

Member
Joined
Dec 28, 2011
Messages
214
Location
West Michigan
I've decided like many many others that I want to build an AR. But I won't try if it's hard to make one reliable. I have quality parts picked out from Aero Precision and a Faxon Barrel. Not sure on the BCG yet but I think I might go for WMD NiB-X. Is there really any voodoo magic to making a rugged, reliable, and accurate AR besides having the correct tools, quality parts, and following instructions properly?
 
A quality AR is one that at least meets milspec requirements, so the first thing I would do is check and see who at least meets these requirements. Colt, Daniel Defense and BCM is where I'd start. Larue and Noveske are good places to look too depending on your budget.
 
There are a lot of manufactures out there with good reputations, right now it is pretty darn hard to beat BCM for the price. Stellar reputation and you can build a gun with one of their uppers without breaking the bank. As far as lowers, most any stripped lower will be fine and a DD LPK would definitely be high quality, I haven't had any issues with PSA LPK's either. Not saying the parts you picked out aren't fine but I have never really heard anything about the barrel or the BCG you picked out. It is a lot easier to go with a company that is tried and true.
 
Last edited:
scarecrow, i'm not saying they are or aren't, just asking how you would know?
 
As the others have said, buy good quality parts from a reputable manufacturer and stick to brand names
 
I just assembled my first AR upper. I used a JD machines upper/lower, Geisle SDM trigger, Black Hole Weaponry 18" stainless barrel. PSA mil spec bcg. My biggest concern was aligning the gas block. I knew after the first shot that I did OK. It cycled 80 rounds without a hick-up.
Unless you are buying unmarked gun show import crap you should be good. Stick with the major vendors and you should be OK.
 
I have heard some good things about Faxon barrels. I saw an IV8888 video where Eric poured 830 rounds through one on full auto without any breaks until it finally blew. I like that it is Nitride and 1/8 twist. I'm open to other options but I wanted more than just the standard chrome lined deal. Aero Precision stuff has great reviews on the sites that I've shopped on, and I hear they are what is used on Spike's rifles.

In terms of the WMD BCG, I like the idea of the whole Nickel Boron coating, I'll also be using a 5-coil extractor spring.
 
Buying a complete from a reputable company is good insurance that you're getting a reliable AR.

How much are you going to spend?
 
Well, not as much as you guys might think, I haven't mentioned that I don't need any furniture. I'm transferring accessories from another rifle to the new one. I will need a complete lower minus the stock and grip. I could probably just use my DD BCG, maybe put a Nickel Boron Bolt in. I want to research more on these new coatings for bolts and carriers to see if they really are what they say they are. For the rest of the upper, just a barrel and stripped upper. The upper I'm interested in is one that does not feature the forward assist. I know some will have an issue with that, but I get what guys say about it being a mil-spec holdover.
 
Reliability increase?

Some thoughts .....

1) Dont use crap ammo

2) Put an o ring under the extractor spring

3) keep the chamber clean

4) Keep the action well lubed

5) Clean when needed

6) keep your mags in good condition
 
I wouldn't pull a used bcg out of one rifle to put in another. I'm not sure if I understood you correctly but if that's what you are considering, don't.

Right now for the price I'd buy a BCM upper unless there was something real particular i was trying to accomplish through a build. They still have some great deals going. You will be getting a quality upper that should run reliable provided its lubed.
 
If I'm going to just buy a BCM upper, I might as well just buy another complete rifle. What drew me to doing my own were things like having a 1/8 twist, Melonite/Nitride instead of chrome lining, eliminating a forward assist. I want to see about finding quality products that feature these things unless these attributes cannot be found on quality products or if they hinder reliability.

Does anyone have opinions on Aero Precision and/or Faxon barrels, or similar barrels that have those features.

In terms of an argument favoring Chrome Lining, yes I know it works fine.
 
Just read up a little on Nitride, I guess I didn't know it wasn't better in every way compared to chrome. From what I read, Chrome does better with heat resistance, but I'm not sure if I'd do anything to hurt a Nitride barrel.
 
Built my AR on an aero precision upper and lower, got my BCG from Rainier Arms. Barrel is criterion, chrome lined then hand-lapped before it ships. Using only irons, I've put 5 rounds of pmc Xtac on a playing card, and 14rds in the 10-ring of an 8 inch target at 50 yards. Pretty sure it'll do better than that with a scope on it; I'll know soon.

It's not much of a boast compared to some endurance tests I've read, but I've put around 800 rounds of mil spec ammo through it since I built it, half of it without cleaning or lubing, and the only hiccup I've seen was an FTF due to a bad round stopping a mag from feeding. Seems accurate and reliable enough for my needs.
 
Aero Precision is good, never heard of Faxon and there is better than WMD. For the barrel I would do a lot more homework on BCM, Centurion, FN, Wilson, Rainier, etc. The barrel is too important. Regarding the BCG: PSA premium, BCM, CMT, etc. A good milspec BCG is all you need. Edit: also don't skimp on a trigger.
 
Last edited:
I have heard some good things about Faxon barrels. I saw an IV8888 video where Eric poured 830 rounds through one on full auto without any breaks until it finally blew. I like that it is Nitride and 1/8 twist. I'm open to other options but I wanted more than just the standard chrome lined deal. Aero Precision stuff has great reviews on the sites that I've shopped on, and I hear they are what is used on Spike's rifles.

In terms of the WMD BCG, I like the idea of the whole Nickel Boron coating, I'll also be using a 5-coil extractor spring.
I just watched that video last night.

Aero Precision is a quality lower. I built my pistol with Aero Precision stripped receivers.

Elsewhere on the forum someone listed all of the manufacturers of AR receivers, the list was surprisingly small compared to the number of roll marks that may be applied to them.

While not all receivers are created equal, as long as you don't go with polymer lowers, you should be fine. Stick with 7076 aluminum forged lowers.

What is more critical as far as quality are the guts. Not all springs are created equal. Trigger, hammer and disconnect springs may not be wound to the proper tolerances, causing all sorts of issues from heavy trigger pull to light primer strikes. Get a good quality bolt. It's easy to shortcut bolts. I've got one where the gas key looks like it was staked by a billy goat. It'd be better had they not bothered to stake it at all, but instead they did it half arsed.

My suggestion, build one just to get familiar with how to build one. Don't worry so much on the budget, unless you plan on this being your only rifle. Since that is virtually impossible, and you will want to build more, other variations in the future, start with blemished receivers and standard parts kits from PSA. Go from there. once you gain some confidence and understand what pitfalls to avoid, which parts to stock up on because they will get lost during assembly, and what special tools you thought you didn't need but really do, then start your next build.
 
I find it easier for many things to get all of the parts from one source. I have built more than a few rifles from model1sales "kits" that include everything except the lower and all have worked well.

Not the lowest buck route but not the most expensive either and it's a one stop shop and if I ever did have a problem there is only one number to call for any of the parts in the rifle (excluding the lower).
 
aligning the gas tube/gas block is a little voodooish IMHO. No problem if has a milspec sight tower but clamp on type gas blocks I still don't see how to get the hole in the barrel absolutely square over the gas block hole and have found variance in the gas tube pin length dimensions too. I build good ARs but that issue and the final torque with gas tube alignment into the upper seem kinda vague to this old engine builder.
 
Thanks for the information guys. You all seem to be in favor of a standard BCG, do you have any opinions on various so-called advanced coatings for bolts?
 
if it's really reliability you want, stick with the standard stuff and a company like bravoco or colt.

if this is hobby/educational, build your own.

for reliability, the most important parts are the barrel and bolt assembly. don't cut corners there. beyond that it's mostly how well you can screw things together so they don't come apart.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top