I'm in the "always one up the pipe" camp, BUT:
Read what pbman (who carries chamber empty) said:
I'm still beter off than 99% of the people.
Now, I agree that
quality handguns can safely be carried with a round in the chamber. THAT SAID, I will suggest that
as many as half of the above posters left their homes today, UNARMED. "Yeah, but when I carry, I carry
tactically!" Um, so?
pbman's point stands: better to carry in ANY fashion --even if it's not the fastest-- than not to carry at all. Many were trained in the military NEVER to chamber until immediately prior to firing. They have been so indoctrinated, that they feel uncomfortable carrying in Condition One. Okay, so they carry in Condition Three-- AT LEAST THEY'RE CARRYING!!!!
Many, many times, I've found myself having to go out on a sultry Texas summer evening, wearing a polo shirt and slacks or jeans. One of the few viable answers to my "always carry" rule is to put on an ankle holster, and shove a M-37 Airweight or KelTec P11 into it. If my trousers have no flair (which they rarely do, as I have not succumbed to the '70's retro fashion trend, and I can't seem to find affordable boots in my outlandish shoe size), it takes a little struggle to get the cuff of my pants up high enough to draw my little gun. Obviously, I've given up the tactical advantage of a fast draw. I don't deny that this is true.
But at least, if I'm out of the house with my pants on, I'm carrying.
The Israelis train even their super-duper anti-terrorist squads to carry chamber-empty. They also train for it, and consequently, they are pretty durn swuft at racking and firing. They probebly don't give up more than a quarter to a half-second on my Condition One presentation.
My father has an old striker-fire Bauer .25. After a few years of carrying Condition One, he got to looking at how it was constructed, and began carrying it chamber empty. It just made him toooo nervous. But until he obtained a reliable P-32, that was his "always gun."
Do YOU carry an Always Gun? If not, why not?