Considering a SigSauer, tell me about 'em...

[leadcounsel]

I'm familiar with a lot of handguns, and have fired a Sig once...

I'm a fan of Glock, CZ, and XDs primarily. Not much experience with the Sigs...

Sigs just seem really complicated as far as names, features, designs, etc... I have to say I like the simplicity of the "XD 40" You know exactly what it is based on the name. Anyway, I digress. I wanna learn about Sigs tonight.

I've seen a Sig promotion for $100 rebate for military, so I'm considering one (keep in mind I can get a new Glock for around $450, and I like Glocks, so it will take some convincing).

I don't "need" a Sig to fill any certain role, other than maybe the .22 for plinking. But any caliber would be fine (9, 40, 45).

First, briefly tell me about these models and what distinguishes them (DAO, SA, polymer vs. steel vs. alloy, etc.); The P220, P226, P228, are eligible for the $100 rebate. The Sig556, 1911, and SSG 3000 and Tactical 2 are also eligible for $100 off.

The P239, P250, and SP202 are eligible for $50 rebates.

Also, can you give me a ballpark for a fair price for new Sigs of each model...

 

[doc540]

Just make sure the controls fit your hands and are intuitive.

I sold mine for an HK because the safety, decocker, and mag release were more "natural" to me.

My Sig was a good gun, shot straight, shot well.

 

[DRYHUMOR]

$100.00 of a new gun isn't bad, a little patience would net you more off of a used gun though.

Mine shoot well and feel well. The decocker is handy. One drawback is the extra magazines, if you buy new, are a bit pricey. Some have stamped slides, some milled.

The sights are good as well, I've got several different types. There are different ones available for some models, different blade heights.

The only sights I didn't care for where the ones on the .22 Mosquito, they were not rigidly in place. That pistol was very nice overall except for that.

Two of mine.

 

[goofy grape]

They are an excellent weapon and $100 off sure helps, because they're expensive weapons. I'm a fan of Glocks too. Fired an XD once and it just didn't suit me. 1911's is what I grew up shooting and that old Marine .45 of mine is my primary CC and HD weapon. Uncle Tim carried it in 'Nam and it served him well, it also serves me well. I've seen Sigs down here for 700-1100 bux and that's too darn much, when I can get a Glock for $480 and it's just as reliable and lighter too.

 

[dkk73]

...
I sold mine for an HK because the safety, decocker, and mag release were more "natural" to me.
...

Wow! I was debating whether to say the same when I came across this post.

If you are considering a Sig, make sure to check out HK's stuff. I have been really impressed by their quality of build and design. I've come to think they're honestly the highest quality pistol made.

The .22 Sig is very worth looking at in this day and age due to ammo cost issues, though.

 

[rhinoh]

Also, can you give me a ballpark for a fair price for new Sigs of each model...

That is hilarious, there are literally probably 100 or more different Sigs

I have 2, p228 and p220, and love them both, yes they are expensive. I'm trying real hard to buy a third, p238, just can't find it available anywhere except over list price

 

[Ala Dan]

Also, I have 2x West German models, a .45 caliber P220A, as well as a
9m/m P228. Never had an issue with either one; and NO they are not for sale
or trade~!

 

[stevek]

Have a P220R Carry, and a P229 in .22 with the 9mm conversion kit on order. Great pistols.

 

[joeturner]

I have a 229 SAS in 9mm. Accurate without effort, soft shooting and very balanced. If it fits your hand, shooting one is the only sales pitch it will ever need.

 

[benderx4]

Try to find a range with rentals and shoot as many guns as possible. Personally, I could never grow enamored with the Sig trigger and their control locations. Also, you can search and find many threads of late regarding the quality of "American-made" Sigs.

Having said all that, the German made Sigs are outstanding weapons used by military and police forces all over the world.

Personally, I prefer the trigger, control location, grip ergos, and build quality of the HK.

 

[wbwanzer]

Here's my P229 in 9mm. I love this gun. It came with the Truglo TFO sights and the previous owner had the slide and all mags done in NP3. I don't think I'll ever let this one go.

 

[mongo4567]

It is just personal preference, but I really don't like the trigger, controls, or the weight. Try to visit a place that will let you dry fire them and work the controls; better yet fire a friends or rent one at the range.

For larger sized autos I like the Glock, HK, 1911 (esp Kimber), and Beretta.

 

[The Lone Haranguer]

My experience with SIGs is with the "classic" German-made P-series and one 1911. Pros (of the P-series): accuracy, reliability, decocker system, customer service. Cons: hand fit (excessive trigger reach), long DA pull. This is an individual thing and may not apply to you. The 1911, on the other hand, was egregious. To their credit, they did promptly repair it when it broke and replaced it after the third repair, but I would rather not have had to use their customer service.

If it fits your hand, IMO you will not go wrong with a SIG based on the "classic" design. I rather fancy a P220 SAO myself.

 

[sigman]

They are just plain sexy !!

Yes ! I think all Sigs have a certain alure to them that goes beyond just their appearence .They are extremely reliable,and accurate.Of course,for durability,the Glock is better.But i would NEVER expose or treat my pet Sigs to the harshness and rigors of ANY sort of abuse !

I like the fact that the world's best elite forces and private security perssonnel carry Sigs also.

The P 220 in .45 is pure perfecion.

 

[Pilot]

Great guns, I just don't like the high bore axis. Plus, the decocker position is different than what I am used to, but that's a personal thing. If you get used to Sigs, its fine. You really can't go wrong, just try to shoot one before you buy and see if you like them. My P228 is a fine gun, but it sits in the safe as my CZ PCR suits my needs better for a compact 9MM.

 

[SigP229R]

I have a 229 in .40 and it is very accurate and I also own a P6 9mm they are my daily carry. If you are going to consider one look around on some of the auction sights and you should be able to find some CPO'S for a lot less than retail price. Sure they are used but sig has gone over them and replaced anything that was worn prior to placing them on the market. Also check top gun supply they have some 228's comning in fron Zurich right now and they will have a rather good price on them. Top Gun is aces to do business with also. Good luck in whatever you choose. CPO stands for Certified Pre Owned.

 

[Chris Plitt]

Across the board, for a new Sig on standard retail (with the exception of the 1911s, .380s, p250, and the 556 pistol) you are looking at $675-$900. I sell them for about $725 (p220, p226, p229) and on the p239 I run about $650. For the .380s I run from $525-650 and the P250 is on sale right now for $489 (normally $600), and thats with night sights. PM me if you are looking for anything special.

 

[sigman]

Avoid the new P250.....

there's too many negative posts on here about this new model.
It's suppose to be a "chamelian " of some sorts so that you can interchange calibers.But at the cost of doing such a " Frankenstein " operation,you can just buy another gun in the new caliber that you're striving for !
They are not to reliable in cycleing,which to me ,spells " death wish " if you're staking your life on it in a combat situation !

P.S. excuse my misspelling on the " changing lizard " !

 

[gc70]

Sigs are high quality, well made guns. The biggest difference between Sig and other brands is that the classic P-series models (P220, P225, P226, P228, P229, and P239) are typically traditional DA/SA designs with a frame-mounted decocker just behind the trigger. If you like that location for the decocker, Sigs are great - if not, Sigs are probably not for you.

 

[DFW1911]

Re: the P250, I have one and have had no problems with it whatsoever. I have hundreds of rounds through it of various manufacturers and bullet types and it has cycled just fine every time.

I will not, however, be changing any part of it: I like it the way it is. The whole modular concept isn't a favorite of mine...too much many and too many chances to make a mistake of some sort.

I have many Sigs and they are very good firearms indeed, just make sure you find one that fits your hand right and balances well.

 

[sigman]

i like the CZ P-01 compact 9 MM

If you want another choice in 9 MM compact look into this model.
There's ALOT of good threads on this pistol.
A Sig is the best choice,but this EZ is a very,very close second !

 

[smallbore]

I own a P232 (.380) & love it. Have shot a few in 9 (228/239) & 40 (226/239). They functioned flawlessly and are easy to operate/break down for cleaning. My buddy bought a 239 in 9mm & loves it.

 

[Chris Plitt]

there's too many negative posts on here about this new model.
It's suppose to be a "chamelian " of some sorts so that you can interchange calibers.But at the cost of doing such a " Frankenstein " operation,you can just buy another gun in the new caliber that you're striving for !
They are not to reliable in cycleing,which to me ,spells " death wish " if you're staking your life on it in a combat situation !

P.S. excuse my misspelling on the " changing lizard " !

I'm sorry, but as far as reliability goes, it is on par with just about everything else. I've done over 2500rds through mine without a hiccup. Don't believe everything you read in the magazines. Also, I don't know what dealers in your area charge for the upgrades, but I offer them for $275 a piece... tell me what Glock, Sig, Smith, Ruger, anything you can get for that price that is backed by a big name. Your entry CPO Sig classic is $500 and all of the M&Ps are roughly the same price. Also, you can't beat the highest capacity 9mm on the market! 20+1 P250 Full Size... yeeeahhh...

 

[Jed Carter]

I currently own a P226 .40S&W/.357SIG, P232 .380, P239 .357SIG and a SIG556. If I could only own 1 it would be the P226 with the Tritium sights and no rail. It is as simple to operate as just pull the trigger, has a stout DA trigger but a sweet SA. Safe reliable and very accurate, ugly enough to be a good looking "weapon". Everyone should own a P226 in any caliber, kinda like everyone should own a 1911. Remember SIG's are habit forming... but they won't stunt your growth.

 

[LancerMW]

i have a P220 and GSR(1911) both are excellent guns!