Dad's Take (WWII Vet) on the Nuke

Status
Not open for further replies.
My $.02

My dad served in The War. He died in '99 at 87. I had an uncle who was a chemistry PhD who worked @ Los Alamos (birthplace of Fat Man and Little Boy) although he never could tell me exactly what he did there, of course. I'm a war baby, born in '42 and mother & I spent the first 3 yrs of my life @ her parents'--this was pretty normal given the conditions.

The ONE thing I don't like abt. nuclear weapons is the genetic toll they take on the next generation, and the ones after that, who had nothing to do with the conflict. That is the basic difference as I see it between Dresden on the one hand, and Hiroshima/Nagasaki on the other. When the fires were out in Dresden, that was it, the damage was over. No one born later in Dresden was born genetically damaged, crippled, deformed, etc.

Now, having said that, in 1945 we were fighting for the survival of our civilization, against an implacable enemy. We used the best weapon we could lay our hands on to stop that enemy cold. That's all.
 
grampster

If not for those two bombs, the inhabitants of this wonderful web site would be an entirely different crew of people. Or maybe THR would not even exist at all.

Very true, had we not seen the chaos and destruction the nukes could cause we might have been more ready to use them. (Though we probably should have used them in North Korea so we wouldn't have this current mess. Or mabee we could have stoped when the Chinese asked us to.) We might have nuked Oleg Volk's parents in WW3 and he would have never been able to start this great site. (And give us some great photos as well.) :)
 
The only thing Truman did wrong, was not to wait till we had about 30 of those bombs, then drop them all the same day. Japan needed it, And the rest of the world should take the lesson. Cant stand bledin' hearts! :fire:


I'm still mad about Pearl Harbor! :fire:

Dang it yes it was right!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
 
My take on it is simple.

It began and ended on these two vessels:
980622-N-7749B-001_screen.jpg

Uss Arizona Memorial with USS Missouri being readied to dock in the background


Someone walks up behind you and whips out his switchblade. He then takes said dagger and jams it into your back destroying a kidney and severing some juicy blood vessels.

With great effort you roll over from your position on the ground and draw your 357. A far superior weapon - and you empty it into your attacker's body.

I have a real problem seeing the nice oriental gentleman with the switchblade as the victim just because he attacked a person with eventual access to better and more decisive means to defend himself.

If even THAT simple analogy is too tough for your liberal inlaws, perhaps they need pictures to follow along with...


The only thing that made the thugs in fancy hats stand here
surrender.jpg


Were the common gentlemen pictured here in flight suits
_36577831_crew300.jpg

It's unfortunate the aformentioned thugs needed persuasion from above.
nagasaki.jpg


and below...
A-bomb%20scene.jpg


All of the above would have been avoided had said thugs kept their aircraft from visiting us unanounced... Pearl_Harbor.jpg
...and killing our men in their bunks early one Sunday morning.
976-FlagsIn_Closeup.jpg
 
Dad was a gunner on B-17. Thankfully, he got to ship out from Okinawa and got married back in the USA on August 27. Celebrating the 60'th wedding anniversary this month. And is firmly convinced the big bombs were the right thing to do.
 
Greybeard, my father, too, is celebrating his 60th wedding in October. He flew half his missions (31) as B17 waist gun and half as bomb toggelier. Three years ago, I had the wonderful experience of flying aboard Aluminum Overcast, a restored B17, with him. It was a moving experience seeing Dad become a young man again.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top