Doesn't anyone have a sporting shotgun any more?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Hmm, there have been times on a dove hunt when I was wishing for a belt fed full auto. LOL
They will never make anything like the AA-12 civilian legal, but I have read about them.
They have a recoil reduction system that makes it have 10% of the kick of a model with out the reduction system.
I saw a video of some guy firing it upside down with one hand.

I will stick with my 870.

I was at Bass Pro the other day and I saw the most beautiful Wingmaster .410,
I am not usually a .410 shooter, but I wouldn't have refused this as a gift!
Too much money though...

When I drive into town, I see so many pigeons sitting just inside the town limits, and I whisper to them "Make one false move, and your mine!"
 
Last edited:
Two others come to mind, the Franchi SPAS-12, and the (so-called) "Street Sweeper".

And I may be wrong on this, but I beleive that the Benelli M4 was designed from the ground up as a tactical shotgun. Though they do share similarities to their cousins. In fact they are gas operated, while all other Benellis are recoil operated.

Wyman
 
I can't find myself getting enthusiastic about the new shotgun market. The cheapest mainstream-brand autoloaders don't start coming in until you get past the $600 mark. (Synthetic 11-87. Maybe I'm not giving the Mossberg 935 a fair shake, but I don't know anything about them.) Interesting pumps start in the $400-500 range. (Browning BPS.) I'm way, way too much of a cheapskate and utilitarian to consider any double-barrel that's worth owning.

Now, the USED market is another matter, but since those guns are, by definition, not part of a currently mass-produced product line, you can't the same results from one to another with sufficient regularity to warrant lots of discussion.
 
I currently have a Winchester 1300 .12gauge 28" vent rib , screw-in chokes .
Shiney stock , pretty gun .
I had a couple of those H&R - New England Firearms Single Shots and I've got to say , they grow on you !
I would not mind having one of those in every gauge available .
They are so easy to carry and use , they are really fun guns .
I just noticed on their site that they no longer make them in 16 gauge . That's a pity .
Had a Maverick 18" and a Mossberg 590 , whatever the proper number is for the military version , Nice guns , miss those too .
To me Shotguns are like women , I love them all !
 
Pete409 said:
It sounds like YOU are the one with the "attitude" problem. The sporting shotgun users simply want a forum of their own. Perhaps if the sporting shotgunners felt more welcome on this site, they might post more here instead of going to another site. Of course, it doesn't appear that it would bother you any if they did leave.
As I noted in my previous post I am a sporting shotgunner, been a member here since 02 and have never felt other than welcome. Unlike you I do not believe the number of threads on the shotgun forum justifies splitting into different segments like the handgun forums.

I support a comprehensive shotgun forum not one that segments members unnecessarily or because elitists feel it is "disappointing" to rub shoulders with those having a tactical interest.
 
It sounds like YOU are the one with the "attitude" problem. The sporting shotgun users simply want a forum of their own. Perhaps if the sporting shotgunners felt more welcome on this site, they might post more here instead of going to another site. Of course, it doesn't appear that it would bother you any if they did leave.

Pete - As I mentioned earlier, try Shotgunworld.com, uplandjournal.com, among others. IMO, I do not believe there would enough traffic here for a sporting-specific section. I could be wrong, and hope so, just don't see it. It appears the majority of new shotgun purchases, at least since the
election, have been Mossbergs and Remington pumps intended for HD. Nothing wrong with that, they're are cheaper to buy and easier to shoot well compared to handguns and most of the folks posting seems to be new to shotguns, if not guns in general, so a place to get questions answered is OK. Which is why I frequent the other forums previously mentioned. Shotgunworld breaks things down by types of shooting disciplines, even by brands of guns - so that might be something you would want to investigate to see if it meets more of your wants and needs.
 
I don't have much regard for the attitude among certain shotgunners who believe that discussions of personal protection and well being are beneath their exalted status.

Personal protection, OK. I just get danged tired of hearing about pistol grips and flash lights. :rolleyes: The tacticool crowd doesn't seem to value light weight and proper balance. 30 lbs of CRAP hanging off a gun might be tacticool, but it's not practicool. They act like I can't possibly defend myself with my coach gun, only two rounds, how the hell am I going to kill a zombie that takes 4 rounds of 00 to put down? 20 gauge? MY GAWD MAN, you'd DIE with that POS. :rolleyes:

I just think anyone who thinks they need a military weapon for home defense is a bit off his rocker. Some of 'em act like they're just praying for the chance to kill some one so they can use the cork screw on the picatinny rail to open the campaign to celebrate.

Yeah, I'll start skipping over the obvious "defense" threads from now on.
 
I don't have much regard for the attitude among certain shotgunners who believe that discussions of personal protection and well being are beneath their exalted status.
I doubt they are against self defense, it's probably just that they want to discuss hunting shotguns.

pistol grips and flash lights
I don't have experiance with pistol gripped shotguns, but I doubt they'd be pleasent to shoot. They might also not point as well. Flashlights, however, I can see a use for. (I probably wouldn't use one, but I can see why someone would)
 
I have 2 shotguns...A Maverick 88 w/18-1/2" barrel...HomeLand Security shotgun

Mossberg 500 28" mod choke barrel for "Woods-N-Water" work.

Used to just have the Maverick 88 and I would swap barrels depending on need of the day.
 
I have to laugh. This thread has taken an unexpected turn; all I was trying to do is get some of the folks with sporting interest to post more so I would have more threads that interest me on the forum. I don't have a problem if people want to post threads talking about tactical or HD shotguns.

What makes me laugh is that the topic of the thread is clearly meant to start discussions on sporting guns but a large number of the replies are folks posting their pics of HD shotguns and discussing clearly HD and tactical issues.

Maybe the fact that those of us interested in sporting shotguns can't even start a thread without it being hijacked by the tactical gun enthuisist supports having a seperate forum topic for tactical and sporting?
 
Re: Shotgun Forum

WE don't need another sub-forum.
Too many sub-forums clutter up a site and makes it difficult to conduct searches for information,

Here is the the bottom line, The Great Equipment is real, and it does not matter whether one is into clays games, self defense, hunting or...

I remember when there was no THE Great Equipment Race, which means I was there when TGER started up, picked up a head of steam and arrived like a train wreck.

There is difference in being a Shotgunner, and someone that owns a shotgun. There always has been, and always will be.

Heck I was not the only one for example that ran a bone stock Win SX1 for serious Skeet, Live Pigeon, Columbaire, Gun Games (Before 3 Gun come to be) quail, doves, ducks, geese, deer , rabbit , squirrel, home/business defense, predator control , 5 stand, Sporting Clays and even Trap, which is not my game...you name it.

Folks did the same things with Win Mod 12 and Ithaca 37s, including using them in Combat and in Police Work.

Rudy Etchen used the same 870 40 years later to win again Trap Championships.

I do not care what your flavor is, you cannot buy skill and targets.
I have missed a clay bird on a skeet field with shotguns that cost up to $100,000.
I missed a quail with a $53,000 shotgun too.

I felled a Live Pigeon worth $2500 with that Field Grade, bone stock, SX1.
Then again I have seen expensive "birds" felled with H&R Toppers, and JC Higgin pump gun too.

It is rumored some of my Mentors might have been Hustlers.
Nah, some folks just put money in that cigar box for lessons is all - Mentors

I will neither confirm or deny I know anything about that, though I will admit having a fondness for cigar boxes all my life.

Do you folks realize whom all is a member of THR, and breaking it down further, whom are members that use Shotguns?
It would blow your mind.
Name a use for a shotgun, and they are members.

Another thing, do you want to know one reason some of these members and known trainers, instructors, competitors and others either do not post or become a member?

Well for one, their time is valuable and being on a forum not only cuts into their time, it does not put money in their pocket, so they can do the work they do.

Second, they have respect for others that train, teach, instruct, compete and whatever else other disciplines a shotgun is used for. There is no "elitist" attitude, instead respect.

They do not want to be around folks that have the attitudes they see on fora.
They genuinely care about folks getting the correct basic fundamentals, and then advancing. TGER is one huge stumbling block that prevents them from getting through to people.
So they spend their time wisely assisting those that have a willingness and really want "it".

Defensive Shotgun, or Clays, it does not matter, these folks are not going to fight TGER and other attitudes on a forum, when they can be treated with respect in a civil manner elsewhere.

Umm yes, since I am a member of some fora where one has to be a member to even read the forum, some of these folks are present, and do post.
These forums will eat you alive if pull some behaviors as is pulled on other forums.


Dead serious when I share a shotgunner that teaches defensive shotgun use, will get lessons from someone that shoots sporting clays, and vice-versa.
Both will go see another trainer about Carbines, and Handguns .

TGER did a lot of damage during its inception and continues to now.
Internet is a faster means of communication. What is communicated can be both good, or bad.

There are a lot students looking for a Guru, and Gurus looking for students.
This circle jerk is about stroking egos, and money.

Folks interested in shotguns around here, do not need separate forums, instead they need to change themselves.

Dead Serious again.
It was learned Life has not been kind to me, and I was offered a shotgun for defensive use, I turned it down.
I was also offered a shotgun for bird hunting, and I turned it down.
And I was offered a shotgun for clay games, and I turned it down.
Free shotguns and I turned them down.
Same thing happened with a AR and a handgun.

No thanks. I have done my thing, and Internet has soured me big time as it has other members you no longer see post, and others folks did not realize were the instructors, professionals, trainers, and competitors they were.

I have quit doing a lot of what I used to publicly, and keep doing less publicly.
Now behind the monitor, I always have done things.

But hey, maybe someday I will get the gumption to fix a few things I need to fix on the one shotgun I have left, a youth single shot 20 ga. Heck, I might actually get the notion to actually shoot it.

Personally I kept hanging around assisting folk behind the monitor.
It was rare thing for me to miss the opening day of dove season, I have not bothered to get a hunting license in the last few years.
I have gone out to assist new folks and kids go dove hunting, still I had no desire to shoot, for me.
I felled a few for some kids, I promised them and some grandpa's that passed before they could take these kids out I would be there for the kids.

No, I had one last big shotgun shin dig that meant something to me. A Tribute if you will to Mentors, Elder and others , as a private range was closing.
Being the only one left alive from the old days, this role fell to me, as it was how it agreed to be.
"Last one out, turns out the lights".

Mentors, Elders, and these were interesting folks and my people.
They were Shotgunnners, and name a use for a shotgun, and they had been there and done that.

Cast Iron Skillet, 8" one is what I have handy if someone comes in on me right now.
And since I spend most of my time in a restrictive setting where I cannot carry a concealed gun, I don't.
See, I really am big on Software, not hardware, always have been.
Some around here , like some Staff, think I have pushed the envelope a bit too far in this Software aspect.
Some are concerned, but I don't care anymore.
I was not supposed to live this long no way.

Some know a bit more about me and the running joke, is not funny.
This being if some folks were to spend 30 min with me in doing some things I am familiar with, they would wet and soil themselves.
Oh, see, sometimes one cannot have a gun period, maybe not even a penknife.
You can have and use Software though...



You see, I burned my sanctioned cards, and some membership cards, when THE Great Equipment Race picked up more steam and I had had enough.
Others of my kind did the same the same after I did it. We went Rebel, Outlaw, Rogue, whatever you want to call it.

I have only been on public range a few times in decades.
Who knows how many times I have been in a gun store and someone invited me out to teach me skeet, or how to hunt doves, or ...

"Oh, well thanks, but no thanks I thought only LEO and Military could have shotguns" - I have replied.

No brag, just fact, I have dropped more shells than these folks have ever shot, and most likely more than some ever will.
Not my kind of people, they are into buying skill and targets,and not my way.

It is said, one teaches folks how to treat them...

Well some folks have paid attention and that is the reason some folks do not participate anymore, or as they once did.
I am one.

There is difference in a Shotgunner, and one that owns a shotgun...

Ya'll do as you wish, as I plan on doing as I wish with like kind.
 
Last edited:
Hinton, how much for the sandals?
Besides shotgunworld.com, try uplandjournal.com, doublegunshop.com, gunandgame.com, sportinggun.co.uk (for the British look at things), shootingsportsman.com, and shotgunsports.com

Yes, and/or come over and post in the HUNTING sub-forum on here once and awhile!
 
hinton03,

Post another Sporting thread, and it will run as you had hoped it would.

You can PM me anytime though I am not sure of my schedule in the near future.
Still there is another option or two I can assist with as well.
 
The closest thing I have to a tactical shotgun is an old 870 Exp. Mag. 12 ga. Note the black tactical Decelerator pad I put on it. Pretty good fit for a hand sanded job.

watermark.jpg

The other one is also a 28-incher, but it's a 28 ga. Guerini Woodlander. Weighs about 1.5 or 1.75 pounds less, too.

John

P.S. - Which mag extension is best for an old 870? Has this been asked before? :evil:
 
Don't hunt, don't like it and it's probably due to the fact that no one ever took the time to show me the way as a kid. However even at 49 years old I sure admire the firearms, stories, and brotherhood of those that do.

Just sayin.

Note the black tactical Decelerator pad I put on it.

Just put a decelerator pad on my 30-30 and here I thought it was due to the bum shoulder. Now I find out it's tactcal too?? Bonus!
 
I just get danged tired of hearing about pistol grips and flash lights.

Its funny...I used to get tired of hearing about chokes, proper ammo for taking down the latest game, turkey guns...field guns...etc., etc. :rolleyes:

The tacticool crowd doesn't seem to value light weight and proper balance. 30 lbs of CRAP hanging off a gun might be tacticool, but it's not practicool.

I have no problem with a "balanced" weapon and Ill admit, too much "crap" can become cumbersome. But, given the ambiguous nature of HD encounters (not all of them happen during the daytime and/or involve simply one individual), I see nothing wrong with adding certain accessories which give added control (such as a pistol grip...NOT PGO however) and/or add light (onboard white light systems) or any other items which may put the advantage into the hands of one defending his/her home. It is possible to utilize/justify certain accessories regardless of whether or not they are used by the "tactical" crowd.

Heck, even the "sporting" or "hunting" crowd could benefit from these accessories, given certain situations. There is no reason why one crowd cant learn from or gain ideas from the other.

In terms of weight/balance, well yeah..sometimes this stuff throws off the much coveted "balance." But, thats what practice is for and frankly, I dont think any loss of weapon balance is going to have much affect when adrenaline is pumping through someones system (ie., during an HD encounter for instance). Balance may have alot to do with sporting, hunting and target shooting, but (IMHO) when dealing with close encounters of the worst, most brutal kind well..... balance would probably be the least of concerns.

Frankly, I would rather haul around an 18" barreled shotty with a few accessories than deal with a field gun sporting a 26-28" barrel. But, this is just a preference, nothing more.

Personally, even though not a hunter or sportsman, I do enjoy learning as much as I can about shotguns and their range of use. Sure, I prefer certain topics, but I certainly appreciate any information I may glean from ANY shotgun/handgun related arenas.

Tactical, sporting, hunting, target shooting...regardless; any information is a good thing, is it not?
 
Last edited:
Tactical, sporting, hunting, target shooting...regardless; any information is a good thing, is it not?

Yep.
The problem still exists that folks do not want to learn or discuss, instead rationalize and qualify a shotgun platform and accessories.

Old School I am. Learn the correct basic fundamentals with a bone stock shotgun , with a full stock, with no PG, or anything else.

Anytime someone has a problem with shooting, it is always one or more of the basic fundamentals that needs to be addressed.

These basic fundamentals apply to clays, hunting and even self defense.

Folks buy shotguns, accessories and when they go see someone like Awerbuck, the real deal trainers and users don't have all that heat shield this and fuzzy dice that and...

Personally, a PG fore end impedes my ability to use a shotgun as they effective, versiltle weapon it is.
Ditto for AR type stocks.

My lessons were private, on a Hot Range, 3 Rules of Gun Safety , Big Boy Rules.
If the objective was "Survive" then I was to survive. Seriously, we did not us a start buzzer, as there is not "start buzzer" in real life.
My start might be the gunshot that hits the vehicle door ( wax bullets).

I will share a Carbine with a mag will hang up getting out of a vehicle , fast.
Later when PG forends came to be, these too will hang up, and they will break.

Mentors , on purpose would not let me have spare ammo, and often loaded the shotgun, and my sidearms.

Survive, was the objective.
I have busted barrels, and stocks, going after steel "threats", 3 D steel threats, and busting out a window , then going to town to kill a "driver" in a vehicle attempting to leave with a kidnapped person.


Re: Pistol Gripped Only (PGO).
I hate the damn things.
That said, I have had to carry one, as did my bodyguards. Also I have assisted with Armored Car Drivers that have to use this platform, qualify and re-qual with one.

I will start these ACD out with a bone stock, full stock, version of the PGO they are issued, and start with the basic fundamentals.
I mean all the back to eye dominance, using a BB Gun with no sights, primer only hulls, dummy shells to load, unload, and when we get to live fire, light target loads.

Work up to the issued 2 3/4" , nine pellet 00 buckshot issued load.

Then...we snag the issued gun, and go back to basics again, and address the limits and other challenges the PGO presents.

Again, primer only hulls, dummy shells, light loads...working back up to the issued buckshot load.

WE had an interesting thing happen with PG Fore ends, as we were messing with these when they came out.

Now all of us were old school , including the younger folks, and this includes ladies.
The girls said it did allow them to hold up a gun one handed, but, it held the gun up "wrong". Meaning, it was not as the correct basics were instilled in them.

Note: Lessons = training, Setups = stages.
There were no gun schools when I was coming up, so these terms are what I were raised with.

Bleh...The set up was, I was supposed to get a gun to a lady during a civil unrest.
The lady was 19 years old.
Damn fore end "caught" on the wheel of the vehicle of which I was sliding it under.

Another set up, this same 19 year is supposed to toss me a shotgun, and again the balance was off and this "toss" was whomper jawed.

We were not the only ones, as all of us had problems. WE are so old school, these new fangled guns impede and limit what we are so used to doing with a bone stock gun.

Shooting port side up, port side down, and back and over our head.
Dang PG messes us up.
Heck, I hate to say this but I had better hits with a PGO shooting back and over my head ( I was being extracted and shooting as I was being extracted).


Yes, it is all good, just dad-burn it! I am so old school and do not want folks to learn on a crutch, no matter they are going to use a shotgun for.

If one loses that crutch, they will fall down.

Here is another "Shocker", The 28 ga is used by a lot of known instructors, and other instructors as well. A lot of our members use this gun as a teaching tool.

Did ya know the 28 ga is used to teach defensive shotgunning?
Yep.
Mentors were doing this when I was a brat.
And...the 28 ga has been the defensive shotgun for folks and stopped threats.

A 28 ga is .550, which is not far off from a .54 cal which has a history of killing man, and animal.

Did I mention the 28 ga slugs?

It might surprise folks how handy and versatile a bone stock 28 ga pump, even with a fixed choke 26" barrel , really is.

Never mess with a old man with a well worn 28 ga 870 pump, bone stock. He is one with that gun , as evidenced by the quail, doves, wabbits, squirrels, ducks, geese, deer and...we won't get into the threat he stopped against multiple VCAs, but he did.

See, my problem is, care.
So when Dave Williams shares about the Swamp Shoot, and what works...
When Gordon , Lee Lapin and others attend a Awerbuck class...

Others attend a class by Clint Smith ( who btw keeps a single shot 20 ga bedside)...

I pay attention and am old enough to see correct basic fundamentals when they are shared, or I see pictures, or video.

I wish folks would just go see folks in whatever they want to do about a shotgun, get lessons and learn before they buy a gun.

WE have folks out there that are going to get not only themselves injured and dead, those around them too if something goes down,
This bothers me...
 
I think I'll take a crack at this...
I own a "sporting" shotgun and a HD shotgun.

Sporting shotgun is a Benelli Nova.
Its weighs about 7 metric tons, is 3 miles long, and very clumsy to swing around in a small appartment if something goes bump in the night.
It is currently February, therefore not deer season here in NC, so I have no need to discuss my Benelli at this time.

However, there is no "closed season" on Home Defense when you live about a 1/4 mile from a less than reputable area (college town... ghetto butts up against the campus living) so my 18" barrel Rem 870 "zombie killer" complete with its tac light, side saddle, and pistol grip stock does see alot more use at the range, and I like to see what other people are doing with theirs.
Both of the scatterguns, unmodded 870...
P1010601.jpg
 
Two others come to mind, the Franchi SPAS-12, and the (so-called) "Street Sweeper".

I forgot about the street sweeper. :eek:

I found this about the SPAS:
In 1983, the gun was introduced to the United States, where it was marketed as a sporting shotgun to help bypass laws that would normally label it as illegal for private ownership. As a result, the SPAS acronym officially stands for "Sporting Purpose Automatic Shotgun". However, military-oriented features like a heavy heat shield for sustained fire increase the weight of the weapon to the point where it can become unwieldy for hunting or competition shooting. For this reason, there exist popular reinterpretations of the acronym, such as "Special Purpose Automatic Shotgun" or "Special Purpose Assault Shotgun".

I had never read about the SPAS-12 before thanks for spreading the knowledge. :)
 
WOW!

I thought this would be informative reading, turned into gossip and quibbling.
I enjoy shooting shotguns, but.....the Beretta 1200/1 FP models kinda' kick a tad more than I "really" enjoy.

I bought a Saiga 410 for fun and really enjoy it on clays; but.......... nothing is more enjoyable to me than a 40 yard left to right shot on a dove cooking with the wind from my 686 12ga.

I sold the 2 SPAS I bought because I just didn't like them as much as the guy was offering, but.......glad I got rid of them when I did.

Shooting my beater 11-87 w/ 9 shot mag at snow geese during the COLGS is about as tactical as I roll on a regular basis, but......... if this season (like last) gets missed because of work, Oh well.

I like the forum to be expanded, but....anyone who likes a shotgun ( or SHOTTIE:barf:) is alright in my book and having any intelligent interaction about fine doubles or heatshields for a mavric 88 is ok with me.
I'm here to learn things which I don't know and help when I can.
 
The closest thing to a "tactical" type shotgun I have is an old Westpoint (Stevens) 12 ga. pump cut to 20 inches with no bead that was used as a slug gun by a Virginia hillbilly.:)

I love that old gun.

I have an old, ivery good condition Stevens 16 ga. double and two Of the NEF pumps that are loathed, it seems, by some folks. :what:

All basically straight up non tactical. I am looking to buy a used Remington 1100 real soon. It will remain a sporting piece.

Tactical ,to me, is between your ears. My humble opinion, of course.:D

My rifles are another story...:evil:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top