FAL vs G3

[Destructo6]

It's generally cheaper and easier to build a good FAL clone than it is to build a G3. The FAL is basically screwed together, while the G3 is pressed, pinned, and welded.

Personally, I prefer the G3's ergonomics to the FAL's.

If I were you, I'd buy a FAL first, then part together a G3 and send the bits to a competent HK smith and have him build it your way. Adding the G3 paddle mag release is usually only about $90 if done during a build and worth every penny.

Of course, the JLD HK clones are pretty reasonable and have a good reputation.

 

[Feanaro]

The only thing you CAN'T argue with is the ridiculous location of the charging handle on the G3...come on...at the front of the barrel???

It seems like an odd place but I haven't encountered any difficulty with it. I can even do it prone without a problem, though I am a little long of arm. It does slow mag changes down a tiny bit if you operate it the way you're supposed to. And it is a little odd as far as the manual of arms but I don't see why people hem and haw so much over it.

 

[Risasi]

Kris

Nope,

I love the fact that the charging handle is topside. Means I can keep my trigger hand where it belongs, and slap it with my "wrong hand".

 

[Preacherman]

I had the opportunity to use both the FAL (the South African R1 variant) and the G3 (the Portuguese Army issue rifle) on the range in South Africa. Comparing them head-to-head, I found the FAL to be superior in ergonomics, more accurate, and a LOT more reliable - but then, the ex-Portuguese rifles we were shooting had probably not received the armory maintenance and regular overhauls that our issue R1's had been getting. I never saw a NIB G3 to compare to my NIB-issue R1.

 

[iamkris]

Well, it's true, some guys (or girls) like blondes, some brunettes...

Personal preference and it's hard to argue with that. The important thing is you're shooting a MBR!!

 

[bow4828]

I am not very well versed in G3's,But I have build and owned a few FAL's now.Love Em!Simlpe design.easy to build and change out stuff to get the look and feel You want,Very reliable.One thing nobody mentioned yet is;the FAL can also be set-up with forward assist.Not usually nessisary but nice to have none the less.I also like the C-H in closer.Less hand movement to operate.