Federal Cartridge under legal fire

Status
Not open for further replies.

powerstrk

Member
Joined
Dec 25, 2002
Messages
98
Location
Orlando,FL
Injured big-game hunter takes aim at bullet manufacturers
Howie Padilla, Star Tribune

Published April 16, 2003 LION16


When a professional big-game hunter on safari in Africa shot a charging lion from about 30 yards away, he expected that the cat would die, or at least be stopped.

Instead, the lion mauled the marksman.

It wasn't bad aim, but bad bullets that allowed the lion to take Rolf Rohwer temporarily out of the hunting game, according to a federal lawsuit filed Tuesday against the bullet manufacturers, one of which is the Federal Cartridge Co. of Anoka.

Rohwer, of Scotland, is a wildlife biologist who has more than 30 years of African hunting and wildlife management experience, according to his Web site. He suffered permanent damage to his legs, arm and back, said his attorney, Louis Franecke. Rohwer was trying a new type of ammunition on Aug. 11, 2000, the day of the attack, he said.

"We think the company makes good ammunition, but not all of it is good for every application," Franecke said from his office in San Rafael, Calif. "Therein lies the problem. This bullet is not suitable for all big game."

Although the bullet might be good for hunting the majority of big game animals -- including rhinoceros, elephant, buffalo and hippopotamus -- the lion's thin skin allowed the bullet to pass through with minimal damage, he said. On a thicker-skinned animal, the bullet -- a .458 Winchester Magnum, 500 grain Trophy Bonded Bear Claw -- would expand, killing the animal quickly, according to the suit.

A lion shot with the bullet is still a dangerous and "harmful beast capable of causing severe personal injuries to human for a substantial period of time," the suit said.

Officials at Federal Cartridge hadn't seen the suit and were unable to comment on it, said Rod Bitz, spokesman for Alliant Techsystems Inc., Federal's parent company. The other company named is Trophy Bonded Bullets Inc. of Houston, according to the suit.

"This bullet is not suitable for killing a charging lion," Franecke said. "It's suitable for killing a lion over a period of time."

Before the lion reached Rohwer, who has since returned to hunting, he shot it a second time, Franecke said.

"The lion died basically while chewing on my client."

Howie Padilla is at [email protected].

:what:
 
30 years experience in being a kitty snack?? What would possess this person to make a switch like that and not test it out before taking it afield? Gee, if he wins, I'm going to tell one of my hunting buddies who shot 3 deer in one morning with his 243-all the bambi's scampered off as if nothing happened. Turned out he was using Federal full metal jacket loads. Maybe he can sue as well because the deer didn't drop in their tracks:rolleyes:
What a maroon.
 
Hunting can a dangerous undertaking.
Hunting dangerous game on the same footing and at close ranges is always a dangerous undertaking. They don't always just up an fall dead in their tracks when shot and even when shot very well.
And...he went back a hunting did he not?
Federal's attorney will have a field day with Rolf and Loius.
(Unless they use one of the same ones the tobacco company used)



S-
 
Federal .458 Winchester Magnum, 500 grain Trophy Bonded Bear Claw eh? Hmmmm, let's see...

Federal Load No. Factory Primer No. Caliber Bullet Weight
Grains / Grams Bullet style
P458T2 215 458 Win. Magnum 500 / 32.4 Trophy Bonded Bear Claw


Velocity in Feet Per Second (To Nearest 10 FPS)
Muzzle 100 Yds 200 Yds 300 Yds 400 Yds 500 Yds
2090 1870 1660 1480 1310 1180

Energy in Foot Pounds (To Nearest 5 Foot-Pounds)
Muzzle 100 Yds 200 Yds 300 Yds 400 Yds 500 Yds
4850 3870 3065 2420 1915 1550

Looks like a wee bit of overkill...
 
No mention of shot placement.

Isn't it the general consensus that at that distance, the only sure stopper is a CNS hit?

Dude also forgot to sue the safari outfitter and the PH.
 
some of these guys that ask the question what round will stop bears or whatever...they should certainly take note of this.
 
Maybe after this big game hunter wins his lawsuit, wives and husbands of police officers who shot at and were subsequently injured/killed by criminals firing back should sue ammunition manufacturers as well.

Then, after that, the family of alleged criminals who died (prior to trial) in the commission of a crime should sue ammunition manufacturers for failing to ensure that police and other citizens were able to kill them. :scrutiny:

Shakespear had it right. Kill all the lawyers!
 
So why did he take a round that sounds as though it was designed for a very tough, large critter like Buffalo and use it on a much smaller, softer critter? Is it a surprise that a bullet designed to hold together when hitting a tough-skinned, large critter doesn't expand when it hits a soft-skinned, small critter?
Sounds more like a failure of logic in the trigger activation computer
Amen to that. Unfortunately, it sounds to me that this Darwin-award nominee is likely to have already had offspring.
 
I am not a big game hunter but....

it is obvious to me he was using the wrong ammo. I guess he did not learn anything in the past 30 years.....chris3
 
Well, it says he shot a charging lion, but was the lion charging directly at him? If that were the case and the round passed end-to-end completely through the lion, maybe he has a case. If the lion was shot at an angle or from the side and no bones were hit, then tough noogies. That kinda horsepower behind a 500 grain .458 slug and that sucker's gonna pass on by.
 
Kill the lawyers? If some jerk didn't come up with the idea of the lawsuit, no lawyer would have taken it. There are some lawyers that keep people like me and you out of jail everyday for self-defense. Blame lawyers, Jews, blacks, whites, etc. but never blame pure idiocy. :rolleyes: You're hunting lion for goodness' sake, you might die.
 
Um, as far as I know Federal Cartridge Company has made no promises as to whether their bullets would stop a charging lion from mauling you.....:rolleyes:

I see no legal writing on the box that says anything to the effect of, "If you use our ammunition, you will not be in danger while hunting African lions."
 
I thought the whole charm of hunting dangerous game was that sometimes you get the game, and sometimes the game gets you...
 
Federal's lawyer:

"Your Honor, we demand that the plaintiff produce the carcass of the alleged lion for independent forensic examination. We further demand that said lion carcass be produced fully intact without any tampering so that said independent forensic examination may be conducted without any question of tampering. If plaintiff cannot produce an intact carcass of said lion, we ask that he be cited for tampering with evidence and prosecuted."

Actually, a Trophy Bonded Bear Claw should expand on a lion. I wonder if the bullet was recovered, or if the guy used a Trophy Bonded Sledgehammer Solid instead.

But even a solid in .458 caliber should make a kitty mighty sick if shot lengthwise . . . provided the bullet is placed correctly.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top