similar circumstances here....I started carrying in church a year and a half ago. Every Sunday. I may forget my Bible (well we have them in the pew), but not my piece.
The way I see it, there's a lot of hatred and anemosity towards Christians....just look how many churches have been burned or shot up in the last three years....it's upwards of thirty. Compare that to attacks on synogogs an mosques., which are at about two each. The more faithfully Christians represent God's standards to the world and speak out against evil....the more hatred they will generate. John Ch 15 bares witness to this. So every Sunday I go and identify myself publically with a hated group of people, which puts my person and my family at greater risk than any other time of the week when we annonomously blend in. You better believe I carry in church.
Our church started out on the security path in earnest about a year ago, when some pedophile type tried to grab a kid from the church down the road during the period in between the service and Sunday school hour. Their pastor wrote a letter to every church in the region detailing the event and asking others to keep an eye on the little ones.
So we have a pseudo security team and several disjointed efforts under way.
We have an usher at each entrance on Sunday morning now. And on each one but the main entrance, the doors remain locked and the usher opens the door, greets the people and hands them a bulletin. Most people don't even realize that the door is locked. So if the usher sees some one coming with a gun, they simply don't open the door.
Each usher and each Sunday school classroom and the nursury have a walkie talkie type handset. One guy is a floater and is responsible to run down to help out if he is paged. The worst "incident" we've had was a grandfather who didn't attend and was unknown to the nursury workers, came to pick up jr. So they paged the usher and he came down and explained what the policy was and that it was to protect the kids. After a brief conversation, it was obvious that grandpa was legit. and he took Jr. home. He seemed confused by the whole affair, but understood that it was well meant.
We are very concerned about getting stuck in the middle of a custody dispute, where a non-custodial parent might try to snatch their kid while the estranged spouse is upstairs in the service. Our policy is that only the person who drops the child off can pick them up. But were not exactly dealing with trained/paid professionals here. Like many churches, we're doing well just to get enough volunteers to run the many programs going on.
Fortunately, the chief of police from the town up the road is a member and our elders have tapped his expertise to come up with some good plans and ideas. We just recently went with keyless entry swipe cards, as it seemed that after twenty years, every body and their brother had a key to the building.
One big concern is that on week days the secretary and the custodian are the only ones in the building....which is fairly large. The concern is that someone might target the secretary. Fortuantely, as the church has more and more going on, there are fewer times when the building isn't more occupied.
Had some knuckle head who tagged along to youth group break in with his buddy and steal the youth pastors bow (we have an archery set up in the gym). They even started to paint a swastika on the youth center wall. As is often the case, the kind of kids who do this type of stuff aren't to bright and they were caught trying to sell the bow two days later. And though the church didn't really want to make a big deal out of prosecuting Beavus and Co., the state automatically refers all of these type of incidents for review for possible prosecution as a hate crime.
So that's some thoughts on our disjointed efforts. I'd say on any given Sunday there are at least four or five men packing in the congregation. It is all low key and is rarely discussed from the "pulpet" though, as there are certainly some members who have pacifist leanings, or even a few anti's. Our leadership doesn't want to make the "gun thing" an issue that might turn people off from the primary message and mission of the church.
Now a funny anecdote. Our senior pastor is an avid hunter and fisherman and has his carry permit. When another brother learned that I had obtained my permit, he mentioned it to pastor. The following Sunday, I was turned around leaning over the back of my chair to talk to someone and my sweater slipped up over my holster. At the same time, a lady who was looking my way had an odd expression on her face. I thought for sure I had been made. Well a day or two later I was talking to pastor and he say's "hey I heard you brought a gun to church. My wife was at a meeting and said that all the lady's were talking about it". My heart sank...but it turns out that he was just pulling my leg, having heard that I now had my permit.
Christmas Eve. we had a children's program and afterward when I greeted our senior pastor, who is very much a mentor and father figure to me, I gave him a big bear hug, and inadvertantly flipped his sport jacket up over the full frame .45 he was carrying OWB. Fortunately he was standing in a doorway and was able to discreatly fix his "wardrobe casualty". Hey, you know what they say about paybacks. I told my wife later in the day and we both agreed that it made us feel loved, to know that our shepherd was prepared to put his life on the line for the little sheep.
That's life at this end. I need to step up to the plate and get more involved, as our "security team", which is primarily a collateral duty for the ushers, is kind of a cluster.
Church is one of the only places that I would run to the threat instead of away from it.
My thoughts exaclty.
As for the Christian ethics of personal defense, there is some very good logic and reasoning to be found in the section of the Westminster Confession of Faith were a Christian's moral OBLIGATION to resist evil is addressed.